StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Advantages and Disadvantages of Living in a Capitalist vs a Socialist Society - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Advantages and Disadvantages of Living in a Capitalist vs. a Socialist Society" presents a compare and contrast analysis of capitalism and socialism. Almost all nations take elements of each system and incorporate them into their regulations and social structures…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Advantages and Disadvantages of Living in a Capitalist vs a Socialist Society
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Advantages and Disadvantages of Living in a Capitalist vs a Socialist Society"

 Advantages and Disadvantages of Living in a Capitalist vs. a Socialist Society When comparing capitalism and socialism, it’s sometimes difficult to separate the theories of these systems from the realities of the way we actually run our cultures. There are no purely socialist or purely capitalist societies operating today. Almost all nations take elements of each system and incorporate them into their regulations and social structures. Capitalism. The pure theory of capitalism looks at economics from an individual rather than societal standpoint. Since the consumer ultimately determines the value of products and work, capitalism promotes free trade of goods and labor. In pure theory, each individual in a capitalist system has the same opportunity to succeed or fail as every other individual. Capitalism rewards ingenuity, ability and achievement on the part of individuals regardless of their circumstances at birth or current station in life. Each member of a capitalist society is rewarded for being frugal, responsible, and disciplined, and qualities of honesty, thoughtfulness, and prudence are supposed to be paramount. These qualities are rewarded across all fields of labor, from executives to janitors. Entrepreneurship is vital to a capitalist system. Entrepreneurs see potential everywhere, and are always looking to exploit creativity and initiative for the greatest gain, either financially or for the good of mankind. In theory, there’s an unlimited potential for any individual to grow his or her wealth, and although wealth is distributed unequally, everyone under a capitalist system benefits by association with the wealthy individual. Under capitalism, individuals are free to choose how they act, and if they act immorally, they’re punished by the system. Socialism. Under socialist theory, resources, transportation, and industries are owned by the state, and wealth can be distributed equally among all laborers. Competition between workers or business owners is reduced or eliminated, bringing all people together philosophically and economically. The workers aren’t separated from the products of their work; instead, they retain control over how and why it will be distributed. When the state controls such things as schools and healthcare, those necessities are available to all equally, and private school education and cosmetic or expensive health treatments become luxuries that individuals must pay for instead of the state. Socialism ends hunger and homelessness because wealth is equally distributed to all citizens. Equality and freedom are hoped to be extended to all regardless of race, creed, or sex, because there’s no need to overcome other individuals. Socialists want an equal society, with wealth and resources distributed among the population more evenly. Mixed economies. In reality, most of us live in mixed economies, a blend of state-controlled institutions and resources and the free market system. Socialist-leaning mixed economies socialize major and economically vital industries such as mail, railways, power, utilities, healthcare, and schools. Then they let the free market determine the value of goods and labor. Once each worker is ensured that he or she (and everyone else in the socialist mixed economy) can count on basic necessities, after-tax income can be spent at will on luxuries or reinvested into the economy. In capitalist-leaning mixed economies, the state provides basic infrastructure such as roads and railways, but lets entrepreneurs and individuals control how those resources are used to a greater or lesser extent. Some social programs such as public schools or national forests are almost entirely controlled by the state. The state regulates businesses and individuals to keep a certain boundary on any individual’s actions. In capitalist economies, the workers “sell” their labor. Technology develops as a profit center. The consumer becomes part of the economy, not just laborers as a means of production. Capitalism distributes wealth to whoever can grab it, but anyone can grab it. As levels of wealth rise, economic output rises, creating a cycle. Sometimes, monopolies, business cycles, unemployment, unequally distributed wealth, and economic exploitation of workers happens in capitalist societies. There is often exploitation of low-wage workers, but this exploitation can happen in socialist-leaning cultures, too, when there are profits to be made. Detractors from capitalism point out that there is inefficient distribution of wealth, unemployment and economic instability. In capitalist-leaning economies, the means of production is owned by private people, and operated for profit, with investments, distribution, income, production, and pricing of goods determined through the free market (supply and demand) rather than fixed by government regulation. The state only enforces basic rules like not allowing complete monopolies and keeping worker safety and minimum wages in mind to some degree. Conclusion. In the United States, the current crisis over the health care system has many lawmakers talking about instituting a national health care system. This is like many European nations, Australia and Canada, and many others. Socialized health care has proven to be very difficult to implement in the capitalist economy and thinking of the United States, however, although there are many arguments in favor of implementing such a system. Another problem facing the capitalist culture of the United States is its large pool of low-wage workers. In his book The Working Poor, David Shipler mentions that many of these people are immigrants (both documented and undocumented). Their low-wage work supports farming, restaurants, builders, the garment industry, and so on throughout the United States, providing more prosperous people with goods and services. Many immigrants come to the United States on the promise that even they could make their fortunes, and find so many obstacles in their way that they can barely make a living. Capitalism does not have a provision for more equal distribution of wealth, and so these low-wage workers continue to swim at the bottom of the economic pool. In the early days of labor unions, workers united among themselves to fight unfair labor practices on the part of employers. Nowadays, while most workers do not work under labor unions, government employees, health workers, teachers, and many others do work under union rules. Labor unions provide some of the best aspects of socialism for workers: predictable wages, regulated hours, and guaranteed provided insurances. Unions operate inside of the capitalist system, allowing employers, business people, and individual employees the choice and chance to make profits. Since most of us live in mixed economies, we try to take the best aspects of both capitalism and socialism and incorporate them into our cultures. There’s no doubt that the idea of making a fortune appeals to most people, and capitalism offers that promise to any and all. However, in reality, few people actually make those fortunes, and many more are left with not enough money to prosper and thrive, so the equal distribution of wealth aspect of socialism is also appealing. Nations can only try to come up with the best system for supporting their people using varying aspects of both socialism and capitalism. Work Cited Shipler, David K. “Importing the Third World.” The Working Poor: Invisible in America. New York: Random House, 2005. 77-95. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Advantages and Disadvantages of Living in a Capitalist vs a Socialist Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1548811-socialism-see-instructions-below
(Advantages and Disadvantages of Living in a Capitalist Vs a Socialist Essay)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1548811-socialism-see-instructions-below.
“Advantages and Disadvantages of Living in a Capitalist Vs a Socialist Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1548811-socialism-see-instructions-below.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Advantages and Disadvantages of Living in a Capitalist vs a Socialist Society

Business Systems in China and Japan

The similarity between the political systems in the countries is that both are state capitalist countries; a system which incorporates both free enterprise and government control to generate rapid or unmatched development and growth of their economies as well as the industrial sector.... Japan instigated the capitalist form of governance in Asia during the 1950s and 1970s when it produced similar trends in economic growth and development as that produced by China in the current economic market (Yiping and Kunyu, 2011)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Inequality, Its Impacts and Relation to Occupy Movement

In the paper “Inequality, Its Impacts and Relation to Occupy Movement” the author focuses on the US through the use of international standards, in order to sharpen the scope of prevailing domestic trends in the US.... He contended that economic disparities in America began to soar in the mid-1970s....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Can anarchism be a viable political system

As society within which people freely co-operate together as equals, as it is without a government or any other constituted authority.... This led to the emergence of theories which were against the oppression and inequality in the society of all forms.... Most anarchist theories aimed at creating a classless and a stateless society.... Marxism begins by looking into the origin of class and state; according to them, the different classes in the society are as a result of struggle for existence which is unavoidable (Vodovnik, 2012, pg 43)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Sociology: Capitalism, Socialism and the Concept of Mixed Economy

Likewise a socialist economic system can be either part of Communism or Socialism.... Socialism means ”control of property is put into the hands of society as a whole” (Capitalism, socialism and Mixed-Economy, 2007).... In a collectivist society there are no market prices to help guide the dictator by serving as indicators of expected benefit and expected cost, and enabling him objectively and meaningfully to record the benefits and costs of each undertaking....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Advantages and Disadvantages of Capitalism and Socialism

This essay advantages and disadvantages of Capitalism and Socialism talks that the different forms of economic systems can be put under two major groups which are collectivism and individualism.... As individuals and companies encounter motivation to work hard, this leads to innovation and expansion of the economy, consequently this aids in increased actual growth of the GDP and improved standards of living.... Collectivism is where mankind is considered as raw material for the development of the society....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Social Conflict View

The situation developed when one social group took advantage of the incapacitation of another group to acquire the same… Karl Marx, a German philosopher, supported the concept that there exists no justice for the poor in the society.... The socially disadvantaged in the society received serious punishment for minor crimes as compared to the rich.... Karl Marx, a German philosopher, supported the concept that there exists no justice for the poor in the society....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Social Justice in Catholic Teaching

This paper "Social Justice in Catholic Teaching" discusses the Catholic Church as an institution that has spanned more than 2,000 years.... She traces her beginnings to the pronouncements of Jesus Christ when He called Simon “The Rock” (Peter) and said He was entrusting the keys of the Kingdom to him....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

How Far Does the United States Benefit from Globalization

rdquo; will speak about the advantages and disadvantages of globalization in American society.... Generally, globalization refers to a group of countries joined together, through education, economy, society, and policies.... In reality, the advantages cover three main areas: the American culture, the American political system and the spread of the American economy.... nbsp;… This paper will seek to discuss three more important advantages in America....
12 Pages (3000 words) Dissertation
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us