StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Present savalescu's argument harmless wrogdoing using the nuclear acident case - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name: Instructor: Course: Date: Essay, philosophy Savalescu, a bioethicist professor, supports the selection of best children by parents given all genetic information about the children. In this case, Savalescu supports the killing of embryos arguing that killing is not bad as long as it results to benefits to the living and to those at risk of dying…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.7% of users find it useful
Present savalescus argument harmless wrogdoing using the nuclear acident case
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Present savalescu's argument harmless wrogdoing using the nuclear acident case"

Download file to see previous pages

The professor equates the case of the nuclear accident to selection of embryos otherwise referred to as procreative beneficence (Mills, 65). He argues that a poor country can invest in nuclear energy in order to provide heat and light. Nuclear energy then changes the citizen’s lifestyle since citizens can now enjoy their lives more by staying awake for longer periods. After sometime, a break down in the nuclear plant emits radiations to the environment and causes harm to the population. Majority of children born after the nuclear accident suffer pregnancy complications and physical abnormalities.

Savalescu points out that objecting the nuclear accident is like admitting to harmless wrongdoing. He argues that children born after the nuclear accident would not have been born if the government did not invest in the nuclear plant. He argues that the nuclear accident was wrong but the population not severely harmed unless of death cases. According to Savalescu, if the population objected the accident then they have no right to object his concept of procreative beneficence. According to Holland (81), Savalescu justifies killing in order to save lives. . Savalescu argument in relation to nuclear accident refers to using “preimplantation genetic diagnosis” (PGD) to select genes not affected by the nuclear accident.

Nuclear accident not only results to body abnormalities, but also affects future generations. Nuclear accident affects the genetics composition of adults’ genes, which can affect future generations by inheriting the undesired genes (Mills, 27). In this case, Savalescu calls for use of the PGD to select embryos while destroying the nuclear affected embryos. However, the use of PGD is only possible when used with in-vitro fertilization (IVF) where fertilization of the ova and the sperm cells occurs outside the body before implanted into the female’s body.

Savalescu arguments for harmless wrongdoing are logical since it may result to improvement of a child’s life. According to Savalescu, nuclear affected genes may affect the lives of the born children. This is because; the children born will have physical abnormalities hence may not live a good life. According to Oakley (192), applying Savalescu theory of selection of embryos may help to prevent the unborn child from living a miserable life. Parents can prevent their children from the effects of the nuclear emissions by selecting the non-affected genes.

This helps to control the effects of the nuclear accident by preventing the inheritance to future generations. Savalescu’s arguments help in evaluating the embryos with the highest chances of survival (Mills, 66). Procreative beneficence is crucial in evaluating the best genes that are likely to survive and live the best life. The parents then neglect the weaker genes that are not likely to survive. This will ensure the elimination of the problem of infant mortality

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Present savalescu's argument harmless wrogdoing using the nuclear Essay”, n.d.)
Present savalescu's argument harmless wrogdoing using the nuclear Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1496581-present-savalescu-s-argument-harmless-wrogdoing
(Present savalescu'S Argument Harmless Wrogdoing Using the Nuclear Essay)
Present savalescu'S Argument Harmless Wrogdoing Using the Nuclear Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1496581-present-savalescu-s-argument-harmless-wrogdoing.
“Present savalescu'S Argument Harmless Wrogdoing Using the Nuclear Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1496581-present-savalescu-s-argument-harmless-wrogdoing.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Present savalescu's argument harmless wrogdoing using the nuclear acident case

Understanding the Effects of Wrongful Imprisonment

False imprisonment is a tort which is also presented in the common law… This paper presents a case of Paul Trune against a farmer who allegedly falsely imprisoned him in relation to the Herbst v.... Wuennenberg case in which the plaintiff's complain for false imprisonment was disapproved by False Imprisonment: The case of Paul Trune Introduction When an individual has been confined without his or her consent and thus defying the will of the individual and the associated violation of freedom then it is said that false imprisonment has occurred....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Disaster

Effects on the nuclear industry, changes enacted by the Department of Energy or Nuclear Regulatory Commission to prevent or minimize the recurrence of the event in the US.... The paper "Fukushima Daiichi nuclear Disaster" describes that the power plants, during that time, after experiencing the earthquake, shut down.... Studies or reports about the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster has been also cited in the paper.... What really happened with the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster?...
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Comparison of Two Articles' Arguments

In relying totally on his personal experience, and using pathos to emotionally appeal to his reader, the author has demonstrated too much bias against the issue and no consideration for the opposition's stance.... Logos refers to a plea or argument leading to a conclusion, or thesis, or ground of argument....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Effects of Accidents and Catastrophes

This paper "Effects of Accidents and Catastrophes" focuses on the fact that in the world today many kinds of disasters and accidents take place.... The world has always been in a cycle of all these events together.... As the population has grown many such incidents have been witnessed.... nbsp;… A hazard can be defined as a factor or factors which tend to cause harm to an individual or a thing....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Arguments on the Legalization of Snow Making Using Dirty Water

The following paper under the title 'Arguments on the Legalization of Snow Making using Dirty Water' presents the United States which is home to many tribes living in villages on mountain peaks and untouched, virgin forests like the San Francisco Peak… The tribes are quite sensitive to their homes as they take the peaks to be sacred and under no circumstances, should there be any violation of this fact....  The paper also debates and strongly opposes the idea of using dirty water to form artificial snow, in addition to protecting the affected peaks....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

The ase of Scott Starson

The Supreme Court held that a patient, in this case, Starson, was not required to make a decision that is in their “best interest” as determined by the physician, and thence they are permitted to disagree with a treatment recommendation.... he above case represents a conflict of these two rather ethical considerations, on one side, the physician feels compelled to do what he believes is in the best interest of the patient.... ost legal cases, not only in Starson's case, often uphold the position of the patient....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

The Operational Events of Nuclear Power Processing

the nuclear power processing sector is one of the technical complex industries whose operational events have serious effects on nature.... Communicating within the nuclear processing industry involves several groups of audiences.... The paper 'The Operational Events of nuclear Power Processing' presents technical communication that is prepared for several audiences.... Evaluation of the consequences of the operational events of nuclear power processing these effects to the affected parties is in most cases challenging for the technical communicators....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Analysis of Two Nuclear Accidents in the USA and Ukraine

This led to an immediate build-up of pressure in the primary system (the nuclear part of the plant) (Walker, 2004).... The author of the "Analysis of Two nuclear Accidents in the USA and Ukraine" paper looks into depth the cases of two nuclear accidents, the Three Mile Island nuclear accident in the state of Pennsylvania in the United States and the Chernobyl disaster in Ukraine.... The Three Mile Island nuclear power plant accident occurred near Middletown, Dauphin county Pennsylvania on the 28th of March, 1979 (World nuclear Association, 2012)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us