StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Kant, Mill, and Nietzsche - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
A nurse’s refusal to give a CPR to a dying 87 year old woman at a living center has promoted outrage and a criminal investigation.” What would Kant, Mill and Nietzsche say about it?…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Kant, Mill, and Nietzsche
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Kant, Mill, and Nietzsche"

Download file to see previous pages

However, Kant and Mill also differ in a sense that Kant states that a person’s moral is innate as in a priori reasoning and Mill suggests, however selfishly, that morals are essential to a person’s happiness as people abide to morals for them to be happy. Now, for Nietzsche being good – at least morally good, is a social construct as the upper class and the people who are in control are defining the word with their preferences and activities. It can change as to who controls the social power.

With this notion, evil, or bad, is also arbitrary, as the social class also determines which are bad and those things are generally the ones that do not work for them. For example, if you are an upper class gentleman and your slaves are working well for you, would you consider slavery immoral? No, because it is good for you. You might even think that slavery is important. But if you are a slave, slavery for you is evil because you suffer. However, who holds the social power? For the longest time, it was the upper class, which is why slavery did not become illegal for a long time.

Then when the revolution happened, many people were affected by it. And those “many people” helped slavery become a “bad” thing. . Now these imperatives in turn, determine everyone’s duty. Because of this, morals are not arbitrary because it is universal and it is true to everyone. For Mill on the other hand, has a similar belief to Kant – everyone has innate morals; morals are not arbitrary. But unlike Kant, Mill states that these morals are used to maximize happiness and reduce suffering.

Utilitarian in most ways, he basically says that the right things bring happiness and wrong things bring suffering. In his words, “actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness; wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness”. Therefore, if an action is morally right if it makes the doer really happy. Therefore, happiness is not a social construct but an innate faculty in humans, and because it is innate, it cannot be arbitrary. Now, given the scenario above, what would each of the philosophers do given the situation?

For Nietzsche, the nurse would just be in a wrong place at a wrong time. If the society urges euthanasia, then she would not have been stigmatized by having outrages towards her action. She will not be treated as a criminal. She’s having these negative connotations mainly because in her society, the people in power have deemed that her action is “immoral”. If we are taking Kant’s point of view, where all morals are innate, then we can conclude that the nurse is indeed wrong, as there are more people who were outraged by her actions than the people who weren’t.

For Kant, there are universal ethical standards that cannot be broken. Now these ethical standards are about killing. Obviously, killing is not very accepted as it has produced crime and outrage. If we are talking about Mill’s point of view, then we should ask the nurse if she was

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Kant, Mill, and Nietzsche Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1470502-kant-mill-and-nietzsche-respond-to-the-scenario
(Kant, Mill, and Nietzsche Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1470502-kant-mill-and-nietzsche-respond-to-the-scenario.
“Kant, Mill, and Nietzsche Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1470502-kant-mill-and-nietzsche-respond-to-the-scenario.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Kant, Mill, and Nietzsche

Objections to Nietzsche's conception of pity/compassion/love

In this essay "Objections to nietzsche's conception of pity/compassion/love" the writer will discuss the value of pity and other morals by nietzsche and his predecessors.... Additionally, the writer will reveal nietzsche's six premises on pity.... nietzsche apparently interpreted the Christian psychology as a doctrine that seeks to diminish humanity's "will to power".... nietzsche defended humanity against mysticism by asserting that human beings are naturally free and autonomous....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Vernon God Little by D.B.C Pierre

Impact of good and evil, wealth and poverty, cause and effect, all these themes are evident in D.... .... .... Pierre's novel Vernon God Little.... Vernon, on the other hand, has problems with absorbing each one of them.... The composition is being told in the first-person recitation by Vernon.... hellip; Vernon's language is full of vulgar language and a distorted outlook of life; also he frequently shares learning's with the readers....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

On the Genealogy of Morals: An Analysis of Power Friedrich Nietzsche

This book report "On the Genealogy of Morals: An Analysis of Power Friedrich nietzsche" discusses asceticism weakens our capability to obtain power, through the misplacement of power we experience when we fall short in shielding ourselves from pain.... In nietzsche's point of view, this directly undervalues them.... e, as well, just like nietzsche should begin searching for the origin of the words.... The argument of nietzsche is founded on linguistics; he explores the words in several languages, and terms resembling them....
9 Pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review

Effective Theories for Political Order Development

Conversely, the other philosopher John Rawls in response to the theory of nietzsche initiated “A Theory of Justice”, which elaborates individual rights and liberty (Iowa State University Department of Economics, n.... An argumentative viewpoint will be presented in this essay determining the creation of political order and its purpose as per the theories laid down by dissimilar philosophers namely nietzsche, Rawls, Kant and Mill.... As per the respective theories propounded by the aforesaid philosophers, it can be ascertained that nietzsche believed in morality and the concept of perfectionism....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Analyse and assess Rousseau, Marx OR Nietzsches critique of Hobbes and/or Locke

The Genealogy of Morality is a polemic book by Friedrich nietzsche consists of three treatises that trace the evolution of moral concepts in relation to undermining moral prejudices especially that of the Judaism and Christianity.... nietzsche examines the meanings and origins of… In the first essay, he looks at Good and evil and Good and bad where he indicates that master morality was developed by the health, free and strong who identified their happiness as good....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Perspectivism: Evidence For and Against

Truth is something that is made by individuals after bringing together separate vantage points (nietzsche and Kaufmann, 74).... nietzsche concept on God is dead.... In post modernism reason and science have become the sources of truth (nietzsche and Kaufmann, 181).... This will to power is at work unconsciously according to Jacques Derrida (nietzsche and Kaufmann, 183).... The evidence against this idea is that the theory of knowledge relies on the reasoning power this is according to kant and Descartes....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Freud and Nietzsche on Religion

The "Freud and nietzsche on Religion" paper argues that Freud's fundamental criticism of morality and religion is based on his own method of analysis.... riedrich nietzsche (1844-1900) is also critical of basic religious beliefs.... Immanuel kant believed that the concept of morality should be imposed by a divine deity or God....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Hume and other Philosophers

This paper "Hume and other Philosophers" discusses why Kant did not end up with Hume's skepticism as far as the notion of causality goes, Kantian and a Nietzschean take on killing in order to stop a murder, the moral philosophy of nietzsche, Sartre's understanding of existence preceding essence.... There has been a disparity in regards to kant's idea of causality along with Hume's and therefore there has been controversy over if the two conceptions have considerable differences....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us