StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorders - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Your Name Date Course Response to Patricia Backlar’s Ethics in Community Mental Health Care: Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorder: Impediments to Assigning Moral Responsibility One of the most interesting aspects of the argument Patricia Backlar makes in her article “Ethics in Community Mental Health Care: Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorder: Impediments to Assigning Moral Responsibility” is the epistemological lineage she draws her logic from…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER99% of users find it useful
Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorders
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorders"

Download file to see previous pages

While the ancient Greeks argued that logic, not instinct, was what gave rise to knowledge, most people today use a combination of both. Just as a cop follows a lead on “instinct” or a mother knows her child is sick through “intuition”, humans rely on an illogical gut reaction to compliment logic in the decision making process. Ignoring this gut reaction in favor of pure logic can cause humans to draw irrational conclusions, as is the case with Backlar. Furthermore, ignoring this visceral reaction causes Backlar to defy society’s view of justice in favor one more easily dismissed by logic in her article, and causes her to not only act against her human instinct, but to also practice a lower quality of medicine.

Because it contradicts her profession, society’s view of justice, the instinctual feeling of what is right, I reject Barker’s conclusion that the criminally insane should be viewed as felons. In her article, Backlar tells the story of being a naive provider in a criminal psychiatric ward and feeling shocked upon hearing a more senior provider refer to patients as felons. Backlar then goes on to describe her transition from shock to acceptance as she begins to believe this senior provider is correct and that the patients are in fact felons.

Throughout the article, Backlar repeats this conclusion, arguing that because the guilty and the criminally insane are all convicted criminals, they should all be given the same level of baseline treatment by the justice system. This conclusion defies Backlar’s medical profession, whose duty it is to treat patients. In any scientific process, bias introduces a systematic error in results. Thinking of patients as felons constitutes judgment of the patients and judging patients introduces a bias into care.

This bias will lower the quality of care provided to the patients and will contradict the very reason Backlar is with her patients to begin with. This bias is why some medical personnel working in corrections settings choose not to know what crimes the patients they treat have committed. Viewing a patient you are assigned to treat as a felon introduces a judgment that medical personnel are not called on to provide. The job of any health care provider is to treat the patient. Using logic to formulate the argument that the patients are felons denies the true connotation of the word.

“Felon” is more than its dictionary definition; it is a stigma in our society. To refer to a person as a felon is to pass judgment on them, and judging a patient because of his or her personal background would lower the standard of care. It is because of this compromising of the quality of medical care that I reject Backlar’s conclusion that the criminally insane are guilty felons. Beyond the bias that referring to a patient as a felon introduces, calling patients felons is also wrong because it implies their guilt.

This argument gets at the root of Backlar’s true question in the article: should the criminally insane be punished or treated? Are the criminally insane culpable or innocent? Instead of choosing from the two options, I propose a third: to not categorize the criminally insane on the basis of their disease state, but on the basis of their individual case. The justice system does not say every drug crime should be

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorders Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1424009-criminal-behavior-and-mental-disorders
(Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorders Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1424009-criminal-behavior-and-mental-disorders.
“Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorders Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1424009-criminal-behavior-and-mental-disorders.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Criminal Behavior and Mental Disorders

Sentencing of People with Mental Disorders

  Sentencing of People with mental disorders [School Affiliation] Offense and sentencing are two terms which have been going side by side since many centuries.... mental disorders: A disorder can be termed as functional abnormality.... mental disorders comprise of a wide range of derangements in behavioral or psychological functions.... Criminals with mental disorders are released after a small period of incarceration.... In law enforcement, the stakeholders can be: Judiciary Probation and parole services Social service organizations mental hospitals and treatment facilities Community etc....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Cohen vs Hall Study of Disorderly Behavior

Consequently, behavior disorders pose the society to negative consequences leading to the development of diverse bodies to address the concern.... On the other hand, Hall limits disorders to given occurrences, which cause change or influence on human behavior.... The essay "Cohen vs Hall Study of Disorderly behavior" focuses on the critical analysis of the comparison and contrast between Cohen's study of disorderly behavior with that of Hall et all....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Abnormal psychology

Jack the Ripper's victim choice, his mutilation techniques (also referred to as his Mondus Operundus or MO) help to shed some light on factors that might have triggered his personality disorders; which in my opinion fall under Cluster B of personality disorders as categorized by DSM-IV-TR.... Cluster B personality disorders are characterized by dysfunctions in impulse and emotional regulation.... Moreover, it requires a professional mental practitioner to rule out psychological disorders as the precipitating cause of the crime....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

Personality Disorders and Offending Behavior

The essay "Personality disorders and Offending Behavior" critically discusses the relationship between personality disorders and offending behaviors.... o accomplish the tasks, it will first be necessary to define a working definition of personality disorder and a basic typology before further exploring the risk factors that influence personality disorders over the course of an individual's life.... It is the basic thesis of this paper that these risk factors and subsequent personality disorders explain offending behaviors far more satisfactorily than vague references to criminal subcultures, dangerous prisoners incapable of reform, or the dreaded substance abuse allegation....
24 Pages (6000 words) Essay

Treatment, Profiling of Psychopaths, Personality Disorder

This is a synonym for antisocial personality disorder (ASPD), a category listed in the fourth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of mental disorders (DSM-IV) and is applicable to the majority of criminals.... A personality disorder is characterized by a history of continuous and chronic antisocial behaviour that is not attributable to severe mental retardation, schizophrenia, or manic episodes, and is also called antisocial personality.... hellip; The distinction between psychopathy and ASPD is of considerable significance to the mental health and criminal justice systems. In the UK, 'psychopatic disorder' is a legal term used in the mental Health Act 1983, and is 'a persistent disorder or disability of mind which results in abnormally aggressive or seriously irresponsible conduct'....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Conduct Disorder over Aggression

aggressive destructive behavior and covert misconduct.... Aggressive children and youth are known to inflict pain and cause discomfort to those around them and hence it is of utmost significance to ascertain the prevalence and causes behind such overt aggression and conduct disorders among young children and adolescents.... Conduct… rs are one of the most frequent reasons for clinical referrals to young children and adolescents and are most common causes of behavioral disorders among young children....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Link between ADHD and Criminal Behavior

Research has also termed this disorder as the developmental forerunner of later disruptive behavior and criminality.... In this regard, they note that there is a strong connection between the high rate of conduct behavior and the prevalence of ADHD.... This paper “Link between ADHD and criminal behavior” discusses how ADHD causes criminal behavior.... It analyzes the various aspects of ADHD that indicates and causes criminal behavior....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Cohens Study of Disorderly Behavior with that of Hall

Consequently, behavior disorders pose the society to negative consequences leading to the development of diverse bodies to address the concern.... On the other hand, Hall limits disorders to given occurrences, which cause change or influence on human behavior.... nbsp; Therefore, according to Cohen disorders in human behavior is incitement by the surrounding atmosphere.... This work called "Cohen's Study of Disorderly behavior with that of Hall" describes the key aspects of human behavior....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us