StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Gender-Related Issues in Leadership - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This research paper "Gender-Related Issues in Leadership" aims to proffer pertinent issues relative to a review of related literature on the topic of gender in leadership. Relevant research studies on the subject would be analyzed where significant points would hereby be cited…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
Gender-Related Issues in Leadership
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Gender-Related Issues in Leadership"

Gender-Related Issues in Leadership The essay aims to proffer pertinent issues relative to a review of related literature on the topic of gender in leadership. Relevant research studies on the subject would be analyzed where significant points would hereby be cited and highlighted to reveal diverse viewpoints on gender in leadership. Different authors’ evaluations and concerns on gender biases, attitudes towards promotions, and stereotypes in gender in leadership would be discussed. The discourse would thereby reveal if indeed leadership’s effectiveness and the ability towards goal accomplishment are highly influenced by gender differences. A concluding portion would summarize points that were discussed and future thrusts for research on the subject. Gender-Related Issues in Leadership One of the most frequently researched topic focuses on leadership. The evolution of theories and concepts proposed and promulgated by various scholars and practitioners have undergone constant and continuous development until contemporary times. Aside from the traditional thrusts delving into leadership styles, characteristics or best practices in famous organizations, one of the controversial issues confounding leadership is the effect or influence of gender, among other demographic factors. Leadership concepts and contemporary theories evaluate the effect of gender in leadership in terms of according the benefits, prerogatives, and even challenges on equal terms. In this regard, the essay aims to proffer a review of related literature on the topic of gender in leadership. Relevant research studies on the subject would be analyzed where significant points would hereby be cited and highlighted to reveal diverse viewpoints on gender in leadership. Review of Related Literature According to the research study conducted by Gedney which is aimed to determine a relationship or link between gender and leadership effectiveness from her personal experience in the military, she initially provided crucial qualities identified from effective leaders. Her findings divulged that “leadership effectiveness is not gender-specific, but there seem to be many attributes that are found in both males and females that lend themselves to becoming an effective leader” (Gedney, 1999, p. 2). This fact was validated by Kelly, a Lieutenant Colonel of the U.S. Air Force, who averred that “men and women operate in the work environment in somewhat different ways based upon genetic/biological differences, cultivation, communication styles and to some extent, the characteristics of the particular career field chosen” (Kelly, 1997, p. 26). Since the military is a male-dominated profession, Kelly’s findings disclosed that “women who choose careers as military leaders generally adapt or fit in to survive, become isolated with the organization (generally ineffective members), or they leave. Adaptation creates a more homogenous organization, but predisposes harassment and limits diversity. The US Air Force forfeits benefits and advantages which women would normally contribute; those very attributes considered essential to strategic leadership of the future” (Kelly. 1997, pp. 35 – 36). In this regard, promotions to leadership positions in male-dominated careers could still exhibit biases, especially in gender. The study of Gedney (1999) cited Kolb as indicating that “when we reviewed this literature we were struck by the prejudice against women. Research has demonstrated that there are far more similarities than differences in the leadership behaviors of women and men, and that they are equally effective. Still, women are less likely to be pre-selected as leaders, and the same leadership behavior is often evaluated more positively when attributed to a male than to a female” (Kolb, 1997, p. 371). Interestingly, Gedney (1999) likewise cited Mitchell’s book that clearly reveals the extent of eminent gender bias in the military, to wit: “were it not for the intense political pressure, there would be virtually no women in the military today” (Mitchell, 1998, p. xiii). One can understand that from the point of view of the author, who is a woman, the contents of the controversial book written by Mitchell are magnified in terms of focusing on information that contends male-dominance in that career. There are statistics that actually support the truth to her allegations. As of the time of Gedney’s writing in 1999, “of the 284 Air Force general officers on active duty today, there are only 7 females among them, for a 2% representation” (Gedney, 1999, p. v). The author further categorized barriers for women aspiring for leadership positions in the military in terms of areas such as perceptions and attitudes of senior officers towards women in the military, the masculine culture, and stereotyping. To provide a more balanced discourse in other fields of endeavors, the study conducted by van Engen and Willemsen (2009) presented a more expansive review of gender and leadership by presenting a holistic approach that evaluated a total of 80 authoritative resources on the subject. Their findings disclosed that “sex differences in leadership styles still existed towards the end of the twentieth century. In general, however, male and female managers lead similarly; the overall effect size was .05, and only 27% of the comparisons resulted in a significant stereotypic difference in leadership style. Still, sex differences have not diminished or vanished” (van Engen & Willemsen, 2009, p. 19). Further, Lyons and McArthur indicate that “the challenges that women face in accommodating themselves to male-defined executive roles and suggests how corporate leaders--men in particular--can make these detrimental effects discussable within their own executive suites” (Lyons & McArthur. 1998, 1). These generalizations were arrived at from an interview with 44 senior executives from various corporations of admired businesses in the United States, where the focus of the questions about leadership were: (1) what are the executives strengths and weaknesses? (2) How good is she at strategic thinking? And (3) how effective is he operationally? The findings revealed that “gender is an active variable in the assessment of male and female executive leadership” (Lyons & McArthur, 1998, p. 3). Apparently, it was evident that the concept of stereotyping apparently emerged from the responses made by the male executives expressing their strong belief that leadership is synonymous with male dominated culture. In addition, gender alone (female) was manifested as a barrier to promotion to higher leadership ranks. Further, when asked to comment on overall performance, male executives comment more on a woman’s gender than their male counterparts. Accordingly, the Lyons and McArthur (1998) disclosed that “no matter how she behaves, the fact that a woman is a woman puts her at odds with prevailing norms for leaders at the top of corporate organizations. A woman executive may exhibit many of the behaviors expected of someone in her role; nonetheless, her gender stands out and often works against her success” (Lyons & McArthur, 1998, p. 3). Conclusion The current research aimed to review various literatures and studies that were conducted on the topic of gender in leadership. Different authors have evaluated and highlighted relevant concerns including gender biases, attitudes towards promotions, and stereotypes in gender in leadership. Various research studies have thereby revealed that contemporary organizations have continued to practice biases in gender that precludes women to assume leadership positions. Biases were eminent and resulted not so much on attributes or essential elements for leadership; but more so, on the stereotyped masculine culture that continue to pervade contemporary societies in general. With increasing awareness from results of continued research that aims to determine if indeed leadership’s effectiveness and the ability towards goal accomplishment are highly influenced by gender differences, future research must provide measures to address the bias and unjust stereotyping of women, who are as effective leaders of equal capacities with men. Contemporary leadership theories continue to evolve, adapt and adjust to the changes of the global environment. The issues on gender in leadership should transcend from focusing on inequality based on genetic or biological differences, cultivation, communication styles, the characteristics of the chosen field of endeavor or personalities, to the effective promotion of responsibilities and tasks of leaders, regardless of gender, towards the accomplishments of identified organizational goals. References Gedney, C.R. (1999). Leadership Effectiveness and Gender. Retrieved 02 October 2010, from Kelly, Martha JM. (1997). Gender Differences And Leadership: A Study. Retrieved 1 October 2011, from . Kolb, J.A. (1997). Are We Still Stereotyping Leadership? Small Group Research, Vol.28 No. 3, pp. 371 – 388. Mitchell, B. (1998). Women in the Military: Flirting with Disaster. Regnery Pub, Inc. Van Engen, M.L. and Willemsen, T.M. (2009). Gender and leadership styles: A review of the past decade. WORC Paper 00.10.09. Retrieved 03 October 2011, from Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Research Paper Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 2”, n.d.)
Research Paper Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 2. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1580591-research-paper-assignment
(Research Paper Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 2)
Research Paper Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 2. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1580591-research-paper-assignment.
“Research Paper Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 2”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1580591-research-paper-assignment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Gender-Related Issues in Leadership

Why Gender and Culture Matter

leadership: Why Gender and Culture Matter (Name) (University) (Course) (Tutor) (Date) Gender is simply a social construct and thus does refer to the differences and relationships existing between men and women, boys and girls.... In many years now, leadership has been understood in a wrong way and thus misconceived.... There are different models of leadership that are related to gender and cultural practices.... These models are classified as trait or those based on categorization of leadership or simply implicit leadership theory,; behavioral which does include transformational-transactional leadership, two factor, and leader-member exchange models; and the contingency that encompasses the contingency model of leadership effectiveness and the normative decision making models....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Gender communication

This essay describes the gender roles in society and behavioral patterns that are expected both genders to have.... The aspect of gender varies among different communities.... This therefore, makes gender to be a social or cultural construct, since it is the community, which determines it.... ... ...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Analysis of Issues and Relevant Leadership Process

Walmart faced several ethical issues in recent past due to poor adoption and implementation of workplace diversity process (Hall, 2005, pp.... This paper will determine the issues that are affecting the performance of the global retail chain industry and will provide recommendations with appropriate leadership process in order to overcome them.... An effective leadership style helps the industry to overcome workplace conflicts and issues.... leadership can be defined as the process of cultural and social influence in which an individual can enlist the support and aid of others in the achievement of a common task....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

The Power of Gender In Effective Leadership

This paper talks that the issue of gender in leadership has been a major human resource concern.... While previously power in leadership was associated with masculinity, today effective leadership is based on the ability to work through the subordinate staff by inspiring them and not commanding them.... The feminist tried to show that men and women have their unique identities and this influences the way they relate to different issues in the social construct....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Gender Issues in Sport

This paper "Gender issues in Sport" is being carried out to study the ways in which sports theory must be taught along with feminist and social theories so that the events of society coincide with the belief of society.... One of the more complex issues that plague educational institutions is in handling the gender inequalities that exist within their athletic departments.... While the issue causes strong opinions on the viability of having sports teams be equally funded, there are logistical issues that create problems when trying to identify what is discrimination versus what is fiscally responsible....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Gender and Leadership

The essay "Gender and leadership" analyzes the issue or contention that: Women are being discriminated in the workplace in relation to leadership or managerial roles and positions.... This essay shall first provide facts relating to statistical figures on women versus male leadership ratio in organizations.... The essay shall argue on one hand how women are still being discriminated against for leadership roles.... Discrimination against women has been the dominant type of discrimination observed in the workplace, especially in terms of hiring, firing, as well as being promoted or considered for salary increases, relevant assignments, as well as management or leadership positions....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Analysis of Reconstructing Gender Empowerment Article by Jawad Syed

In such a case, the GEM value is high as it excludes women from impoverished backgrounds with access to leadership levels at the grassroots.... Contrastingly, the secular bias results from the inability of the GEM to consider the impact of religious commitments and choices on individuals' perception of gender related issues....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Gender Dynamics of Organizational Leadership & Politics

This paper "Gender Dynamics of Organizational leadership & Politics" focuses on the fact that in the US, as well as in other countries that mainly value the element of individual achievement as opposed to collectivism, an immense amount of attention is directed towards the capacity of the leaders.... The traditional values that are mainly associated with power and leadership in the U.... construe the masculine ideologies of leadership as one that encompasses toughness and stoicism....
8 Pages (2000 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us