StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Law of Contract and Tort: The Case of Melinda and the dishwasher - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Melinda would have a case against Albert based upon contract law. The test for a contract is whether an agreement exists and what the parties have agreed to in objective terms. The "reasonable man" approach is essential here - would a reasonable person looking at the transaction between the parties reach the conclusion that they had entered into a contract, and if so, under what terms Melinda may reasonably claim that she entered into a contract with Albert to pay him 375 pounds in order to "supply and fit the necessary pipe-work and connect the dishwasher up."
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
Law of Contract and Tort: The Case of Melinda and the dishwasher
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Law of Contract and Tort: The Case of Melinda and the dishwasher"

Download file to see previous pages

A reasonable person would conclude that the new plumber was correct in stating that Albert's piping had been installed "very poorly" (due to the objective fact that it was leaking within seven days) - thus Melinda has a claim against Albert for the 200 pounds that she had to pay the new plumber. The main claim against Superelectrics Limited will be for a breach of contract under the Sale of Goods Act, 1979. This implies into the sale of contract (in this case the acceptance of money from Melinda by the shop in return for the dishwasher) that "the goods will be of satisfactory quality" and that "where expressly or impliedly known by the supplier, the foods will be reasonably fit for the buyer's purposes" (Sale, 1979).

Neither of these implications was met within the sale of the dishwasher, which had a defective thermostat and ended up both injuring Melinda and damaging her property. Melinda will have a cause for action to have her money refunded (599 pounds) for breach of contract, and perhaps, although this is less certain in the case of the shop, for negligence in selling her a product that was dangerous. The general tests for negligence are as follows: 1) the defendant owed a duty of care to the plaintiff; 2)the defendant breached that duty of care; 3) this breach caused the loss or damage to the plaintiff and 4) the defendant should compensate the plaintiff for that loss.

In the case of the shop it is clear that 1 and 2 are met, but Melinda is on less certain ground on claiming that the breach was what caused both the injury to herself and the damage to her property. She should be advised to seek the return of her money under breach of contract, but to pursue the manufacturer of the dishwasher on the other grounds, as she will have more chance of winning. c) Claims against Domestico PlcAs outlined in the description of the provisions that need to be met for a tort of negligence it seems clear that 1, 2, 3 and 4 are all met with respect to the manufacturer of the dishwasher, Domestico Plc.

For a case for negligence to be successfully brought against the company a number of elements need to be met. The first two are cause in fact and proximate (legal) cause. (Barker, 2001) Were the actions of Domestico Plc the cause of the injuries sustained by Melinda and the damage to her property It would seem that the answer is yes. This is assuming that the poorly skilled plumber, Albert, did not in some way damage the dishwasher as he installed it, or, secondly, that the second plumber did not damage it.

If these two are discounted then it is clear that the damage/injury would not have occurred "but for" the actions of Domestico Plc in not producing a safe dishwasher as is assumed under the Sales of Goods Act. Second, was Domestico Plc responsible for the proximate cause: how proximate, and thus foreseeable, were the injuries and damages incurred by Melinda because of the faulty dishwasher There is not any remoteness to the damages that she suffered: it was very foreseeable that a dishwasher that uses high pressure boiling water might cause severe injuries if

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Law of Contract and Tort: The Case of Melinda and the dishwasher Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1516425-law-of-contract-and-tort-the-case-of-melinda-and-the-dishwasher
(Law of Contract and Tort: The Case of Melinda and the Dishwasher Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1516425-law-of-contract-and-tort-the-case-of-melinda-and-the-dishwasher.
“Law of Contract and Tort: The Case of Melinda and the Dishwasher Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1516425-law-of-contract-and-tort-the-case-of-melinda-and-the-dishwasher.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Law of Contract and Tort: The Case of Melinda and the dishwasher

Contract and Tort Interrelationship

contract and tort inter relationship[9]: contract and tort have interrelationship as far as the remedies are concerned.... Where a dispute consists of ingredients of both contract and tort as well then the plaintiff is at a liberty to choose the action either under contract or under Tort.... Because contract was traditionally seen as the method for resolving disputes involving pure economic loss, it was originally thought that where two parties had made a contract, a negligence action could not be used to fill in any gaps in that contract" How has Tort overcome the restrictions involved in a strict reading of the law of contract … The law of torts developed out of court decisions in providing remedies where there are no remedies available in any statutory law enacted by the legislation....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study

Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations

The UCTA 1979 is broader in scope, but does not cover all types of contract and is limited to exclusion and limitation clauses.... ince Melinda is using the dishwasher for both her business and her family we must first determine whether she is covered by the legislation.... On the facts before us prima facie Melinda has purchased the dishwasher to be used partially in her business.... hellip; However there have been cases where a plaintiff has attempted to incorporate an onerous term into a contract without providing adequate notice to the claimant In order to ensure parity in bargaining power the courts would look for evidence that the term was incorporated into the contract and that the claimant had adequate notice of it....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Analysis of Case Concerning Law of Tort

in the case of a chauffeur.... in the case of a taxi - driver.... Betty Bloke in claiming in negligence of the three companies in this case, must prove that loss suffered was reasonably foreseeable.... (Abbot, K (2002) … In this particular case, we note that Betty was not employed by any of the three companies; it is her husband Harry who was employed by the three companies.... Negligence is a form of tort....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Law And Contract Resit

In this case four issues arise and these are noise and vibrations disturbing Pub's customer, Bloggs & Co Builders used the student car park to the jib of a crane, construction vehicles are constantly blocking the entrance of Public house owner and they work continues on site Saturday and Sunday mornings as a result the pub manager was disturbed.... The point was succinctly made in Sturges v Bridgeman6, in which case a physician complained about the noise generated by a neighbouring confectioner who was operating a pestle and motor....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

General Electric: Major Appliance Business Group

n the case of manufacturing changes, Moeller, and his team proposed to totally redo the key Louisville dishwasher sections to fully complement and adopt a cellular approach on major production stages.... n early 1970's, MABG management viewed the dishwasher business as an issue despite its market share being over 20+% and its strong financial performance.... Following the quality issues, Jack Welch challenged MABG by proposing a simple fix on the dishwasher business in to make it efficient in operational standards....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Remedy to Recover Damages for the Loss

nbsp;  … Consumers have certain rights against breach of contract, hence, it is important to determine, if a purchaser is a consumer.... This helps to assess the rights of the purchaser to claim damages in instances of breach of contract.... he Sale of Goods Act (SGA) protects the interests of consumers and provides remedies for breach of contract.... This is because, the Unfair contract Terms Act precludes exemption clauses that seek to avoid liability for physical injuries and death caused to a consumer of their products....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Construction Contract Law

The author analyzes the case about the employer who has express obligations towards the contractor David under JCT Standard Business Contract 2005 with quantities.... Implied obligations of the contractor are that he should complete the contract and he has also the right to complete the work in time as per schedule for which the employer should cooperate.... The employer, having once agreed, cannot split the contract and give it to another contractor as otherwise the contractor can assume it as a repudiatory breach of contract by the employer and enable him to terminate the contract....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Conceptual Framework of Duty of Care

hellip; The cause of the flooding of Jamie's flat which is beneath the flat of Chantelle's flat from where the flood came from should be directly or immediately linked to the dishwasher's defect for claiming damages from the manufacturer of the machine Spandex.... The paper under the title 'Conceptual Framework of Duty of Care' presents the brand new dishwasher's breakdown which could have been due to one or all of the reasons such as defective manufacture, the consumer's mishandling, electrical short-circuiting, etc....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us