StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

A Clear Chapter by Chapter Synopsis of The President as Leader by Erwin C. Hargrove - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Following a distinguished career as a scholar f the American presidency, Erwin C. Hargrove in The President as Leader offers his capstone appraisal f presidential leadership. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
A Clear Chapter by Chapter Synopsis of The President as Leader by Erwin C. Hargrove
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Clear Chapter by Chapter Synopsis of The President as Leader by Erwin C. Hargrove"

A Clear Chapter by Chapter Synopsis of "The President as Leader" by Erwin C. Hargrove Following a distinguished career as a scholar f the American presidency, Erwin C. Hargrove in The President as Leader offers his capstone appraisal f presidential leadership. He builds on the theories f Richard Neustadt by stating that, in addition to bargaining and persuading, a president must be a moral leader in the mold f Aristotle who uses rhetoric to teach the ideals f the American experience. Case studies f real-life leaders help clarify Hargrove's complex model: Franklin Roosevelt, whom Hargrove regards as the model modern president because he used rhetoric to gain support for such significant policies as social security and an end to isolationism; Lyndon Johnson, who, although he inspired the public on civil rights, was frustrated by Vietnam because f his obsession with control; and Ronald Reagan, who connected with the public on values but faltered because he failed to verify the accuracy f his rhetoric. Primarily f interest to political scientists, the book is recommended for larger public and academic presidential studies collections. The chapter one of the book, Power and Purpose in Political Leadership, Hargrove defines characteristics of political leadership. As the title suggest, the chapter discusses as examples powers used by some American presidents. Hargrove argues that Carter's approach eschewed political advantage as a criterion for formulating policy, but that compromise might be necessary. The second chapter, Conceptions of Leadership, explains leadership qualities. The power f the policy to sustain itself is strengthened by comprehensiveness, which implies a long-term view rather than a quick fix. The importance of culture is discussed in the third chapter of the book, Cultural Leadership, where Hargrove has discussed cultural background of many American presidents. For Carter, political leadership was not so much doing what's right instead f what's political as it was doing the political in the right way. Consequently, existing theory is hard-pressed to classify the Carter administration on the basis f a predisposition for or against centralization. As a Democrat and political leader following a public goods approach to governing, it would not be unreasonable to expect a tendency toward centralization f policy making in the White House, especially on domestic priorities. This would allow Carter to control the content f policy important for his substantive approach. On the other hand, like most presidents, Carter entered office with an eye toward cabinet government and a reliance on expertise as a guiding force for policy making. Carter's public goods philosophy led him to choose experts to head governmental departments. This foreshadowed an approach to governance based on specialization and on a willingness to formulate substantive policy addressing major problems. Neither politics nor the strategy f politicization had much to do with cabinet appointments. Nelson Polsby notes that the Carter cabinet in particular was characterized by curious neutrality...toward the vast stew f interest groups...that make up the traditional Democratic coalition. In sum, using Carter as a case study presents a theoretical paradox. On the one hand, his theory f governing leads to the expectation that policy making, especially on domestic priorities, would be centralized. On the other, he valued expertise, which leads one to expect that he would place a high value on policy developed by civil servants in the bureaucracy. Thus, the analyst f presidential administration can learn much by examining the Carter experience. The fourth, fifth and sixth chapters of the books, tiled Franklin D. Roosevelt, Lyndon B. Johnson and Ronald Reagan, respectively, have discussed three great presidents of the United States as case studies. In these chapters, the writer has explained leadership, decision making and some other qualities of these president. One successful case and an unsuccessful one were chosen from each strategy (i.e. centralized, mixed, decentralized). The chosen policies were non-crisis domestic priorities because these provide a generalized base from which to examine policy making in the White House and to begin searching for sources and patterns f continuity and variation in presidential policy making. The policies that were determined to fit the categories are: the Youth Employment initiative (YE) and the creation f the Department f Education in the centralized strategy; the second energy proposal (Energy II) and welfare reform in the mixed category; and civil service reform (CSR) and national health insurance (NHI) in the delegated strategy. Further, a policy in each category was chosen for its "success" and the other for its "failure." The criteria for judging success and failure are laid out below. The cases, along with their concomitant strategies, are illustrated in Figure 1. Finally, all cases considered were presidential priorities as set by Carter himself and later confirmed by empirical work. Definitions follow previous work on this debate. "Neutral competence" is defined as substantive policy information, normally originating in the departments and agencies f the bureaucracy or by experts providing advice. I take the view that neutral competence is policy competence and thus primarily long-term, policy specific, and making little reference to affected political constituencies. In short, it seeks to aid the president in achieving his goals and leaves politics to others. The president's responsive agents are charged with guarding his professional prestige which in turn serves to protect his public prestige. Consequently, it might be better for the president to fight and lose on an issue f importance to him while the content f that issue remains faithful to his perception f political imperatives than it is for him to win on an issue that is sound in terms f policy substance but does irrevocable damage to his professional or public prestige. In the later chapters f The President as Leader Hargrove discusses successes and failures f successive presidents f the United States. When examining specific policies, the analysis takes a presidential perspective regarding what is deemed a success or a failure. "Success" is determined by the degree f cooperation and coordination among the various actors. The criterion f presidential satisfaction, defined as getting what is feasible from the process and accurately perceiving the politics surrounding an issue, is the measure f that degree f cooperation. f course, it is difficult to measure these in any quantitative sense. Determinations are made by impression, and impressions were checked against both the primary and secondary historical record. My analysis will argue that successful cases are characterized by such cooperation and coherence. Less successful cases, or "failures," are characterized by a breakdown or unevenness f cooperation and a faulty perception f the political possibilities surrounding the individual policy. The seventh and the last chapter of the book, Leadership of the Polity, is conclusion. The perception f the political possibilities surrounding an issue is defined as the degree to which the actors succeed or fail to assess the parameters f political feasibility. When referring to a policy process, "coordination" refers to at least two (and usually more) organizational entities providing information and advice with one f those entities (e.g. DPS) playing a mediating role by synthesizing for the president all relevant arguments and, where necessary or explicitly requested, advocating one or another f these perspectives. A "smooth process" is one in which each actor plays a role defined either by convention or by presidential direction, does not covertly seek political advantage, and the responsive agent acts as an "honest broker," i.e. bringing all relevant issues to the president's attention, giving equal weight to the importance f each. Given these parameters, I now turn to the empirical section. Welfare reform was a major goal f the Carter administration. Initially the policy formulation phase was split between the Departments f Labor, and Health, Education, and Welfare (HEW). Late in the process the strategy turned to one f mixing, but it was too late to impact the outcome effectively. One reason the DPS did not step in sooner and develop a more forceful role was that Carp, with Eizenstat's support, wanted Califano and Marshall to forge their own agreement. Initially, there was a standoff between HEW and DPS. Interestingly Califano let it be known that the staff was not to interfere and dilute his control f HEW, that is, not to treat cabinet secretaries as he had when he was in charge f domestic policy development for Lyndon Johnson. Carter felt that welfare reform should be managed by bureaucrats and officials in the agencies f the executive branch, with Califano and Marshall as the key players. However, it soon became obvious that someone would have to take the lead in brokering disputes, and DPS was selected for this function. The role f Carp and the staffers was to make clear to the agencies the president's intentions in the welfare debate. They were to mediate between the departments and guide the debate into political feasibility. Works Cited Hargrove, Erwin, C. 1998. The president as leader: Appealing...University Press f Kansas Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Clear Chapter by Chapter Synopsis of The President as Leader by Essay”, n.d.)
A Clear Chapter by Chapter Synopsis of The President as Leader by Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1511314-a-clear-chapter-by-chapter-synopsis-of-the-president-as-leader-by-erwin-c-hargrove
(A Clear Chapter by Chapter Synopsis of The President As Leader by Essay)
A Clear Chapter by Chapter Synopsis of The President As Leader by Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1511314-a-clear-chapter-by-chapter-synopsis-of-the-president-as-leader-by-erwin-c-hargrove.
“A Clear Chapter by Chapter Synopsis of The President As Leader by Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1511314-a-clear-chapter-by-chapter-synopsis-of-the-president-as-leader-by-erwin-c-hargrove.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Clear Chapter by Chapter Synopsis of The President as Leader by Erwin C. Hargrove

Poets and Revolutionaries: Three Women of Calcutta

It showed a lot of faces of… She was able to show in her book how the many different women of the country live their lives depending on where they live, how they were raised and the cultural norms and Summary Review of chapter 9:Poets and Revolutionaries: Three Women of Calcutta Elizabeth Bumiller's May You Be the Mother of a Hundred Sons chronicled different lives of women from India.... In chapter 9, Poets and Revolutionaries: Three Women of Calcutta, she reveals the lives and insights of three strong-willed and talented women in the city, Aparna Sen, a film maker, Nabaneeta Dev Sen, a poet and Veena Bhargava, a painter....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Dracula chapter 1-12

Through these pieces of correspondence, the reader learns about the arrival of Dracula to Britain and the mysterious illness that befalls Lucy, eventually leading to her death by the end of chapter 12, as she is treated by Seward and Van Helsing.... It is therefore difficult to come to the book without any pre-conceived ideas about the plot....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Chapter Summaries

The paper "chapter Summaries" presents that the first chapter discusses the main microeconomic factors shaping the interrelationship between job search and the structure of the labor market.... hellip; The last chapter seeks to further develop the findings and propositions in previous chapters by evaluating long term trends of average wages in order to determine patterns in wage growth in the last century and the cause of a real wage growth rebound since 1995....
8 Pages (2000 words) Literature review

CRITIQUE ON CHAPTER 7

This chapter once again introduced a large number of new technical terms, and this time they were mostly from the discipline of physics.... The example of water/ice/steam and different phases, is very chapter 7 Critique This chapter once again introduced a large number of new technical terms, and this time they were mostly from the discipline of physics.... An important feature of this chapter is that it assumes that the reader is familiar with material that has been presented in all the preceding chapters....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Chapters' summaries

The leader is bent upon impressing, and employs techniques like metaphor, examples and the so-called real-life experiences.... The leader has to deal with these standard tools with caution.... The intentions of the leader may be right; but it needs to be told at the right time.... The combination of the language tools employed by the leader may produce tangible effects on some; with others it may be quite contradictory.... The audience is intelligent enough to understand whether the leader's message comes out of his convictions or he is trying to outsmart the audience with clever use of the mixed messages and he is doing it quite deliberately....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Summery of chapter 11,12 and 13

However, the… s discussed and elaborated by these theories in all the three chapters concern traditional philosophical issues like knowledge among others explained below (Kline, Hollinger and Klemke, 114). One of the theories is the logical positivism theory which is also known as Summary of chapter 11, 12 and 13 The three chapters in the book discuss the contemporary theories of philosophy which have been developed and spread in the 20th Century.... he arguments presented in the chapters are not so clear and precise and may therefore lead to misunderstanding of the theories....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Chapter 10-12 questions

Jacksons stand handling of Eatons affairs also demonstrated that he was an autonomous leader who could not easily be swayed by the opinion of others as he stood his ground and supported Eaton under difficult circumstances (Brands, 2012).... seventh president.... seventh president.... Similarly, Jackson also surprised many by the way he handled the Peggy Eaton chapter 10-12 Questions al Affiliation chapter 10-12 Questions How did American culture reflect a growing spirit of popularsovereignty?...
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

The President as Leader by Erwin C. Hargrove

This book review "the president as leader by erwin c.... Hargrove" sheds some light on the American presidency, erwin c.... The role οf Carp and the staffers was to make clear to the agencies the president's intentions in the welfare debate.... hargrove President Leader offers his capstone appraisal οf presidential leadership.... n chapter one of the book, Power and Purpose in Political Leadership, hargrove defines characteristics of political leadership....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us