StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Factors toward a New Decision-making Model - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Factors toward a New Decision-making Model" demonstrates the assessment of the example using Simon’s Bounded Rationality Theory. Rational decisions are not always made by people. Most of the time, the decisions are partially rational and partially irrational or emotional…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.3% of users find it useful
Factors toward a New Decision-making Model
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Factors toward a New Decision-making Model"

? Topic - Observation Review Rational decisions are not always made by people. Most of the time, the decisions are partially rational and partially irrational or emotional. Bounded decision making is a principle according to which a person makes a decision based on only few truths or facts with limited computational outcomes (Gigerenzer & Selten, 2008). In other words, such a decision maker has the tendency to deduce the most easily available and satisfactory solution instead of an optimal solution. By saying ‘the most satisfactory solution’, we mean the solution that is arrived at after simplifying the facts that are available due to lack of proper resources and many other factors. The decision made by Christopher Bale, who was the chief site engineer at a construction firm, where I have worked can be cited as exemplifying the concept of bounded rationality. The work contains my personal observation and experience regarding the decision making process of the organization. In the case, Mr. Bale had decided to increase the working hours of the construction workers to two hours in the morning shift. The normal routine shift usually started from 8 a.m. in the morning and continued till 5pm in the evening. The company had entered into a deal according to which it had to construct a multistoried building. Initially the contract was to be completed in a two years time. But later the contract had to be renewed and its duration was lessened by six months. This put pressure on the executives to complete the work fast. Therefore, the chief site engineer, Mr. Bale, decided to increase the working hours and, correspondingly, compensation of the employees. The decision was not favored by the employees as they felt their opinion was not considered. Secondly, a few of the employees who were more than 50 year old felt that it would affect their health if they were made to work beyond the routine hours. Assessment of the Example Using Simon’s Bounded Rationality Theory In the example mentioned above, Bale thought it would be feasible for the company to increase the working hours of the site workers so as to complete the work on time. This is a clear example of bounded rationality as the site engineer had taken the decision after examining the available choices only. He did not have knowledge about the resentment, if any, that would be prevailing among the workers due to the increase in the number of work hours. He was also unaware of the health conditions of the senior employees. The decision taken by Bale can be considered to be an example of decision making based on normative affective factors (Etzioni, 1988). It is more of a normative model because Bale made the decision assuming he had all the necessary information needed to make the choice. Thus it was more of a descriptive form of decision making instead of a prescriptive form (Holloway, 2003). This descriptive form of making decisions was termed as bounded rationality by Simon. Simon theorized that human beings often settle for solutions that are mostly satisfying in nature, which means that such solutions, though they are sufficient to cope with the situation, are not the best solutions (Turban, 2008). There are many factors that can affect a decision. These can be psychological, sociological, political, risk avoidance motives, etc. These can influence the choice of the decision made considerably. In the context of the case, it can be understood that the company executives were put under tremendous strain to complete the construction work six months ahead of the contracted time initially stipulated. They had to come up with a solution so as to complete the work fast as their commitment and their reputation were at stake. In such a situation it is possible that when the decisions were made, not all the crucial factors were considered. Two such factors were the workers’ opinions on the decision to increase work hours and the health condition of some workers. The chief site engineer had suggested the idea to increase the work day of the morning shift by two hours; he thought that the workers who were able to work for 8 to 9 hours daily would not face many problems if they were made to work two hours extra. Besides, they were also compensated for the extra hours. Bale had overseen the fact that most of them were married persons and that they would find it difficult to stay for extra hours at the construction site for six months. The case also highlights Simon’s observation that individuals in an organization tend to make the first available choice as the final decision, which, unfortunately, is devoid of cognitive thoughts (Tolbert & Hall, 2008). According to the theory of bounded rationality, an organization could achieve greater efficiency in its decisions if all the members in the company hierarchy participate in the decision making process (Simon, 1997). This would include all the factors, even the subdued ones, which could make considerable impact on the decision. In the case described in the paper, the responsibility of completing the work was put on the shoulders of the site engineer. He would have been held responsible for any delay in it. This applied strain on Bale, which made him choose the best possible and, at the same time, the most easily available solution, which was to increase the working hours. Because of the psychological constraint, Bale did not feel the importance to take into consideration the opinions of the workers union of the company. He held the notion that it would not be difficult for the workers to put in extra hours, especially on the grounds they would be paid for it. He underestimated the psychological and social needs of the workers. Secondly, to understand whether or not the workers will be able to endure the extra hours for such a long period, Bale had not considered it important to check the upper age limit of the workers and their physical condition. These factors show that the decision taken by Bale was not rational, i.e. was bounded, even though he considered it to be the best possible solution. Review of the Decision Made by Bale – a Personal Reflection The bounded rationality model suggested that the computational skills of humans are lower than the perceived difficulty level of the environment (Bianchi, 1990). This means that we are not able to understand the required efficiencies in decision making. In the context of the case, I would have firstly tried to understand the changes that would be required to complete the work within a new time period. This would have incorporated many aspects like introducing new working methods. This would have been a time-consuming work. Using the theories of bounded rationality, which suggest the involvement of the entire hierarchy, I would have sought help of other members of the organization. Bale had not understood the importance of involving the workers in his decisions. The decision taken by Bale was not received warmly by this section. There were also issues with the health condition of the elder workers. According to the bounded theory of rationality model, complex problems of this kind can be solved through the use of heuristic methods, recognizing the problem, and by pattern recognition along with extrapolation. These features would help the organization to arrive at the most adaptable solution optimizing the amounts of computation. Reflecting on the above discussion, it would be feasible to study the complexity of the problem instead of finding ways of solving it. Therefore, in the case the solution would be to study and understand the complexity of the problem. This would help devise appropriate measures to solve the problem. Simon has discussed the need to integrate different hierarchical levels to arrive at a solution (Simon, 1997). I would have ensured that the members of the organization actively participate in the decision making. Right from the top level to the front line managers, all would have had to contribute to the decision making process. This would have helped in arriving at the most feasible solution ensuring that the construction work is completed within the allotted time. This would have reduced the pressure on the site engineer considerably. Instead of arriving at a solution hastily, it would be better to think over and analyze the problem first. The problem here was the reduction of the amount of time required for the completion of the project. Instead of increasing the working hours, the management could have integrated their thoughts and resources for arriving at a better solution. They could have sought help of experienced professionals who had faced similar situations in their workplaces. A detailed investigated solution would have ensured the workers are heard, too. This plays a vital role as the company is run by all its workers. Incorporation of the hierarchy members would thus mean involving their opinions, too. Therefore, Simon’s bounded form of rationality helps understand the underlying weaknesses – the lack of cognitive factors, for instance – which can affect a decision making process. References Bainchi, Marine. (1990). The Unsatisfactoriness of satisficing: From bounded rationality to innovative rationality. Retrieved from http://cas.umkc.edu/econ/economics/faculty/Lee/courses/502/reading/pwm3.pdf 1990 Etzioni, Amitai. (1988). Normative-affective factors toward a new decision-making model”. Journal of Economic Psychology, 9, 125-150. Retrieved from http://www.amitaietzioni.org/documents/A186.pdf Gigerenzer, Gerd, & Sehten, Reinhard. (2008). Bounded rationality: The adaptive toolbox. The MIT press. Holloway, Stephen. (2003). Straight and level: Practical airline economics. Ash Gate Publishing. Simon, Herbert A. (1997). Models of Bounded Rationality, Vol. 3, MIT Press Turban, Efraim. (2008). Decision support and business intelligence systems, 8/E. Greenwood Publishing Group. Tolbert, Pamela, & Hall, Richard. (2008). Decision making in organizations: Structures, processes and outcomes. Pearson Education Inc. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Factors toward a New Decision-making Model Essay, n.d.)
Factors toward a New Decision-making Model Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1457606-observation-review
(Factors Toward a New Decision-Making Model Essay)
Factors Toward a New Decision-Making Model Essay. https://studentshare.org/management/1457606-observation-review.
“Factors Toward a New Decision-Making Model Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1457606-observation-review.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Factors toward a New Decision-making Model

Importance of Decision-Making in Advanced Critical Theories

Importance of decision-making Different ways of performing a task give rise to the necessity of decision-making.... decision-making allows choosing the best option available in a course of action.... The Process of decision-making Clinical decision making requires the early development of hypothesis diagnosis (Ramezani-Badr, Nasrabadi, Nikbakht, Zohre and Taleghani, 2009).... Ineffective decision-making Effective use of assessment information through decision making process is essential to improve the outcome of the critical care (Gambrill, 2005)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

The Relationship among Decisions Using Decision-Making Models

This paper ''Decision Making Assignment'' tells that decision-making can be termed as a process that involves selecting an alternative course of action and results in getting what you want by using knowledge or what one can learn.... The essay will assess the relationship among decisions using decision-making models.... One possible alternative cannot constitute decision-making process....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Customer Behaviour and Customer Decision Making Processes

This paper is being carried out to evaluate and present the influence of customer behavior and decision-making processes on profitability in the personal computer market in the United Kingdom.... hellip; This paper "Customer Behaviour and Customer decision-making Processes" aims to determine the factors that influence the customer decision-making process in the home computer industry in the UK.... The secondary aim of this research is to examine how these decision-making processes affect consumer behavior in this industry in the UK....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Proposal

Describe the decision making model

A health care manager may be faced with the decision of whether to employ a new driver or pay overtime wages to the current drivers.... He/she should also consider if by employing a new driver will works towards the demoralization of the already hired drivers.... Decision making is the process of evaluating the various options available, benefits and costs related to them, and selecting one The Decision Making model It has been the practice of the people involved in the management of businesses to engage in decision making....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Decision-Making Paper

The main models of making decisions are the rational model, the intuitive model, the combination model, and satisfying model.... The rational decision making model is an approach to decision making in a structured and sequential form.... It is an ideal model since it provides a discipline channel of making decision.... However, this model is quit time consuming as it involves investigation of the existing problems or opportunity before the course of action is made (Amadi-Echendu, 2012, p....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Strategic Management Model and Strategic Decision-Making

hellip; This discussion talks that the strategic management model arguably envisages the mission statement of the business and Wheelan and Hunger's central argument is that a corporate mission is a purpose or reason for the corporation's existence under the management model, which contrasts to the proactive decision-making process.... t is submitted that this backdrop further correlates to Wheelan & Hunger's (2008) discussion of the role of the strategic management model versus the strategic decision making process....
29 Pages (7250 words) Coursework

Theories of Decision-Making

The paper "decision-making" concerns defining, structuring, and explaining how decision-making works, its theories, paradoxes, and so on.... This makes them subjective rather than objective in their decision-making pattern.... Hence, fear is also one of the factors that dominate decision making.... This shows that there are hundreds of different factors that influence the decision making of a person....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Consumer Decision Making Process

"Consumer Decision Making Process" paper study focuses on consumer behavior regarding the purchase of a new car.... nbsp;… The customer is making a purchase of a new car is identified to focus on different factors for making his buying decision.... The consumer in order to make the purchase a new car mainly looks at his capacity of purchasing a new car.... The aim of the paper is to highlight the consumer decision-making process and accordingly, evaluate the factors, which influence buyers' decisions....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us