StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Differences between Written and Verbal Contracts (Bluto vs. Wimpy) - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Differences between Written and Verbal Contracts: The Case of Bluto v Wimpy Instructor Institution Date Differences between Written and Verbal Contracts: The Case of Bluto v Wimpy. The Facts of the Case Wimpy offers to sell Bluto a boat for $500…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
Differences between Written and Verbal Contracts (Bluto vs. Wimpy)
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Differences between Written and Verbal Contracts (Bluto vs. Wimpy)"

Differences between Written and Verbal Contracts: The Case of Bluto v Wimpy Differences between Written andVerbal Contracts: The Case of Bluto v Wimpy. The Facts of the Case Wimpy offers to sell Bluto a boat for $500. Bluto replies, “I think I want the boat, but let me have a week to consider.” Wimpy replies, “OK. I won’t sell the boat to anyone until after one week from today.” The next day, Wimpy sells the boat to Popeye for $600. The day after, Wimpy tells Bluto he already sold the boat.

Nevertheless, Bluto tenders $500. Main Issues The main issue under investigation in this case is whether a mere intention to buy creates a legally binding acceptance to an offer in a contract. The second core issue to investigate in this case is whether Wimpy’s commitment not to sell the boat until a one week period elapses creates a contractual obligation to perform the sale of the boat or whether it was a simple gentleman’s agreement that has no basis for action in contract law. Thirdly, it would be important to consider whether Wimpy’s offer to sell a boat to Wimpy under no clear and certain terms of sale constituted a valid offer or a mere invitation to treat.

The court hearing this case will also seek to elaborate on the extent to which inclusion of an illusionary promise in contract bargaining invalidates the contract. The Rule Applicable Two main concepts of contact law are applicable in this scenario. The first rule concerns the concept of invitation to treat alongside the doctrine of limitations and the statute of frauds. Analysis of the Case In this case, Wimpy has no contractual obligation to sell the boat to Bluto because in essence there can be no breach of a contract that is not in existence.

A valid contract requires the presence of a valid offer from the offeror to sell or discharge of his/her property at a stated fee, often referred to as the consideration. The offer must be met by an express or implied acceptance indicating the willingness to buy the property in question in the terms and conditions specified by the offeror. The offer must be devoid of ambiguity and expressly state the nature of performance. In the scenario of Wimpy v Bluto, the indication by Wimpy that he is willing to sell his boat to Bluto at $ 500 can be treated as a mere intention to sell rather than an offer to sell the boat.

It is an indication of a desired price at which he would dispose of the boat rather than a settlement or an agreement to sell the boat (Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Companyn1893) . Omissions of when and where he intends the boat makes the offer ambiguous and vague. Secondly, the agreement between Wimpy and Bluto is unenforceable because it lacks valid acceptance to buy. When Bluto said that he needed a one week period to consider his decision to buy the boat, he fails to expressly accept the offer to purchase the at the stated consideration amount.

The promise by Bluto that he would buy the boat only after taking a week to rethink deliberate is illusionary as it unduly gives him the option of nonperformance should he consider opting out of the agreement. This illusionary promise to buy at a later date fails to meet the threshold for a proper acceptance of Wimpy’s offer and as such renders the contract invalid. Additionally, Wimpy’s promise not to sell was verbal, never witnesses and hence cannot be authenticated. As such, that promise was a simple gentleman’s agreement that does not create any legal relations between Wimpy and Bluto.

If Wimpy were a merchant and his promise not to sell the boat for one week was in writing, the contract still remains invalid and unenforceable because Bluto’ promise to pay a sum of $ 500 in a week’s time is lacking in consideration or legal motive to induce the contract. The promise to buy lacks any surety and will leave Wimpy with no remedy if Bluto defaults. Conclusion The enforceability of an oral contract depends on the parties’ ability to prove its creation and existence. If not properly witnessed, most oral agreements fail the validity test of a contract, especially where no consideration is involved.

These are often treated as simple gentleman’s agreement. Wimpy’s offer to sell was a mere indication of the motive rather than an action to sell the boat to Bluto. Bluto’s promise to buy the boat after a week’s rethink is lacking consideration and legal motive to induce an acceptance hence fails to meet the threshold of a valid acceptance to an offer. As such no breach exists in this case as there was no contract in the first place. However, receipt of money in lieu of a non –existent contract is fraudulent and the affected parties have a chance to recover the money paid if there exists a valid proof of the same.

Bluto’s Remedies Even though no valid contract exists between Wimpy and Bluto, Bluto can still sue Wimpy for fraudulent conduct since he (Wimpy) went ahead to receive money from Bluto despite his full knowledge that the boat had already been sold to someone else. On selling the boat, it have been prudent for Wimpy to not accept Bltuo’s due impossibility of performance occasioned but the non existence of the subject matter (the boat). Furthermore, silence on the part of Wimpy having sold the bought from someone else and receiving money from Bluto would have implied an acceptance to sell a boat which ordinarily was not in existence anymore.

This was fraudulent and Wimpy should be made to recompense Bluto all the monies paid thereof. Reference Morgan, J., Shedd, P., and Corley, R. (2010). Business Law, 3rd Edition. BVT Publishing

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Differences between Written and Verbal Contracts (Bluto vs. Wimpy) Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1440520-differences-between-written-and-verbal-contracts
(Differences Between Written and Verbal Contracts (Bluto Vs. Wimpy) Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1440520-differences-between-written-and-verbal-contracts.
“Differences Between Written and Verbal Contracts (Bluto Vs. Wimpy) Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1440520-differences-between-written-and-verbal-contracts.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Differences between Written and Verbal Contracts (Bluto vs. Wimpy)

We live in a layered world

How circumscribed are such optimum areas, and how much history, and what deep cultural relations have flowed out of the contrast between well-favored and ill-favored regions.... It is true that we live in a layered world, our earth's surface remain terra incognita to-day,for ease of movement and other technological developments have made possible an almost comprehensive knowledge of the terrain,much of which is now mapped....
66 Pages (16500 words) Essay

The Literature of exile and imaginary homelands in Salman Rushdie's Midnight's Children

This essay talks about Salman Rushdie's novels “Midnight's Children” and “The Satanic Verses”.... It describes a way of national identification which differs from the usual concept.... The spatial perspective in Salman Rushdie's novels is linked to the reconstruction of the notion of home....
44 Pages (11000 words) Essay

What Are the Main Differences between Contract and Tort

The paper "What Are the Main differences between Contract and Tort" highlights that the plaintiffs may claim damages or compensation in the event of loss of property or injury to another person where it can be proved that the day of duty care has been neglected.... On the other hand, tort law can be described as a civil wrong not arising from a contract and in the case of negligence, one should owe due consideration to one's neighbour (Capiro Industries vs.... With regards to employment contracts, there ought to be written agreement which binds the two parties to honour their contractual obligations which can be enforceable in the court of law should one party defaults....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Written vs Verbal Communication

In the essay “Written vs Verbal Communication,” the author discusses the issue when many people feel very shy while conversing with others in everyday life.... There can be different reasons for this including the inferiority complex.... Improving self-esteem requires practice....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Oral Contracts

An important difference between written and oral contracts is in the time taken to sue for breaching of an oral contract is at times shorter.... Oral contracts are also either partially in writing as well as partially dependent, usually on words that are spoken or totally dependent on words that are… Oral contracts are just as valid as written agreements; however the key issue with these types of contracts is proving of their existence or the agreed terms....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Difference between void contracts and voidable contracts

So if one (or more) of the above elements is found to be missing differences between Void Contracts and Voidable Contracts I.... of the differences between Void Contracts and VoidableContractVoid Contract In most simple terms, a void contract can be defined as: “A contract having no legal force or binding effect” (Cross and Miller 2011, p.... ifferences There are key differences between void and voidable contracts.... Firstly, void contracts are itself a category of contracts....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

The Differences between Genders in Expressing Verbal Emotions

the chapter on "Gender and verbal and non-verbal communication" (p.... The author uses a range of data to explore the differences between the genders in spoken and written English.... Harris, is of key significance since it highlights the key differences between the genders with regard to verbal communication.... The chapter on "Gendered differences in language and aggressive / augmentative communication" in particular offers interesting insights the stereotypical verbal communication attributed to both the genders, that confines women to use a more ladylike language while the males are expected to more intense and authoritative....
4 Pages (1000 words) Annotated Bibliography

The Differences between Australian Contract Law and Brazilian Contract Law

The paper 'The differences between Australian Contract Law and Brazilian Contract Law' presents differences that will be relevant for determining the validity and enforceability of contracts and are especially important for contracts that will be governed by Brazilian law.... hellip; The most salient distinction between Brazilian and Australian contract law is the doctrine of freedom of contract....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us