StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Business Employment Law - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper "Business Employment Law" touches upon the law that concerns employees. Admittedly, the need to establish and maintain objectivity during the process of hiring employees is key to defending accusations of unlawful discrimination…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful
Business Employment Law
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Business Employment Law"

Business Employment Law: Dunlap v. Tennessee Valley ity case Introduction The need to establish and maintain objectivity during the process of hiring employees is key to defending accusations of unlawful discrimination. The case scenario of Dunlap v. Tennessee Valley Authority reflects the course of events when there is manipulation in the hiring process to achieve desired result. In this case, it features an African-American applicant called David Dunlap who is 52 years old. He had a work experience of 20 years working as a boilermaker, including 15 years of experience as a foreman for a boil-makers crew (Find Law, 2008). Notably, most of the experience he gained while working as a temporary worker at various Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) facilities in Tennessee. The claim was that he had applied for a position in TVA without getting even an interview, despite his vast experience while working for TVA (Find Law, 2008). The case followed that it was along the lines of racial discrimination that he did not get the position of interview since the hiring committee consisted of nine white members and a single African-American member. The legal issues in the case In the case, David Dunlap filed the suit against the Tennessee Valley Authority in the District Court with claims that he faced racial discrimination, which is contrary to the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act established in 1964 (Find Law, 2008). In the first case, the courts evaluated the claims as he presented on the basics of the law available, incorporating the key elements notable to the case. The District court in this case realized that TVA was subjective as Mr. Dunlap faced acts that amounted to disparate treatment, disparate impact and disparate analysis. The belief was that TVA in its hiring procedures was practicing acts of racial discrimination and biases against Mr. Dunlap, as well as, other applicants of the African American race (Walsh, 2010). Notably, Mr. Dunlap presented claims that showed the aspects of priority given to the white over the black people, irrespective of them having better qualifications and work experiences than the white people. However, Mr. Dunlap failed to prove the case regarding disparate impact. The case later proceeded to the U.S. Court of Appeal with the legal issue being, to establish whether Dunlap fulfilled the burden of proof in the case, in addition to establishing the correctness of the District Court findings. The Court if Appeal confirmed the decisions of the District Court in the case, as they cited the insufficient evidence for disparate treatment. They also upheld the decision on awards for the damages and fees (Find Law, 2008). However, the Court of Appeal reversed the verdict on disparate impact. Why the plaintiff’s disparate, (adverse) impact claim failed Mr. Dunlap suit alleged that TVA manipulated the process of selection, causing the disparate impact on the minority candidates. He alleged he was a victim of intentional disparate treatment that both violate the Title VII. In analysis, the impact theory expects the employee or job applicant to ensure they demonstrate that an apparent employment practice affects a given group harshly (Emerson, 2009). In addition, that the employment practice favors the other side without justification. The countering side, that is the employer, in this case TVA should show that the manifest procedure relates to the employment process, an argument called “business necessity” justification (Find Law, 2008). Therefore, analyzing the case contents from this forgoing establishment, the District Court concluded that there was manipulation of the interview process to exclude the African American applicants (Walsh, 2010). The Court of Appeal disagreed, citing that the case lacked statistical proof to demonstrate successfully that the cited group was adversely affected. Further, Dunlap failed to show how the selected protocol served the interests of the employer creating the undesirable discriminatory effects. Therefore, Mr. Dunlap failed on his claim since he only based his arguments on the interview; hence, lacking sufficient evidence. Why the plaintiff’s disparate, treatment claim succeeded In the claims for disparate treatment, as articulated in the law requires the plaintiff demonstrate that the employer favorably treated some people and showed bias on other basing on their race, color, race, sex or religion (Emerson, 2009). In analyzing the case, the bench considers whether the plaintiff meets his burden of ultimate factual inquiry as designated in Title VII. Under the disparate treatment theory, establishing proof of discriminatory motive is a critical component of the case. Mr. Dunlap alleged that the TVA was intentionally discriminating against him along the basis of his race. The district court, as well as, the Court of Appeal both agreed that he established a reliable prima facie which was minimally sufficient for the case of disparate treatment. He showed that as is African American thus qualifying for application of the claim. He had the qualifications required for the post he sought at TVA. Additionally, in comparison to the white applicants, he had experience higher than the white applicants did. Hence, he used this argument for showing the case of discrimination in the hiring process (Walsh, 2010). The TVA rebuts an inference that is non-discriminatory as required in the law for rejecting him, citing the matrix for his interview scores. TVA argued that his scores were low, failing to enlist him in the selection list. Following this rebut, Dunlap showed the burden of proof, arguing this was a pretext to override the discriminatorily intent. He so established this by facilitating evidence that his matrix score for the interview was manipulated so that he could not reach the top ten qualified applicants. The courts noted the weight given to the interviews instituted a subjective process, despite TVA policy (Find Law, 2008). Additionally, the interview also lacked an objective evaluation as the questions used allowed alteration of scores to produce results with racial biases. Hence, from this evidence, his claims for disparate treatment succeeded. What TVA should have done differently regarding interviewing and selecting candidates for the jobs Hiring most qualified applicants in a job is a remarkably sensitive process. The TVA’s selection committee factor of manipulating the applicants’ scores stripped their defense for the case on disparate treatment (Find Law, 2008). For TVA to facilitate its hiring and interviewing processes for the jobs, it should institute core policies and other cooperate directives that align with their desired goals. The committee should have avoided using objective measures for evaluating the applicants (Cihon & Castagnera, 2008). For instance, it should have avoided questions that feature physical characteristics of applicants, in addition to other stereotyping aspects that impair the selection process. References Cihon, Patrick J., & Castagnera, James Ottavio. (2008). Employment and Labor Law. South- Western Pub. Emerson, R. W. (2009). Business law. Hauppauge, N.Y: Barrons Educational Series. Walsh, D. J. (2010). Employment law for human resource practice. Mason, OH: South-Western Cengage Learning. Find Law, ( 2008). United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit: David Dunlap, Plaintiff- Appellee, V. Tennessee Valley Authority, Defendant-Appellant. No. 07-5381. Decided: March 21, 2008. Retrieved from http://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-6th-circuit/1092121.html Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Business Employment Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1661608-business-employment-law
(Business Employment Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1661608-business-employment-law.
“Business Employment Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1661608-business-employment-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Business Employment Law

Employment Law for Business

he main purpose for this study is to examine the general outcomes of sexual harassment lawsuits for employees and employers, to help end the increasing sexual harassment cases between the employers and their employees and lastly to bring the true picture of law regarding sexual harassment.... lthough the estimates shows that majority of victims filing cases are women there has been an increase on recorded cases of men filing against the female workers, a good example is the Britain's equal employment opportunities commission (Britain's EEOC) which has recorded eight percent sexual complaints coming from men....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Business & Employment Law

rom the perspective of the law, an invitation to treat does not constitute a contractual offer.... In the absence of a valid offer and acceptance, there cannot be a legally binding contract.... The acceptance of an offer is valid, only if it is unconditional, unequivocal, and has been communicated effectively to the… 2 ...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Solving Business Problems and Scenarios - Ford Pinto Car Model

Case laws can be defined as a group of rulings that are existent and have managed to make new interpretations of the law hence can be quoted as precedent.... This means that no law will solve a problem that is not someway provided for in that law, and correspondingly, most business problems are not crimes till they have been recognized and a rule has been applied against them (Collins 2010, p.... nother problem seen in laws applying to business scenarios is that such laws tend to create a negative portrayal of the relationship between ethics and law....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Employment Business Law

The rape of the coworker occurred in a work environment according to Title vii of the 1964 civil rights act and the New York State human rights law.... The law violated in this case is the law… The airline is responsible for renting hotel rooms for its workers as opposed to them going home at the end of a working day.... Though the airline does not recommend Employment business law Employment business law Case one In a way, the airline was liable for the sexual harassment to the flight attendant....
1 Pages (250 words) Coursework

Employment Business Law

How should employers who need employees to be on-call structure these arrangements to conform to the law while minimizing overtime… Overtime work is generally a measure of increasing productivity and meeting the deadline stipulated for specific tasks within organizations.... In order to maximize profits, employers should come up with lawful measures of Employment Business law Employment Business law Q.... How should employers who need employees to be on-call structure these arrangements to conform to the law while minimizing overtime liability?...
1 Pages (250 words) Coursework

Nuances of Business and Employment Law

The agreement that was to occur between the two parties were not confirmed by the law due to the fact that the agreement between the two was not reviewed.... Consideration as an element of an agreement for sale between the two parties was not agreed that could make them being bounded by the law to take the particular exchange of the book....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Business Organizations; Employment Law

n addition to the inadequacies of the management, there was no auditor Business Organizations; employment law al Affiliation) Adelphia Communications represents one of the most ideal cases for analyzing ethical issues on a global platform.... Improvement and reform of corporate law has been mandated following the scandal.... It mandates securities lawyers to prevent violations of securities law by companies or a company employee breaching his/her fiduciary duty to shareholders....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Employment Law for Business: At-Will Employment

The law recognizes two types of labor relations: employee-employer and contractor-contracting party.... The paper will attempt to discuss the history of prominent employment contracts and to contextualize the geographical contexts where it is found.... the term “employer” can be defined as “a readily identifiable identity, …, any person, partnership, corporate body or unincorporated association who (which) employs one or more persons under a contract of employment”....
15 Pages (3750 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us