StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Feminist Jurisprudence and Work Discrimination - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Feminist Jurisprudence and Work Discrimination " is a great example of a finance and accounting essay. Studies have shown that the majority of the culprits of workplace gender discrimination are women. The underlying principle of the feminist legal school of thought is to establish the root cause of this problem in an attempt to empower the status of women workers in a male-dominated corporate world…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Feminist Jurisprudence and Work Discrimination"

Name: University/ College: Lecturer: Course: Date: Studies have shown that majority of the culprits of workplace gender discrimination are women. The underlying principle of the feminist legal school of thought is to establish the root cause of this problem in an attempt to empower the status of women workers in a male dominated corporate world. Though the various feminist jurisprudence models have registered remarkable progress in the empowerment cause, there are some limitations to their approach to the same. A discursive analysis of three feminist legal schools of thought –liberal feminism, black feminism and sex-difference model shows how their approach in handling this problem, their progress and the subsequent limitations to their cause. Feminist legal theory and workplace discrimination In an attempt to tackle the issue of women discrimination at work, it is prudent to note from the onset, the root cause of this discrimination by comprehending the causal dynamics that breed discriminative attitudes, notions and behaviour. Studying the fundamental cause of discriminative behaviour beats assessing the surface level indicators of the same. Like in all other forms of discrimination, traditional gender stereotyping triggers workplace sex discrimination. Gender stereotyping takes the form of pre-existing notions that masculinity is the superior gender. It also results from men’s insecurities concerning the unknown productivity of women, which cause them to be intimidated (Moult, 2009). The liberal equality model The liberal feminist school was endorsed by inter alia Rebecca Walker, Stuart Mill, Betty Friedan and Mary Wollstonecraft. This school asserts equality of both genders. They insist on equality of opportunities for both men and women reiterating that women share the same capabilities as men. In the US, proponents of the liberal school relentlessly lobby for the ratification of the Equality Rights Amendment especially so to curb the issue of workplace sex discrimination. Wollstonecraft insists that both men and women share the same credibility only that men get undue advantage to realise their full potential. She held that in the contemporary occupational setting, women experience sex discrimination through the covert acts of their male counterparts. They are denied mentorship, left out in informal workplace interactions and more demeaning, treated as sexual objects. John Stuart Mills, in defence of liberal feminism, noted that men are actually not superior to women. He held that this traditional perception is attributable to the fact that most men are intimidated by women’s potential, which in turn leads to fears that women might turn out to be more productive than men do. Mills affirmed that, given equal opportunities, female workers show more dedication to work as they do to their domestic duties. Gender mainstreaming This concept was coined during the 1985 Third World Conference on Women held in Nairobi, Kenya where it was described as “the public policy concept of assessing the different implications for women and men of any planned policy action, including legislation and programs, in all areas and levels” (Finley, 1989) Gender mainstreaming primarily aimed at alleviating economic, social and political disparities that women face. The liberal school elevated this concept with the definitive goal of attaining gender equality. Liberal feminist theorists championed for reforms in the political, social and cultural realms as a means to realising women empowerment in the third world. The UN Economic and Social Council concurred as much and sought to make both genders’ concerns an integral element in the legislative policies, planned action and programs of member states. Limitations of liberal feminism Though their concerns are properly motivated, the liberal feminist school lays too much emphasis on gender equality. Owing to the pre-existing structural disparities, gender equality in not feasible. The initiatives of this school are based on unrealistic goals such as a rigorous allocation of resources to achieve structural balance. They ought to have championed for equity as opposed to equality. Radical feminist Mary Daly Before her demise in January 2010, Mary Daly sought to empower women workers amid a male dominated corporate world. She championed for an absolute reconfiguration of the current patriarchal society in her effort to boost the welfare of female employees in upstate New York during her days as a lecture in the prestigious New York University. Daly urged women in the occupational setting to assert their positions without fear of their male colleagues. She held that patriarchy thrives in women’s fear of action. Daly criticised liberal feminism for merely threatening to take action while doing nothing. Her philosophy was elaborated in a famous quote; “a tiger does not declare its ‘tigrihood’, it pounces.” She cautioned women that they could not earn respect from male colleagues; they can only command it. Daly championed for women action to curb male dominance (Hoagland & Frye, 2000). The sexual-difference feminist legal theory Unlike the preceding school of thought, the sexual difference model recognises the fact that men and women are not equal. This school faults liberal feminism for basing their theory on false premise that women and men are equal instead of recognising that there are indeed real and tangible differences in the capabilities of both genders. The principle concern of this model is for the law to appreciate gender differences and subsequently provide for them. They push for law reforms to eliminate the provisional obscurity of the legislation on workplace gender discrimination. Once the law unequivocally accounts for gender equity, it allows women to seek legal redress whenever they feel sexually offended by the men workers (MacKinnon, 1983). Case study: Thompson v Courier Newspapers In this case, an Administrative Decisions Tribunal fined the Sydney based newspaper publisher for occupational sex discrimination. The tribunal found the publisher guilty of prejudicing against Christine Thompson on account of her assertiveness, which in turn intimidated her direct supervisor. The tribunal deemed inappropriate and unethical the fact that men workers watched naked women in the office computer mainframe with no due regard to Thompson’s feelings. Courier Newspapers was compelled to compensate her as follows; a sum of $ 4,875 for preferential treatment of her male counterparts at her expense and another $ 650 for inappropriate training. The tribunal imposed a further $ 1300 since the male workers watched women pornography at the workplace (Moult, 2009). Still on gender discrimination, sex-difference school champions for fair treatment of both male and female employees – job equity. Proponents of the theory reiterate that their primary concern is equity and not equality. They hold that the idea of equality in the workplace can only have negative connotations as opposed to striving for equity. The notion of sex discrimination is so entrenched in women’s mind that sometimes they tend to think they are being treated unfairly. Echoing the same, psychologist Julian Baker affirmed that gender discrimination is at times a mental phenomenon. Due to the traditional trend in the occupational context, women perceive their male colleagues as patriarchal while this may not be the case. Limitations The black feminist hardliners have criticised the leniency of the sex difference model on male domination. They hold that this attitude is responsible for the continued marginalisation of women over the years and as such is intolerable. Similarly, the liberal feminists refute the claims that both genders are inherently different. They dismiss this outlook as incorrect if not misguided. Black feminism This feminist school asserts that sex and racial discrimination as well as class oppression are intertwined. Proponents of this feminist school include the Combahee River Collective, Patricia Hill-Collins and Marilyn Frye among others. They are all dedicated to eradicate women oppression that they feel emanates from a network of systematically related obstacles, which inhibit women empowerment (Rhode, 1990). Frye uses the analogy of a bird in a cage to illustrate how oppression occurs within a framework of systematically related obstacles. She explains the individual components of the cage – wires, nuts etc are of least hindrance to its escape. The bird is held captive by the interrelation of the components of entire structure. Much in the same way, there is a set of inevitable societal factors that significantly hinder the course of women empowerment. Such factors include inter alia women apprehension of inferiority and double bind – oppressed women have, at their disposal, few redemption courses all of which cost them ridicule and censure (Frye 1983). Black feminists are particularly disturbed by the issue of workplace gender that mostly affects women employees. They hold that in the occupational setting, gender stereotyping, class oppression and discrimination based on sexual orientation are increasingly making women workers vulnerable. Due to gender stereotyping for instance, job evaluators are biased against women and as such, they overlook their productivity and potential. Similarly, while conducting interviews for job selections, interviewers are more likely to recommend men over women regardless of whether they share the same credentials. Since its formation in1974, the Combahee initiative strives to eliminate those structural injustices that are biased against the female worker. In their black feminist statement, they refer to the structural injustices against women workers as ‘interlocking systems of oppression.’ Women psychologists who are proponents of this school explain that discriminatory work settings cause women to be less productive and more detached from their obligations. This in turn leads to poor performance by the affected women and consequently, the organisation at large. They urge male colleagues to treat women workers with due esteem to avoid such situations (The Combahee River Collective, 1982). Limitations Black feminism focuses more on class oppression and racial discrimination and less on workplace sex discrimination. In their course of black women liberation, they overlook the need to liberate other women workers from different races who share the same predicament as they do (Bartlett, 1990). Conclusion The issue of workplace discrimination is prevalent in the contemporary occupational setting. Feminist jurisprudence arose to address the concern while seeking redress for the culprits as discussed earlier along with the limitations facing each approach. Bibliography Bartlett, Katherine T. (1990) ‘Feminist Legal Methods’ Harvard Law Review, Vol. 103 pp. 829- 888 Finley, Lucinda M. (1989) ‘Breaking Women’s Silence in Law: The Dilemma of the Gendered Nature of Legal Reasoning’ Notre Dame Law Review, Vol. 64 pp. 886- 910. Frye, M. Oppression: The Politics of Reality New York: The Crossing Press Online at http://www.terry.uga.edu/-dawnba/4500opression.html (1983) Retrieved on 21st April 2010 MacKinnon, Catherine (1983) ‘Feminism, Marxism, Method and the State: Toward Feminist Jurisprudence’, Signs, Vol. 8 pp. 635- 658 Moult, Julie (2009) Women's careers more tied to weight than men Washington: Herald Sun. Online at; http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/national/gender-divide-in-career-belly/story-e6frf7l6-1225697154065 Rhode, Deborah L. (1990) ‘Feminist Critical Theories’. Stanford Law Review, Vol. 42 pp. 617-638 The Combahee River Collective A Black Feminist Statement Online at; http://www.lilithgallery.com/feminist/modern/Black-Feminist-Statement.html (1982) Retrieved on 21st April 2010 Hoagland, Sarah Lucia & Frye, Marilyn (2000) Feminist interpretations of Mary Daly Penn State Press Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Feminist Jurisprudence and Work Discrimination Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
Feminist Jurisprudence and Work Discrimination Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/2033386-feminist-legal-theory
(Feminist Jurisprudence and Work Discrimination Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Feminist Jurisprudence and Work Discrimination Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/2033386-feminist-legal-theory.
“Feminist Jurisprudence and Work Discrimination Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/2033386-feminist-legal-theory.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Feminist Jurisprudence and Work Discrimination

Role of Media and Feminism

Some also use the term feminism referring to the discrimination of women or an idea focusing on the equality of gender in society.... … The paper "Role of Media and Feminism " is a perfect example of a finance and accounting assignment.... The term feminism has different uses which depend on how writers define it....
17 Pages (4250 words) Assignment

The Role Popular Culture Has Played in Transforming Notions of Gender

The word “popular” was used during the fifteenth century for jurisprudence and government making (Siapera & Hands, 2004).... … The paper "The Role Popular Culture Has Played in Transforming Notions of Gender" is a great example of a finance and accounting essay....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Stepford Wives and Popular Feminism

The television shows of the 1950s and '60s like Leave it to Beaver show the typical American Family, the father going off to work and the mother being the typical housewife and always being sweet and having dinner ready.... … The paper 'The Stepford Wives and Popular Feminism" is a good example of gender and sexual studies coursework....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

How Can an Understanding of the Values, Beliefs, and Practices of Different Cultures Benefit Learners

Economically, issues of discrimination in the workplace, maternity leave and reception in the workplace have been accounted for (Cornell, 1998).... Much of the work done by the post feminists argue that the agenda of feminism is separating the people of opposite sexes instead of reuniting them.... This is because the feminist has continuously staged their consents as far as the rights of women are concerned in terms of social, political, health, economic and legal rights are concerned....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Equal Opportunities Policies and Discrimination at Work

… The paper "Equal Opportunities Policies and discrimination at Work" is an outstanding example of management coursework.... nbsp;It is worth noting that there have been extensive debates on whether equal opportunities (EO) policies have played a significant role in the minimization of discrimination in the workplaces.... The paper "Equal Opportunities Policies and discrimination at Work" is an outstanding example of management coursework....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

How Val Plumwood Work Has Influenced Current Environmental Thinking

… The paper "How Val Plumwood work Has Influenced Current Environmental Thinking" is a great example of a business case study.... The paper "How Val Plumwood work Has Influenced Current Environmental Thinking" is a great example of a business case study.... The essay seeks to provide a critical analysis concerning how Van Plumwood work has influenced the current environmental thinking.... Acquisition of Knowledge is progressively more justified exclusively along with instrumental worries, and so Plumwood's work is steered by dedications to feminist as well as advocacy of social justice....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Kate Sullivans Arguments on Desexualization at Work Place - Massage Therapy

Kate Sullivan looks at how attempts to desexualize workers in organizations end up in creating gendered subjectivities characterized by heteronormativity, discrimination and sexual harassment.... his essay will, therefore, present Kate Sullivan's view that pressures towards organizational desexualization in massage therapy maintain heteronormativity, sexual harassment and discrimination, in her article With(out) pleasure: Desexualization, gender and sexuality at work' (2014)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us