StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper 'The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods' states that CISG has been adopted by seventy six (76) countries as of 7 July 2010. This essay would like to examine if indeed the view that the CISG has many inconsistent provisions is true or not…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods"

?Introduction The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) has been adopted by seventy six (76) countries asof 7 July 2010 (Kritzer, 2011, 1). This include the United States which has ratified the Convention and has made it part of the US law (Johnson, 2011, 1). However, there have been various debates arising as to its interpretation mainly because of it has been claimed that its provisions has too many inconsistencies. This paper therefore, would like to examine if indeed the view that the CISG has many inconsistent provisions is true or not. United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) Susan J. Martin-Davidson, a Professor of Law at Southwestern Law School in Los Angeles, has commented that the “place of business is not defined in the Convention” which is the foremost important consideration in examining whether or not CISG would apply (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1). It was said that commentators have proposed that the place of business would refer to “a permanent and regular place for the transacting of general business” (Honnold, 1989). However, Martin-Davidson says that it is still unclear if such a term would include “the location of a distributor, or other agent, who participates in the negotiation and performance of the contract” (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1). Even the final draft of CISG, the delegates were unable to address as to the issue if place of business would apply to “local agents working on behalf of foreign principals” (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1). Martin-Davidson also comments that “matters relating to agency” are not addressed by the Convention and does not also illustrate what “activities of an agent” would be adequate to establish that “the agent's place of business” is that of the principal (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1). A CISG critic has even remarked that the term “place of business is a “concept (that) carries with it substantial factual and definitional uncertainties, the resolution of which are likely not to be known by the parties at the time of contract formation” (Rosett, 1984, 265 & 269). CISG is also critiqued because it “does not suggest a test for establishing which location has the closest relationship to the contract and its performance” (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1), which place is so provided under Article 10 of the CISG and which basically determines the location of parties under Article 1 of the CISG (Bailey, 1999, 300). In Micro Data Base Systems, Inc. v. Dharma Systems, 148 F.3d 649, 653 (7th Cir. 1998), it explained that “it is not clear whether a relationship linked to the formation of a contract is more or less important that a relationship linked to its performance.” Such provision is even more complex with the proviso that instructs to have a regard “to the circumstances known to or contemplated by the parties at any time before or at the conclusion of the contract” (CISG Article 10(a)). No suggestion however is offered as to kind of circumstance referred to in such provision (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1). The sale of goods under the CISG is also said not to have been defined under the Convention (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1). Although there have been “scholarly commentary” explaining that “goods are basically only moveable, tangible objects,” (Schlechtriem, 2005, 28), there were some reported decisions wherein the court had to decide the meaning of such a term (Landgericht, 2001, 1 & Oberlandesgericht, 1991, 1). This is especially relevant to the application of CISG on the “information stored in and read by computers” which include both the “information stored on a disk or in a computer” considered to be “intangible property” and not as goods (CISG, Article 2(f)), and the so-called “licensed use of information,” which does not satisfy “the seller's obligation to ‘transfer the property in the goods’” under Article 30 of CISG (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009). Such concern however, was addressed by Frank Diedrich who interpreted the goods as to cover “standard software or custom-designed software, or whether the software is transmitted electronically or by means of a tangible data carrier” (Diedrich, 1996, 336). As to the issue that “the licensing restrictions fail to satisfy the seller's obligation to transfer the property in the goods,” Diedrich commented that “the CISG allows the parties to derogate from or vary its provisions” (CISG, Article 6).  There are however some difficulties experienced by courts which use “the vague and open-ended provisions of the Convention” in order to address complex questions “posed by custom and usage in the software industry” (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1). Hence, Martin-Davidson suggests that there must be “uniformity in the application of the CISG to licensing agreements that accompany computer products and transactions” by having an agreement as to the “nature, timing, and quality of information exchanges that will constitute assent” (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1). Contracts providing for both goods and services are said to be covered by CISG “unless the ‘preponderant part of the obligations of the party who furnishes the goods will consist of services” (CISG, Article 3(2)). Such provision in Article 3 has initiated a controversy that paved the way for the “CISG advisory Council to issue Opinion No. 4” (Pace Law School Institute, 2005), that listed issues such as the differences in meaning of terms like “substantial, preponderant, and obligations” which have been translated officially in different languages; the seemingly lack of commentary and applicable case law analyzing issues arising from the “interpretation of Article 3” Oberlandesgericht [OLGZ] [Civil Court of Appeal] Dec., 3 1999; and a general confusion regarding “the relationship between Article 3(1) and Article 3(2)” (Oberlandesgericht [OLGZ] [Civil Court of Appeal] Dec., 3 1999). Another issue raised against CISG is that it does not address “the potential for conflict between buyers of goods still attached to realty and purchasers of the real estate prior to their severance” (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1 on CISG, Article 4(b)). This issue is very relevant in many developing countries, wherein “real estate and things associated with real estate are still the most important sources of the wealth of its people and are protected by formal requirements governing contracts to sell them” (Cod. Civ. arts. 1183-84 (Argentina). Hence, such unresolved questions on CISG’s application to these kinds of transactions, Martin-Davidson suggests that “lawyers should play it safe and comply with local provisions that govern the sale of real property if the contract of sale predates severance” (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1). The term “validity” has not also been defined under the Convention causing numerous debates concerning its meaning (Hartnell, 1993, 1). This issue has not been resolved as the drafters then were “unable to reconcile the desire for a uniform international sales law” having “proper regard for domestic public policy” (Crawford, 1988, 187 & 191). Generally though, “the validity exception to the scope of the Convention” encompasses domestic policy concerns such as “lack of capacity,” (UNILEX database, 2007), “duress, fraud, and illegality” (Kritzer, 1989, 86). There is also a controversy as to “whether and to what extent the CISG excludes franchises and distributorships, transactions of barter, and consignments” (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1). Another problem with CISG is Article 7, which include “four principles for interpreting the provisions of the Convention,” thus: “(1) consideration of the Convention's international character, (2) the Convention's need for uniformity, (3) observation of good faith in interpreting the Convention, and (4) the use of the Convention's implicit general principles to address matters not explicitly covered by the Convention” (CISG, Article 7). The Convention also suggests “a specific hierarchy for interpretation of the Convention” in that courts should be guided by “CISG’s unstated general principles if the explicit provisions of the CISG do not provide an answer” (Bailey, 1999, 299). Domestic law rules which are “applicable by virtue of the rules of private international law” must then be applied by courts if there is no answer provided therefore (CISG, Article 7(2)). However, these principles were said to be “vague and difficult to apply” (Bailey, 1999, 299), even if it requires that it be interpreted based on “independent international principles” (CISG, Article 7(1)) as “it does not adequately explain what those principles mean” (Bailey, 1999, 299). “Observing good faith in international trade” as declared in Article 7 of CISG, was also said to be vague as there is “no agreement as to what this principle means or in what situation it is to be applied”(Kritzer, 1989, 109). Article 7(2) also suggests on how to resolve situations not covered by CISG, which states that it be resolved “in accordance with the general principles on which it [the Convention] is based or, in the absence of such principles, in conformity with the [domestic] law applicable by virtue of the rules of private international law” (CISG, Article 7(2)). These general principles however, are not expressly stated in the Convention and is left for courts to apply (Bailey, 1999, 299). Conclusion Given the above analysis of the Convention, the view that CISG has many inconsistent provisions, is not really accurate. The more accurate view is that because the terms have not been clearly defined in the Convention and because the Convention fails to explicitly state the principles or circumstances applicable in certain cases, make it hard for courts to interpret various situations in commercial law, that may possibly lead to varying or inconsistent rulings. It is possible that in the future, U.S. courts and commercial lawyers will be faced with difficult questions in relation to interpretation of the CISG (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1). Hence there is a need to “anticipate and address these potential problems” by “carefully drafting choice-of-law provisions” for the protection of people engaged in international commercial transactions (Martin-Davidson, 2008-2009, 1). The history and debates in the drafting of the Convention as well as precedents, must also be taken into consideration, so that inconsistent rulings may be avoided. References Barse Trading Limited v. Selkhozpromexport (Russian Federation v. Cyprus) (Fed. Arb. Ct. for the Moscow Reg. May 26, 2003). Bailey, James E. (1999). Facing the Truth: Seeing the Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods as an Obstacle to a Uniform Law of International Sales. Cornell International Law Journal, 32: 273. Civil Code, Articles 1183-84 (Argentina). Crawford, Blair & Rich, Janet L. (1989). New Rules for Contracting in the Global Marketplace: The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods, C395 ALI-ABA 115, 130. Diedrich, Frank (1996). Maintaining Uniformity in International Uniform Law via Autonomous Interpretation: Software Contracts and the CISG. Pace International Law Review 8: 303, 336. Hartnell, Helen E. (1993). Rousing the Sleeping Dog: The Validity Exception to the Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods. Yale Journal of International Law 18: 1. Honnold, John O. (1989). Documentary History of the Uniform Law for International Sales. Johnson, William P. (2011). Understanding Exclusion of the CISG: A New Paradign of Determining Party Intent. Buffalo Law Review, 59: 213. Kritzer, Albert H. (1989). Guide to Practical Applications of the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods. 108-09. Kritzer, Albert H. (2011). CISG: Table of Contracting States. http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/countries/cntries.html Landgericht [LG] [Trial Court] Jan. 19, 2001, (F.R.G.). http:// cisgw3.law.pace.edu/cases/010119g1.html. Martin-Davidson, Susan J. (2008-2009). Selling Goods Internationally: Scope of the U.N. Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods. Michigan State Journal of International Law, 17: 657. Micro Data Base Systems, Inc. v. Dharma Systems, 148 F.3d 649, 653 (7th Cir. 1998). Oberlandesgericht [OLGZ] [Civil Court of Appeal] Nov. 27, 1991, (F.R.G.). http:// cisgw3.law.pace.edu/cases/911127g1.html. Oberlandesgericht [OLGZ] [Civil Court of Appeal] Dec., 3 1999, (F.R.G.). http:// cisgw3.law.pace.edu/cases/991203g1.html. Pace Law School Institute of International Commercial Law. Opinion No. 4, Oct., 24 2004. http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/CISG-AC-op4.html Rosett, Arthur (1984). Critical Reflections on the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods. Ohio State Law Journal, 45: 265, 269. Schlechtriem, Peter (2005). Commentary on the UN Convention on the International Sale of Goods 101 (2d ed). Unilex Database (2007). http://www.unilex.info/ Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“CISG has too many incosisten provision Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1413526-cisg-has-too-many-incosisten-provision
(CISG Has Too Many Incosisten Provision Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1413526-cisg-has-too-many-incosisten-provision.
“CISG Has Too Many Incosisten Provision Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1413526-cisg-has-too-many-incosisten-provision.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods

Why Saudi Arabia has not joined the CISG And should it join now

CISG: The CISG (Convention for the international sale of goods) is an important adoption in the international business transaction.... The United Nations Convention for international sale of goods is applicable to international transactions of goods.... The CISG covers only the buying and selling of goods.... CISG aimed to regulate the international transactions and frame transparent rules for the workings.... … CISG and Saudi Arabia [Name] [Course] [Professor's name] [Date] Introduction: the international business transaction has taken a major step after the formation of the CISG....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

The impact of the CISG on international business transactions

hellip; The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods is popularly known as the CISG.... The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) was adopted in the year 1988.... Hence on the basis of the recoded data and reviewing the literatures about The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods, it can be concluded that CSIG played an extremely important role in facilitating smoother international trade....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Role of Arbitration in International Commercial Disputes

In the realm of judgments managed in arbitral situations the international Law Association, which was founded in 1873 utilizes definitions of public policy including international public policy and public policy.... The Encyclopaedia Britannica would state that the art of international arbitration began between the united States and Great Britain approximately in the year 1794 in order for America to build a sound national economy and ensure commercial prosperity....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

German Legal System

The current German legal system is a result of many centuries of development, beginning with the tribal laws of the first Germans.... Those native customs were influenced and transformed under Roman law and later by the laws that prevailed in the Holy Roman Empire (Berle & Means, 2005).... hellip; Feudal law also had a strong influence....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Delchi Carrier, SpA v. Rotorex Corp

Delchi filed an instant action for breach of contract and failure to deliver goods in the US District Court for the Northern District of New York based on The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG). ... Delchi filed an instant action for breach of contract and failure to deliver goods in the US District Court for the Northern District of New York based on The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG)....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

The Legal and Regulatory Environment of Business

An example is the Uniform Commercial Code, Sarbanes-Oxley Act, and The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods and the Constitution of the United States among others.... These are held in place in order to not only protect the consumers from shrewd businessmen but also protect the businesses themselves from themselves and other outside markets that may affect them....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Ineffectiveness of the Provisions of SGA in Allocating Risks

The researcher of this essay will make an earnest attempt to explore the gaps existing in the Act governing the sale of goods, which makes it difficult to allocate risks as well the possible legislation and amendments that may rectify the gaps.... hellip; This research will begin with the statement that the provision of risks of loss under the Act governing the sale of goods is not spelled out clearly; it has several provisions that are ambiguous because of their open nature....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Phase3 DB International Business Disputes

The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) was formulated in 1993 with the aim of promoting international trade.... This assignment provides a compressive discussion on the consequences that a business would face for operating within states that have not agreed with The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods.... It also gives detailed information on whether a business should or should not engage in business with nations that have not conformed to the requirements of The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us