StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Undocumented, Indispensable by Anna Quinden - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay describes claim is the main thesis of an essay that sets the direction of the argument. In the essay written by Anna Quinden entitled Undocumented, Indispensable the main claim is that the Immigrant issue has already assumed a proportion that has to be addressed seriously…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.2% of users find it useful
Undocumented, Indispensable by Anna Quinden
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Undocumented, Indispensable by Anna Quinden"

Undocumented, Indispensable by Anna Quinden 1. Analyze the cartoon on page 137 of Perspectives on Argument and discuss the answers to the following questions:188 a. What is the claim? Claim is the main thesis of an essay that sets the direction of the argument. In the essay written by Anna Quinden entitled Undocumented, Indispensable the main claim is that the Immigrant issue has already assumed a proportion that has to be addressed seriously. b. What is the support? Support of a claim is the justification or argument to substantiate the claim. The support of the claim lies in the first few paragraphs of the essay wherein the author vividly described the march of the immigrants from Market Street in San Francisco that numbered in thousands that the author described it to be near earthquake albeit not in geological sense. The marchers raised valid arguments about their status through their placards that says “I am a worker, not a criminal”. c. What are the warrants? Warrants are the reasoning links between the support and the claim. They are the persuasion of the argument. In this essay, the warrants tell that in addressing the immigration issue, one should look at the whole issue and that includes the contribution of the immigrants and not only the common arguments raised against them such as social security costs etch. d. What is the backing? Backing is the argument of the warrant and is often characterized by the word because. In Quinden’s essay entitled Undocumented, Indispensable the backing is of the warrant that we should also look at the contribution of the immigrants in addressing them because they may in fact, be the ones who are keeping our system afloat with their contributions (through taxes) and yet are not entitled to the full benefits of social security (such as claiming for pension). e. Are rebuttals or qualifiers present? If so, describe them. Yes. The writer recognized the arguments against immigrants that they still go to hospitals, send their children to schools and that costs United States socially. The argument raise against immigrants that their cheap labor drive wages down are valid. We benefit from it because they help build cheap houses, bring our food fresh to the detriment of American workers. 2. Perspectives on Argument: Page 208-10 Exercise C Immigration is an emotionally charged topic in the United States. Read the essay, “Undocumented, Indispensable.” Begin your comments by noting your emotional response to the essay. Then, make a critical note of the primary claim this author makes. Use the questions in Exercise C to guide your analysis of the essay. Does the author strengthen or change your stance on this issue? The primary claim of the author that immigrant issue has already assumed a proportion that has to be addressed seriously was well positioned. Quinden did not put her main argument nonchalantly or straightforwardly but rather, she used colorful descriptions and analogies that engage the readers. She used the description of geologic earthquake and comparing the march to the other important marches such as march about Vietnam War and feminist rallies. After engaging the reader about her claim, she then conditioned the reader to her arguments that there side of the arguments that were not considered about immigrants such as their contributions through the taxes they pay that they may in fact be the one helping to keep the system afloat. It also helped to mention that they are being demonized as social costs when in fact they work and also contribute to the social security yet not entitled to full benefits. In essence, Quinden humanized the issue that immigrants are not devils or social security malaise that drains our resources but rather as individuals who helps to keep our way of life. They may have kept wages down but they also keep the prices our homes cheap and ensure that our foods are cheap. Such, many employers who are also campaign contributors turn their eyes the other way about the immigration status of their worker. And perhaps they may be doing this because they are waiting for immigration laws to be more responsive with the reality of the times. Immigrants are workers and therefore are tax payers and not social liabilities. She mentioned America’s primacy to human rights to put value on her arguments and help the reader see the humane aspect of the issue. Finally, she cited personal experience with her grandchildren being a grandmother of immigrants herself to appeal to the human emotion of the reader knowing that everybody has a soft side for children. The author strengthened my stance on the issue to look immigrants favorably. I particularly, more inclined to enlist them instead as our workers, as what President Obama said in his Inaugural Address, to help build this country instead of demonizing them and driving them away. For all we know, they may have contributed more to this country more than we realize. 3. Read the student essay “Dear Boss” on page 296. What is the issue?  If you were the boss, how would you respond to this letter? Try to incorporate a Rogerian approach. However, if you feel the need to, combine traditional and Rogerian approaches.  This is not to be a lengthy letter of response; just share briefly how you would respond to the student, especially from the Rogerian pattern. Rogerian approach in argument is basically finding the middle ground or consensus between two parties. The letter of the student/employee was basically a Rogerian approach because it first recognized the need of the boss and then explain his side without antagonizing and then proposed a solution or compromise on how they could both meet their expectations about tasks and the company in general. My response would be Rogerian as well. First, show appreciation on how the student took the effort to explain his or her side as well as acknowledging where, I, the boss is coming from. I will reiterate his argument to convey that I understand where the student is coming from. I will also acknowledge his proposal to find a compromise on how to arrive at a mutually satisfying solution. Finally, I ask him for a discussion on how we can expand our options to be mutually satisfactorily. The student employee is basically dodging more work in his letter but his Rogerian approach justified it beautifully. But it has a appoint that a compromise should be made that he or she is a student with a limited time. The personal discussion will have an objective appraisal of the issue where I can heck his or her schedule, compare the actual work on how it fit and evaluate what additional work I can give him or her. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Undocumented, Indispensable by Anna Quinden Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/creative-writing/1618154-engl-compositionrhetoric-11
(Undocumented, Indispensable by Anna Quinden Essay)
https://studentshare.org/creative-writing/1618154-engl-compositionrhetoric-11.
“Undocumented, Indispensable by Anna Quinden Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/creative-writing/1618154-engl-compositionrhetoric-11.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Undocumented, Indispensable by Anna Quinden

Immigrant: Undocumented Students

The paper "Immigrant: undocumented Students" discusses the illegal immigrants, especially the undocumented students who pursue their dream to be college students, and improve the work field, and the economy.... nbsp;… A particular disadvantage have been the undocumented minor children who are brought to the US accompanying adult members of their families.... Scientific studies have shown that undocumented students face enormous problems and research confirms that a large number of these undocumented students were not able to continue their higher education at universities or colleges because of immigration status....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Immigrant: Undocumented Students

In the paper “Immigrant: undocumented Students Problem” the author discusses the issue that undocumented minor children, those under the age of 16 when brought into the US, face laws denying them equal opportunity in higher education in colleges and universities.... Amongst the unauthorized immigrant population, there are nearly three hundred and sixty thousand high school graduates, (Van Hook, Bean, and Passel) and another seven hundred and fifteen thousand such undocumented children in the age bracket of 5 to 17 years (Topical)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Should undocumented students qualify for federal student financial aid

Additionally, it is responsible for the growth distribution… undocumented students are not mentioned anywhere in the federal financial aid program.... undocumented students are those students that These students face legal uncertainties and limitations in the United States lawful system.... In this essay, I will examine whether the undocumented students should be qualify for federal student financial aid.... undocumented students are not denied from applying or being admitted to colleges; however, unlike other students who are citizens of the United States they face federal financial limitation....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Should Business Hire Undocumented Workers

This is because they are the only individuals who are willing to do jobs that the Therefore, by accepting the undocumented immigrants the employer is violating the law, as they should always ensure that all employees are properly documented (Carroll & Buchholtz, 2010, p.... Moreover, the employer knows that the undocumented immigrants are using false documents, and yet they are willing to employ them.... Illegal immigration is primarily a social issue because the more the number of undocumented immigrants there are the more the population....
5 Pages (1250 words) Coursework

Quicken Financial Program

The essay "Quicken Financial Program" talks about a personal finance software developed to help the Banking financial sector around the world, with a view to enhance the quality of service and productivity through the smart use of integrated technology.... “Quicken online Banking booster takes downloading bank and… Today Quicken is one of the leading financial software providers of financial and business management solutions around the world providing its vast operation....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Issue of Undocumented Students

The "Issue of undocumented Students" research paper answers the question of whether undocumented students should be allowed in the United State of America or deported.... Mike Honda has substantial experience because of his position, and his focus on improving education makes him qualified to write about the problems of undocumented students.... The website aided in supplementing information into how the government has tried to solve the problem of undocumented students....
5 Pages (1250 words) Annotated Bibliography

Children of Undocumented Immigrants Should Attend College

From the paper "Children of undocumented Immigrants Should Attend College" it is clear that introduction of DREAM act is surely advantages for all but its negative impact need to control in an effective and tactful way by the managers or leaders of the organizations or nation.... hellip; Implementation of DREAM act might offer the facility of improving the living standard and lifestyle of the undocumented families as compared to documented citizens.... However, in order to reduce such type of crimes, the government of Germany tried to offer varied types of financial aids to the children of undocumented immigrants in order to fulfill their college or university educations effectively just like the other individual candidates....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Our Tired, Our Poor, Our Kids by Anna Quindlen

This article "Our Tired, Our Poor, Our Kids by anna Quindlen" tries to appeal to her audience by showing a side of America that most middle-class Americans would never have even heard of.... For many low-class citizens, having the luxury to live where you want is only just a dream....
1 Pages (250 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us