StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Arguments in Favor of Capital Punishment and its Alternatives - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The writer of this essay seeks to critically discuss the idea of the death penalty among other forms of punishment. Moreover, the writer would like to argue that offering Life Imprisonment is not among pertinent options as compared to sentencing malefactors to death…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
Arguments in Favor of Capital Punishment and its Alternatives
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Arguments in Favor of Capital Punishment and its Alternatives"

Capital Punishment Should criminals, especially murderers and rapists, be hanged to death or offered life imprisonment on their heinous crimes? Indeed, this has become a serious debate as people argue that death penalty to felonies would help eradicating the hard core criminal elements in our society. The author himself is in favor of ‘Capital Punishment’ and would like to argue that offering Life Imprisonment is not among pertinent options as compared to sentencing malefactors to death. Capital Punishment refers to awarding death as a punishment or penalty to the murderers, assassins and serial killers, who subject people to death for any reasons. Indeed, this punishment has been applicable since ancient times to curb crimes and bring felons before justice. World’s major religions such as Christianity and Islam have also prescribed death for murder, necromancy and rape attempts as presented in Holy books including Bible and Quran. For instance, we have to consider the viewpoints, arguments, opinions, ideas and understanding of every individual as we live in the democratic society where every person enjoys freedom of speech, expression and open communication. It is worthwhile to mention the fact that anti-capital punishment campaigners usually disregard the universal truth that everyone is mortal, when defending Life Imprisonment against death penalty. For instance, such campaigners argue that life-long wait for natural death by criminals will increase their agony of torture and emotional anguish in comparison to pain and hurting they receive before hanging in public for death. However, they fail to provide a legitimate explanation against the argument raised by endorsers of death penalty “whether Life Imprisonment to culprits is the just decision for those who have lost their loved ones killed by felonies for personal reasons”. Some of the major arguments raised for and against capital punishment will now be demonstrated in the following sections to reach an appropriate conclusion. The first major argument in favour of Capital Punishment by supporters is that it leads to permanent eradication of notorious criminal groups, gangs or individuals from society. In addition, the death penalty serves as a example that no one is beyond the law as well as permitted to take law in one’s hand by brutally assassinating the innocents in society. Also, the punishment makes society safer and restores confidence of general public, which remains frightened from presence of such malefactors in prisons, as the probability that they could ditch law enforcement authorities and evade is always there, though, minimal. Next, the notorious personnel obviously would not commit any further crimes after death. The second major argument for death penalty is resources are scarce and governments have to utilize them efficiently to bring greater good to the society. Felonies, if offered life imprisonment, have to be kept in safest prisons that are, of course, not constructed, managed and maintained for free. Indeed, the government has to provide food, shelter, medical and clothing facilities followed by recreational activities to prisoners in case law supports the latter, which should be considered as additional financial burden. Why should this money be spent on proven criminals instead of deserving needy personnel that are victims of poverty and unemployment monster? Hence, it is justified to argue that economic and financial costs of life imprisonment are extremely high than death sentencing. Third, the malefactors should also be subjected to feel pain, agony and anguish of death to understand the real meaning of ‘offence and assault’ towards the innocents. Moreover, many people still convict in old principal of "lex talens" (an eye for an eye), because they view it as absolutely legitimate and lawful for atrocities. There are various arguments raised against the imposition of Death Penalty that will now be evaluated to prove if they are really relevant and legally acceptable. The most important argument against Capital Punishment is that the probability that genuinely innocent people will be suspected as guilty party or felonies is always there, no matter how stronger the law and investigation committees are. Now, the proponents of Life Imprisonment argue that if this probability increases than who will be responsible for the adverse consequences to families of innocents whose life will turn into an eternal torture? Could this miscarriage of justice be compensated by law enforcement agencies? The second important argument is that the person involved in the murder may have done that intentionally because of nefarious designs, yet he would not accept that the assassination was a killing; rather maintain that it was nothing but a mistake. In such cases, only the alleged and the victim (deceased) would know about the underlying truth; however, the absence of deceased makes the case complex and difficult to get resolved. Consequently, the lawyers remain busy in court sessions as well as in signing appeals or petitions, which benefits the culprit (in short run) but nettles both culprit’s and the victim’s families and other associated personnel. Indeed, the time and money is also involved in such hearings that could be devoted for better purposes. The third argument against Capital Punishment is that the law is strongly implemented in developed nations unlike most developing countries. Hence, the investigations could be conducted in a better manner in societies with stronger law, yet the probability that innocents could be suspected as notorious due to personal, ethnic, religious or language biases, is higher. The situation in most developing countries is much complex than estimates presented by researchers. In the light of above, the dangers of capital punishment would create unrest and uncertainty in society that might lead to civil disobedience. Well, the response to such above mentioned questions is that the possibility that innocents might suffer in a society is always there but very low (specifically in USA), and there are certain investigative techniques that further help in reducing such possibilities. Next, according to Utilitarian Principle of Ethics, the Capital Punishment will permanently wipe out such criminals from society that will bring greater good to society in general, even if some bad events happen due to miscarriage of justice. Next, life imprisonment is not even supported by our religion, which confirms that the guilty party should be sentenced to death if it had been deliberately involved in atrocious and unlawful crimes. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Arguments in Favor of Capital Punishment and its Alternatives Essay”, n.d.)
Arguments in Favor of Capital Punishment and its Alternatives Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1570681-write-a-persuasive-essay-on-any-topic-public-or-private-identify-the-problem-and-offer-a-solution
(Arguments in Favor of Capital Punishment and Its Alternatives Essay)
Arguments in Favor of Capital Punishment and Its Alternatives Essay. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1570681-write-a-persuasive-essay-on-any-topic-public-or-private-identify-the-problem-and-offer-a-solution.
“Arguments in Favor of Capital Punishment and Its Alternatives Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1570681-write-a-persuasive-essay-on-any-topic-public-or-private-identify-the-problem-and-offer-a-solution.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Arguments in Favor of Capital Punishment and its Alternatives

Abolishing Death Penalty

Client's 31 October 2012 Introduction Every country has a different constitution but no constitution permits cruelty and it has been widely debated that capital punishment is intense cruelty, death penalty has been widely employed in the US does that mean the constitution of the US supports cruelty?... The cost of delivering capital punishment is a source of the extra burden to justice systems that may be grappling with limited funds to address their needs (Death Row in Pennsylvania 14)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Issues in the criminal justice system: capital punishment

Those in favor of capital punishment argue that it reduces crime rates.... Consequently, there exists a controversy in the adoption and execution of capital punishment.... Consequently, according to the UN website there have been increased calls for the abolition of capital punishment.... However, according to Amnesty International, majority of the world's population is still under the influence of capital punishment.... Thus, most of these nations have been vehemently involved in the propagation of capital punishment....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Capital Punishment in the United States: Legitimacy and Efficacy in a Modern Liberal Society

This coursework describes capital punishment in the United States and the aspects of its legitimacy and efficacy in modern liberal society.... The Court heard oral arguments in early January 2008 and will hand down an opinion later this year.... Furthermore, the author contends that such an application can be morally justified in terms of the values and goals of a society that, at its core, has a fundamental respect for the integrity of the individual and human life itself....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Capital Punishment Is a Moral Ignominy

Supporters of capital punishment group up in three categories; the retributivists, who claim that for the most heinous crimes, the penalty of death is morally justifiable or perhaps even required, the consequentialists and the welfarists.... They contend that the deterrent consequences of capital punishment are important and that they justify the penalty.... With regard to Popper's view, we then get the standpoint on which to base the support of capital punishment....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Aristotelian Rhetoric: The Debate over Capital Punishment

Further, he goes on to repudiate all the arguments raised by the abolitionists against the death penalty and persuades the readers to think in favor of administering capital punishments.... "Aristotelian Rhetoric: The Debate over capital punishment" paper seeks to undertake an Aristotelian rhetorical analysis on McAdams's article “Wisconsin should have the death penalty” (2006) and in doing so the paper brings out the rhetorical strategies employed by the author in the article....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Death Penalty in the USA

Studies have argued that the implementation of capital punishment is an expensive undertaking (Roger 34).... Domestic and international activists have raised their concerns over the issue, arguing that there are alternative ways to punish criminals that are found guilty of capital offenses.... It is fundamental to consider the fact that this punishment is provided for by law through the legal system that seeks to enhance social, economic and political coherence in the United States (Ogletree & Sarat 217)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Arguments for and against Capital Punishment

nformation gathered from the Michigan State University and Death Penalty Information Center explains that there is a psychological basis for the use of capital punishment as a crime deterrent.... "Arguments for and against capital punishment" paper argues that capital punishment debate always boils down to certain key points such as morality, cost of the procedure, and other alternative treatments for the offenders.... nbsp;… Let it not be forgotten that aside from the moral cost of the capital punishment, there is the very real financial cost of implementing the death penalty each time an inmate comes up for execution....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Death Penalty as an Issue of Controversy and Debate

he supporters of capital punishment system consider it as the strongest form of deterrence and preserver of judicial retribution.... Similarly, the growing rates of homicides and serious offences prompt one to think in favor of the death penalty.... hellip; The author exhorts one to understand how capital punishment discourses in criminological studies are related to the ongoing legitimacy of power-exercises within the state.... While states engage in other forms of death-dealing in their exercise of power they resort to crime control measures such as capital punishment to deter criminals....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us