StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Reaction to Torture in Physical and Psychological Situations - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The reporter casts light upon the fact that the use of torture is illegal in some countries. Policy makers are responsible for determining the legal definition of torture. Moreover, their definition has its basis in pain severity…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.7% of users find it useful
Reaction to Torture in Physical and Psychological Situations
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Reaction to Torture in Physical and Psychological Situations"

Reaction to TortureThe use of torture is illegal in some countries. Policy makers are responsible for determining the legal definition of torture. Their definition has its basis on pain severity. However, there is an evident discrepancy between the definition of torture and the parameters used in determining the severity of pain on someone’s body. Notably, people who have not experienced pain are likely to underestimate such pain. On the contrary, people who have experienced pain, even in its mild form have a strong opinion against torture.

The hot-cold empathy gap is the existing gap between the views of people who have experienced pain and those of people who have not experienced such pain. Psychological researchers have highlighted that the empathy gap also exists in the definition of psychological pain. Different countries have adopted various interrogation tactics that induce a measure of pain in people. Assessment of the ethical relevance of the different interrogation tactics by people who have experienced the pain differs from the assessment done by people who have not experienced the pain.

The study sought to demonstrate that people’s judgments on whether different interrogation tactics make use of torture depend on the empathy gap (Nordgren, McDonnell, & Loewenstein, 2011). The research comprised of four studies, with each having different result. In the first study, it emerged that participants exposed to a measure of social isolation opined that exposing prisoners to solitary confinement was a very severe measure. Such participants considered solitary confinement as unethical.

However, participants who did not experience any measure of social isolation did not view solitary confinement as unethical. In the second study, participants who filled in questionnaires after the class opined that sleep deprivation was highly painful and unethical. Since they were experiencing fatigue as they filled in the questionnaires, they considered sleep deprivation a severe form of pain. However, the group that filled in the questionnaires before the class considered sleep deprivation less painful.

In the third study, some of the participants faced exposure to cold temperatures. Due to their experience, they described the exposure to cold temperatures as a torturous interrogation tactic. In the fourth study, participants placed under the non-pain conditions underestimated the severity of pain associated with standing in the cold (Nordgren, McDonnell, & Loewenstein, 2011). The participants who experienced the coldest whether described it as torture, and they were against this interrogation tactic.

From the findings of the four studies, it emerges that empathy gaps are existent in both physical and psychological situations. It is impossible for people who have not experienced pain to evaluate the severity of pain in a given situation correctly. However, the people who experience pain can give a detailed description and accurate assessment of the severity of pain in that situation. Many interrogation tactics make use of torture. Policy makers are yet to experience the kind of pain inflicted on individuals during such interrogation tactics.

Only individuals exposed to such interrogation tactics can describe the severity of pain (McDonnell, 2011). For this reason, people who have not experienced the pain inflicted by such interrogation tactics consider them as ethical. However, people who have faced painful conditions brought forth by the interrogation tactics consider them as highly unethical.ReferencesMcDonnell, M. M. (2011). Torture in the Eyes of the Beholder: The Psychological Difficulty of Defining Torture in Law and Policy.

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law, 4487.Nordgren, L. F., McDonnell, M. M., & Loewenstein, G. (2011). What Constitutes Torture?: Psychological Impediments to an Objective Evaluation of Enhanced Interrogation Tactics. Psychological Science (Sage Publications Inc.), 22(5), 689-694.

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Reaction to Torture in Physical and Psychological Situations Essay - 3”, n.d.)
Reaction to Torture in Physical and Psychological Situations Essay - 3. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1677468-editing-the-given-essay
(Reaction to Torture in Physical and Psychological Situations Essay - 3)
Reaction to Torture in Physical and Psychological Situations Essay - 3. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1677468-editing-the-given-essay.
“Reaction to Torture in Physical and Psychological Situations Essay - 3”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1677468-editing-the-given-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Reaction to Torture in Physical and Psychological Situations

Effects of Riots on Families

Different people respond differently to situations they face.... Many people have confessed that they have failed to face such situations, which occur after a riot.... While many people feel that riots create physical damage to the society, some people confess to suffer psychologically many years after the incident.... Sometimes street riots lead to physical injury or death (Ulin 756)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Why was violence so intence in the late 20th centry in America

In spite of, or even due to, its uncommonness, lynching carried a particular psychological power, raising a degree of terror and fear that engulfed all other kinds of violence in the 20th-century America.... It was the scene of lynching, instead of the brutality itself, which inflicted some psychological injury that imposed black submission to white supremacy....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

A Comparison and Contrast between the Theme of Revenge in The Visit and Death and the Maiden

To begin with, it would be imperative to introduce both pieces of work as dark fairy tales of sorts where both the protagonists are thrown into situations where they have to suddenly wake up from their idyllic lives to great distress and even trauma.... hellip; To begin with, it would be imperative to introduce both pieces of work as dark fairy tales of sorts where both the protagonists are thrown into situations where they have to suddenly wake up from their idyllic lives to great distress and even trauma....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Biopsychosocial Approach and the Biological Aspect of Cloning

Extracting the patient's life story is important in knowing to its full extent the story of how the illness started and how the social and psychological domains affect the patient.... Yes, the cloned individual may have the same physical and biological attributes as the parent clone, but it may not have the same reaction to the present conditions wherein it will live because of the learning experience it will encounter.... Although it has the same physical attributes as the parent clone, it may react differently to the situations around it because of the how it will be trained or educated....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Analysis of Darkness at Noon by Arthur Koestler

Noontime is the brightest time of the day and it is only during extraordinary situations (such as a storm or solar eclipse) that noon is engulfed in darkness.... The author analyses Darkness at Noon by Arthur Koestler, a winner of the prestigious Sonning Prize.... As a former member of Germany's Communist Party Arthur was able to put into writing his own personal experiences and build up a compelling political tale… Publicly heralded in France, Darkness at Noon survived Cold War Communist censorship and underground book sales....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

The United Nations Convention Against Torture

Torture is a total violation of the safety of a person's body because it inflicts severe mental or physical suffering through pain and mental trauma.... The paper "The United Nations Convention Against torture" describes that there is no form of interrogation is absolutely effective and humane, but applying torture to extract a confession from prisoners is unacceptable, ineffective, unreliable and a gross violation of human rights.... hellip; torture exposes troops of the offending country in foreign missions to more danger because of the perception that such soldiers are inhuman and do not deserve any better treatment if arrested or detained....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

The Questionable Ethics of Social Influence

Specifically, he designed an experiment to pit good people (students acting as prisoners) against the forces inherent in situations considered bad (students acting as abusive prison guards).... The paper "The Questionable Ethics of Social Influence" highlights that not all social psychological experiments share unethical components with Zimbardo's and Milgram's controversial studies.... sychologists have put this theory to the test with various social psychological experiments....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Main Challenges Associated With Adulthood

ccording to Stiles (2008), nature is a psychological concept that argues that the physical and personal characteristics of individuals are determined by the genes or hereditary factors that cannot be reversed.... On the other hand, nurture is a psychological concept that argues that the physical and personal characteristics are mainly determined by environmental or social factors.... However, one common definition for the concept adulthood is that it is the last phase in human life when physical maturity is achieved with regard mental, biological, cultural and individual characteristics with relation to other similar developments that are present in this stage....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us