StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Savant syndrome - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Savant syndrome, due to its unusual nature, has attracted the attention and efforts of researchers from all over the world. However, the field of psychology has not been able to completely understand the etiology of the condition till now…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.9% of users find it useful
Savant syndrome
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Savant syndrome"

? Critical analysis of the of the Introduction Savant syndrome, due to its unusual nature, has attracted the attention and efforts of researchers from all over the world. However, the field of psychology has not been able to completely understand the etiology of the condition till now. Savant syndrome can be defined as a “rare condition in which persons with various developmental disabilities have abilities that are remarkable considering their handicap (called ‘talented savants’) to those rarer individuals whose brilliance would be spectacular even in normal person (called ‘prodigious savant’) (Sousa, 2003, p. 225). The definition clarifies that individuals suffering from savant syndrome suffer from different mental disorders. This aspect of savant syndrome, i.e. the mental disorder that is associated with the savant syndrome, is the focus of the article “Annotation: The Savant Syndrome,” written by Pamela Heaton and Gregory Wallace. Through the article, the authors aimed to suggest that the conditions of autism and savant syndrome are inseparable, as individuals suffering from savant syndrome always show some sign of characteristics related to autism. Sadly, the authors have failed to present their point of view in focused manner and have touched many different topics in one article. Moreover, lack of strong evidence weakens the argument and opinion of the authors. Hence, the article “Annotation: The Savant Syndrome,” by Heaton and Wallace, due to its scattered topics, lack of focus, and weak evidence, fails to achieve the aim of proving that autism is ‘inextricably linked to autism,’ and hence, fails to convince the readers that researchers should focus on etiology of autism in order to understand the etiology of savant syndrome. Errors in Reasoning The article “Annotation: The Savant Syndrome” comes forward as a disoriented and incoherent paper with topics unrelated to each other, and referred to in haphazard manner. The most important error in the article is an assumption that autism and savant skills are inextricably linked. The authors, in the abstract of the article, say that “autism and savant skills are inextricably linked” and hence, suggest that to solve the puzzle of savant syndrome, researchers should focus on children and adults suffering from autism (Heaton & Wallace, 2004, p. 899). This is an error as there is no strong evidence to support the reasoning of this assumption in the article. The evidence supported for this reasoning behind the assumption is based on ‘observations’ by Young (1995), which cannot be considered as strong evidence. Moreover, the authors have ‘assumed’ that due to lack of “diagnostic criteria and practice in past 25 years,” regarding autism, researchers might have failed to assess the autistic characteristics in savants and hence, most of the savants might have been autistic but must have remained undiagnosed (Heaton & Wallace, 2004, p. 901). These kinds of assumptions are not strong to prove a point as it is an erroneous reasoning. The authors propose that the IQ scores should be excluded from research when studying savant syndrome in an individual. They reason that that reading comprehension and semantic processing is not measured through IQ tests, which makes the measurement of intra-individual performance across domain difficult (Heaton & Wallace, 2004, p. 899). At the same time, they have mentioned that reading comprehension and intellectual functioning can be understood through academic achievement and standardized IQ tests. Moreover, the supporting evidence they use for this reasoning is the study by Volkmar and Lord (1999). The authors say that in study by Volkmar and Lord (1999), approximately 20% of individuals suffering from autism (who also over-represented savant skills) scored “the average range on measures of non-verbal skills” and hence, the IQ tests are not of use in study of savant syndrome, as ‘savant syndrome’ is a condition which is applicable only to those individuals who are intellectually impaired. However, this is an error of judgment as one cannot discard the importance of measuring tool when only 20% of the individuals, that too ‘approximately,’ in sample population fail to match the criteria for the savant syndrome. Hence, the authors’ reasoning that IQ tests should be excluded from the study of savant syndrome is erroneous. The Aim In the article, “Annotation: The savant syndrome,” the authors have attempted to find a link between savant syndrome and autism. In fact, it won’t be wrong to say that the authors have attempted to suggest that all the cases of savant syndrome are linked to autism in some way or other. Hence, they have not attempted to put forward a particular theoretical view of the world but have attempted at forming a theory based on the review of research literature on savant syndrome and autism. In doing so, the authors have challenged certain methods of studying savant syndrome. For example, they suggest that IQ tests should be discarded as a measuring tool while studying savant syndrome. They propose that their literature review has led them to conclude that autism and savant syndrome are strongly linked to each other and hence, their connection is needed to be studied more deeply. On the basis of their conclusion, they suggest that researchers should make efforts to conduct qualitative as well as quantitative studies to find the relationship between savant syndrome and autism. In fact, after reading the article, the reader gets a feel that the authors are subtly but very strongly, proposing that savant syndrome cannot exist in an individual without showing at least some traces of autism. The authors say that even if strong autistic characteristics are not found in individuals suffering from savant syndrome, some mild characteristics are almost always found. Hence, the authors have not attempted to put forward any theoretical view of the world, but have challenged it. Research Literature as Evidence To support their view that savant syndrome is inseparable part of autism, the authors have used the review of research literature from the past as evidence. However, the researches that are used as support have not proved their point strongly. Moreover, the researches that are included in the review are not conducted on large population and lack the strength of the quantity. For example, the authors refer to Young’s (1995) research on 51 savants in which Young has reported to have ‘observed’ some characteristics of autism in all the participants (Heaton & Wallace, 2004, p. 901). However, it is important to note that they were not diagnosed with autism yet and hence, this research cannot be used as evidence. Another example of weak evidence is reference to numerous empirical studies while discussing the relationship between ‘savant skills and intelligence’ (Heaton & Wallace, 2004, p. 901). The authors say that even though there were no clear findings about the link, they ‘are inclined to believe’ that savant skills are independent of general intelligence. This evidence is not strong as nothing is proved from the studies. However, authors have used these empirical studies to propose that IQ tests should not be used as a measurement tool while studying the savant syndrome. In this way, the evidence used by the authors is weak and shallow. The authors should have used more researches and valid evidence. The words like ‘we believe,’ ‘we speculate,’ etc., weakens the argument. It would have been a strong article if the authors had used some strong, quantitative and qualitative studies to prove their point. Moreover, if the authors had focused only on one topic, i.e. either ‘link between savant syndrome and autism’ or ‘role of IQ tests in study of savant syndrome,’ it would have been a strong article. However, by including both the arguments in one article, the authors have confused the reader and have scattered their attention. Conclusion The discussion above shows that the article ““Annotation: The savant syndrome,” by Heaton and Wallace, even though has a valid theoretical perspective regarding savant syndrome, lacks the strength due to weak evidence and scattered focus. References Heaton, P. & Wallace, G. L. (2004). Annotation: The savant syndrome. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 45(5), 899–911. Sousa, D.A. (2003). How the gifted brain learns. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press, Inc. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Savant syndrome Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Savant syndrome Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1454050-savant-syndrome
(Savant Syndrome Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Savant Syndrome Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1454050-savant-syndrome.
“Savant Syndrome Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1454050-savant-syndrome.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Savant syndrome

The Portrayal of Various Psychological Disorders

It featured Raymond Babbitt, an autistic savant who has been in a mental institution since his childhood.... Apply and Discover Date Apply and Discover Media is rich in the portrayal of various psychological disorders.... These portrayals however sometimes fail in accuracy which leads to the misinformation of the audience....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Differentiation of Different Forms within the Autism Spectrum

For this reason, children with savantism which lies within the spectrum of autism disorders make the affected children to be called idiot savants and thus the reference of this disorder as idiot Savant syndrome.... The paper "Differentiation of Different Forms within the Autism Spectrum" gives a critical analysis and discussion of autism with a special focus on the implications of high functioning autism within contemporary society....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Meaning of Labels Aspergers Syndrome

ASPERGERS syndrome AND HOW IT AFFECT PARTICIPANT OR POTENTIAL PARTICIPANTS IN EDUCATION.... HIS REPORT SHOULD BE IN THREE PARTS, AND WRITTEN AS THOUGH THE WRITER IS PLAYING AN ACTIVE PART WITHIN EDUCATION MANAGEMENT IN BRITAIN In recent years the seemingly exponential growth in the number of children exhibiting signs of Autism - of which Asperger's syndrome is a mild type of - has caused legitimate alarm in many sectors of society.... hellip; There are several reasons for this alarm: Asperger's syndrome is one of the various conditions that as a whole make up the classification known as autism....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time

The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time is a novel written by Mark Haddon, best known as a children's author, who was said not entirely sure, at first, whether he was writing for adults (BBC 2004).... The story is written in the first-person narrative of Christopher Boone, a 15-year-old boy suffering from autism, and living in Swindon, Wiltshire. … This paper looks into the novel with nature of autism as its theme....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Gender and Autism Spectrum Disorders

Male and female victims of autism experience their syndrome in a different way.... In the report “Gender and Autism Spectrum Disorders” the author provides a great deal of evidence to support the concept that there are differences that are core to the separation of gender....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Significance of Benjamin Rush about the Transformation of the Medical Profession in America

The reason for this is his great contributions and revolutions he did in the medical profession in America.... Rush was born in 1745 in Byberry near Philadelphia.... He died in 1813 after 68 years of great… He was an educator and a physician.... This man also incorporated politics in his life....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Asperger's Syndrome

This essay functions to consider a number of important factors concerning Asperger's syndrome, including its history, severity, and treatment options, in an effort to gain a more informed understanding of its ramifications as a mental disorder afflicting thousands of individuals … While Asperger's syndrome isn't as debilitating a disability as other aspects of autism, it is nevertheless necessary to recognize its traits as it can pose a significant challenge for the individual and the individual's family....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Main Characteristics of Mental Retardation

nbsp; The major causes of intellectual disability are: Genetic disorders like Down syndrome and X syndrome.... The coursework "Main Characteristics of Mental Retardation" describes a medical condition where a person is not able to make sound judgments concerning situations in life....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us