StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Nobody downloaded yet

Ethical Argument - Essay Example

Summary
Mary Anne Warren, a prominent scholar in applied ethics, argues in her paper “On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion” that the premise that a fetus is a human person is fundamentally mistaken. She proceeds to offer her own criteria for personhood (precisely five in…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Ethical Argument
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ethical Argument"

Download file to see previous pages

follows from these premises is that the right to an abortion is absolute through all cases, and that no legal restriction on that right is philosophically justifiable. However, where it seems Warren’s arguments come off the track is right in the beginning, with her supposedly “overlooked” distinction between “human in the moral sense” and “human in the genetic sense”. This false dichotomy relies on two untenable theses: that (1) a human being is separable into distinct properties called “moral” and “biological” respectively, and that (2) the “genetic sense” of being a human being is less than worthy of moral considerations by virtue of its nature.

In defining the “moral community”, Warren offers five criteria for moral consideration as a person. These principles place a living being in either of two categories: “human in the moral sense” and “human in the genetic sense”. The “moral” sense of being human is that which is a human person, according to Warren, and abortion applies only to those beings which are not instances of this particular category. This makes it excusable to end the life of a human being which is only so in the “genetic” sense.

However, this rests on the assumption that we can metaphysically separate the properties of single beings into dichotomous categories like Warren proposes. We cannot because, for a human being, having a certain set of biological properties is a necessary condition of having a certain set of moral qualities. Warren says, however, that it is not a sufficient condition. She bases this conclusion on the thought that the “potential capacity for rational thought” (a biological property) does not allow us to make the jump to moral properties for the fetus (because it has this potency).

She claims “the potential capacity for rational thought can at most show that an entity has the potential for becoming human in the moral sense”. At this point, Warren seems to confuse

...Download file to see next pages Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethical Argument

Ethical Argument (Should Roe Vs. Wade be overturned) Should Abortion be outlawed

It is also an ineffective argument, as according to the Guttmacher Institute, Catholic women have abortions at about the same rate as non-Catholic women.... Absolutely not: this essay will look at the ethical dubiousness of the pro-life position, before highlighting the fundamental difference between the pro-life and pro-choice positions, to show that criminalizing abortion in modern America would subvert our self-image as the land of the free....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Comparison Peter Singer's and Garrett Hardin's Positions on Helping the Poor

He offers strong Ethical Argument from utilitarian and relativist prospective.... The Ethical Argument given by Singer is strong and coherent.... In this view Garrett Hardin's approach gives stronger Ethical Argument.... Garrett Hardin's article 'Lifeboat Ethics ' presents a solid argument against helping the poor.... Garrett Hardin's article “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor” presents solid argument against helping the poor....
9 Pages (2250 words) Article

Ethical Argument Paper

Ethical Argument on Abortion Introduction In several nations, the act of abortion is acceptable due to certain amount of reason, while on the contrary, countries have very strict rules against abortion and has even recognized the act as illegal.... In the case of United Kingdom it is 24 weeks, the concept of feasibility is very important to this argument because an individual is not recognized as a person until and unless the society accepts him as a person (Simons 142)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Provide an Ethical Argument against the Use of Dolphins in the US Navy for Military Purposes

Provide an Ethical Argument against the Use of Dolphins in the US Navy for Military Purposes ... Provide an Ethical Argument against the Use of Dolphins in the Us Navy for Military Purposes ... cientists were hoping Sea World's expert dolphin wranglers could catch several live diseased animals to permit more detailed studies, although quick answers aren't expected....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Ethical argument-Abortion

The main controversy of his argument is that at what point it is morally wise to charge fetal life as human life.... It seems that the most persuasive argument of the pro-choice lobby is that sometimes pregnancy occurs due to rape or incest.... The question of abortion is the most complex and debatable issue in medical practice dealing with moral and ethical principles and concerns....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Ethical Argument of The Omnivore's Dilemma

Today's commercial feedlots have garnered a lot of attention lately, especially by those who want a change in the current system of food production.... Whether it is organizations that want the animals in today's farms to be treated more humanely, or those who want to improve.... ... ... e nutrition, and thus health, of the population, or those who want to create a more environmental friendly approach to farming, or even those involved in the modern farming processes, there have been many voices that are raised both for and against commercial feedlots....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Legalizing Physician Assisted Suicide

On the other hand the Ethical Argument says that life should continue only if the person feels that it is better to live For instance the pro PAS or those who support euthanasia may advance Ethical Argument that that if a person is living in an unbearable pain and their quality of life is badly affected; they should decide to end life. ... Medically they have an argument that when a health care personnel, that Is doctor or nurse is under the obligation to carry out PAS, he or she will be in violation of medical ethic (rule) that propel all healthcare workers to have respect on life....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us