StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Should judges be elected, appointed, or selected on merit - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
These are important mechanisms that are designed to provide the judicial system with independent and accountable judiciary. But none of these selection methods…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
Should judges be elected, appointed, or selected on merit
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Should judges be elected, appointed, or selected on merit"

Judges selection is often through three main ways: election, direct appointment and/or merit (Glick & Emmert, 1987). These are important mechanisms that are designed to provide the judicial system with independent and accountable judiciary. But none of these selection methods have proved be totally free of outside pressure and hence the debate. The independence of judiciary is important issue that often comes under shroud. The states are either following hybrid method of selection or reforming their method to come up with the best way of selecting judges who can both be held accountable as well as are immune to outside pressure.

I believe that the merit based selection of judges is best as it would primarily rely on its legal expertise for judgment leading to sentencing. The role of judges is paramount in the legal arena. The need for independence in imposing sentences in offences becomes a crucial issue. The accountability to public opinion in cases directly linked to public welfare is an issue that frequently influences the selection pattern or raises controversy. The responsiveness to public opinion is deemed important but at the same time, the need to remain within the broader precinct of law and constitution is integral part of justice.

The judges who are selected through merit are prone to follow law and their judgment and sentences are based on legal statutes and clauses that cut across race, color, culture and socio-political leanings (O’Connor, 2010). This is fundamental to justice system that is not influenced by outside pressure, be it public opinion. The merit system of selection is also commendable because it ensures that selection of judges is done through a nominating committee which comprises of eminent lawyers and non lawyers of public repute.

The list of judges is forwarded to governor who appoints a judge from the list for a defined period. The second term of the judge is through election which the public can appropriately elect if it finds his/her performance up to its expectations. This is a critical parameter that gives public the right to oust the judge if the performance evaluation or the meritocracy level of judgment is found to be below par. Most importantly, the merit based selection promotes independence in judiciary that discourages political interference and undue pressure that could influence justice (Cann, 2007).

It also helps to appoint judges from sectors like minority and women who may otherwise be sidetracked by the vested interests. It also gives equal opportunities to people from small town as well as big cities. The need to promote merit based selection therefore hugely becomes desirable. While the elected judges tend to politicize judiciary through their political linkages, merit based judiciary system favors unbiased justice that is based on law. The well qualified and experienced judges are more inclined towards non partisan conviction that corroborates conviction or sentencing with the degree of seriousness of the crime.

One can therefore conclude that the merit based selection of judges is best. It balances independence with accountability. At the same time, it encourages selection of the judges from all segment of society that in itself promotes social justices cutting across race, color and gender.(words: 525)ReferenceCann, Damon. (March-April, 2007) Beyond accountability and independence: Judicial selection and state court performance. JUDICATURE, 90(5); 226-232.Henry Glick & Craig Emmert. (December-January, 1987) Selection System and Judicial Characteristics: The Recruitment of State Supreme Court Judges, JUDICATURE, 70; 228-235.

O’Connor, Sandra Day. (May 22, 2010). Take Justice off the Ballot. The New York Times. Retrieved from: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/23/opinion/23oconnor.html

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Should judges be elected, appointed, or selected on merit Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/law/1587701-should-judges-be-elected-appointed-or-selected-on-merit
(Should Judges Be Elected, Appointed, or Selected on Merit Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1587701-should-judges-be-elected-appointed-or-selected-on-merit.
“Should Judges Be Elected, Appointed, or Selected on Merit Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1587701-should-judges-be-elected-appointed-or-selected-on-merit.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should judges be elected, appointed, or selected on merit

Carrico Ending 42 Years On High Court

hellip; appointed judiciaries and the merits of establishing a mandatory retirement age for judges.... An elected judiciary is more accountable than an appointed one is.... appointed judiciary members, unlike elected ones, are likely to be impartial.... Effective judiciary systems are those that consist of appointed judges because they do not have to seek popularity among the masses, unlike the elected judges do.... Carrico Ending 42 Years on High Court Ethical advantages and disadvantages of an appointed vs....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Analysis of the Nevada Constitution

Article 5, sections 1 and 2 of Nevada constitution law provides that the governor be elected by qualified electors, while voting for members of the legislature and once in office, takes the supreme executive power of Nevada state vested on him or her as chief magistrate (“The constitution of ,” leg.... Powers of Nevada's governor compared to the president The governors in Nevada are elected and given responsibilities to perform in the state for a four year term....
11 Pages (2750 words) Term Paper

System of Government

    As a rule, the head of the state in such republics is selected by the parliament or specially created parliamentary board.... Elections of the head of the state in parliamentary republic can be carried out on the basis of the general suffrage that is characteristic for Austria where the president is selected for the period of six years.... The head of the government (the prime minister, chairman of ministerial council, the chancellor) is appointed, as a rule, by the president....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Qualifications and selection process for judges

Judicial merit Selection Commission makes screens the candidates and makes sure that they meet all the conditions required to become a particular judge.... f two-third members of House of Representatives votes against the judge, he/she may be prosecuted, and if two-third members of Senate votes against the judge, he/she may be convicted (Judicial merit Selection).... s/judicial_selection/methods/Judicial merit Selection.... The different types of courts in Ohio include The Supreme Court, Court of Appeals, Court of Claims, Court of Common Pleas, General Division, Juvenile Division, Ohio In Ohio, all judges are appointed through non-partisan elections, in which the political affiliations of the candidates are not listed on the ballot....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Judge Selection System in Texas: An Evaluation

The selection system will be merit-based and through a non-partisan and independent commission, chaired by Texas' Chief Justice of the Supreme Court (Leshy, 69).... The primary consideration in this design system is merit - the applicant's professional qualifications.... Prior to the interview, the commission receives any complaint, compliment or objection from the public, concerning the selected applicants, for vetting purposes.... Once the judges are appointed, there will be a periodic retention election, which means the voters will decide if they go on with their job on the bench or go home....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

The State Judicial Selection Process

In any case the retention panel notes or realizes that the merit and quality of the judge has taken a dip of whichever aspect, the judge would not be re-elected and henceforth lose his or her judgeship position and stature.... This is based on the… to begin with, the judges in the appellate courts are taken through a process called the assisted appointed which is squarely based on the Missouri plan.... The judges who serve in the lower courts such as the trial judges are Once a judicial officer ir a judge has been appointed, it would be expected that he or she would serve for a period of one year and then they would be subjected to a retention election based on the positive and negative affirmative yes or no....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Description of 7 and 8 Chapters of Americas Courts and the Criminal Justice System Book by Neubauer and Fradella

The merit collection process tends to cure these ills elements of the other-election and appointed-processes  Chapter 7 & 8Q#1: (Chapter 7) illustrates how defense attorneys can be subject to informal sanctions and rewards.... The merit collection process tends to cure these ills and in some way incorporate elements of the other-election and appointed-processes (Neubauer and Fradella 194).... This is because; elected or appointed judges tend to take the populist posture while deciding cases....
2 Pages (500 words) Coursework

Bolivars Idea of Government

Lastly, all appointed government officials are held responsible to the people on whom true sovereignty lies.... The legislative branch is composed of an elected Assembly, a hereditary Senate, and a board of Censors.... As the paper "Bolivars Idea of Government" outlines, the value and measure of merits and abilities lie wholly on the people who have the right to elect their legislators, governors, judges, and pastors who must have natural qualities of competence, honor, and will to command....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us