StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

How was Nazi Concentration Camp worser than Soviet Concentration Camps - Movie Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
In reality, both camps were horrible in their entirety, however; it is the Nazi concentration camp that left irremovable horror marks on the world human psychology. The question, “who was worse, Nazi or Stalin?” can be considered in two different contexts. This can be…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful
How was Nazi Concentration Camp worser than Soviet Concentration Camps
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "How was Nazi Concentration Camp worser than Soviet Concentration Camps"

Please clearly each point to how Nazi concentration camps are worse than soviet concentration camps? In reality, both camps were horrible in their entirety, however; it is the Nazi concentration camp that left irremovable horror marks on the world human psychology. The question, “who was worse, Nazi or Stalin?” can be considered in two different contexts. This can be interpreted as which regime killed more people? Or who’s motives were more heinous behind taking innocent lives?The Nazi regime killed on racial basis.

There is no doubt that they were eliminating an entire race of people based on religious or ethnic hate. On the other hand, Stalin regime was no worse. They killed millions of people for political gains. In the end, it all boils down to quality vs. quantity. Under which regime did more people died? Vs. which regime killed more brutally? The popular perception is that perhaps Stalin regime probably killed far more people than the Nazis. But records from relevant sources (scholars from Poland, Israel and Germany) show that Stalin regime killed far less people than Nazis.

The Nazi regime focused their attention on one race. Holocaust was targeted towards Jews and the majority of them were tortured to death or died from starvation. Stalin regime did kill millions of people in Gulag but these numbers are far less than Nazi killings. There is a certain reason as to why the Holocaust is considered far worse than the crimes committed by the Stalin. Labeling an entire race of people as ‘outcasts’ is more brutal than finding political excuses to take people’s lives.

People who suffered under Stalin regime probably could have found an excuse to spare their lives by paying strict taxes but Jews had no chance under Hitler’s rein. They were either supposed to flea of die. It is sad and satirical to count dead bodies and claim a winner in this debate. Numbers of killings doesn’t matter. It’s about human lives and tragedy that was hammered down upon people living in both countries. Some people say that the number in Stalin camps were far more than the people at Nazi concentration camp.

But when a loved one is lost, it is only the family that actually suffers and knows how much it hurts. For instance the argument about the number of people who were murder at Treblinka; whether they were 780,862 or 780,863 doesn’t make much sense. It is a huge number and the tragedy doesn’t subside by thinking that it is a huge number. The individual life matters and there is no truth beyond that. All these people were humans and they left loved ones to mourn their death. Nazis killed much more people than Stalin regime.

According to rough estimation the people perished at the hands of Hitler is somewhere around 11 million and these were non-combatants, whereas people who lost their lives in Gulag and other territories between 1933 and 1945 (where Stalin regime was in power) is somewhere around between 2 and 3 million. People can misunderstand the catastrophe that was brought down upon by nature for the brutality of Stalin. A huge number of people died from starvation, not by deliberate killings. Above 5 million people perished in the famine of 1930-1933 when USSR was under Stalin regime.

But that fact doesn’t lessen the crimes of Stalin. Out of that staggering number of 5 million, over 3.3 million people were deliberately killed under some ‘policy’. Between 1932 and 1933, USSR announced a policy tied to national interests that required liquidating prosperous peasants ‘kulaks’. This was in the hopes of expanding the industry muscles of the country by taking capital resources from the agriculture and putting them into industry. Stalinism killings (most of them) took place in the time of peace and can be related to nationalism, political motives and related arguments.

However, the main culprit of waging and fanning the flames of war is Nazi Germany. They targeted specific ethnicity (racial imperialism). Nazi concentration camps were far worse than Stalin camps. They were more brutal and took more lives. There can truly be no comparison as far as the sheer brutality of killings is concerned. When Hitler came to power, he had one motive in mind; to eliminate Jews from Europe. Chełmno, Bełżec, Sobibór and Treblinka were known for their ‘gas vans’ and ‘death factories’, which were only designed to exterminate Polish Jews.

That is why the Nazi concentration camps were far worse than Stalin’s. Source"The New York Review of Books." Hitler vs. Stalin: Who Was Worse? by Timothy Snyder. Web. 16 Apr. 2012. .

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“How was Nazi Concentration Camp worser than Soviet Concentration Camps Movie Review”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1594210-how-was-nazi-concentration-camp-worser-than-soviet-concentration-camps
(How Was Nazi Concentration Camp Worser Than Soviet Concentration Camps Movie Review)
https://studentshare.org/history/1594210-how-was-nazi-concentration-camp-worser-than-soviet-concentration-camps.
“How Was Nazi Concentration Camp Worser Than Soviet Concentration Camps Movie Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1594210-how-was-nazi-concentration-camp-worser-than-soviet-concentration-camps.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF How was Nazi Concentration Camp worser than Soviet Concentration Camps

Difference in Nazi Policies in the Period between 1933 and 1940 and between 1940 and 1945

In the first years, actions were lighter than during the later years.... number Date Difference in nazi policies in the period between 1933 and 1940 and that between 1940 and 1945.... Thus, the nazi Germany set up policies and laws to be implemented in their racial policy based on superiority (42).... nazi Germany Policies In the book “War and Genocide: A concise history of the holocaust”, Bergen brings out the difference between policies during the period between 1933 and 1940 and those of the period between 1940 and 1945....
3 Pages (750 words) Term Paper

Peoples Attitude toward Death and God in the Holocaust

Many in Israel were jealous of the honest attempts made by Kasztner to save the lives of Jews from certain death in the concentration camps.... How can a 14 year old digest the intricacies of philosophical logic related to death The devastating novel by Imre Kertesz, "Fateless" is about the life in concentration camp, of Gyorgy Koves, a Hungarian Jew .... Simon Wiesenthal, in his book, "The Sunflower," describes such a situation thus: "And one piece of bad news followed another, each more alarming than the last....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Arendt and Solzhenitsyn

The book on the Holocaust provided several excerpts from Arendt's previous commentaries on the trial of this Nazi named Adolf Eichmann, a Gestapo chief, who later history would place as the man responsible for the mass extermination of all the Jews who were held in concentration camps.... To achieve this would mean understanding the rationale and causal effects of the perpetrations of the inhumanity in the genocidal murders and the grueling experiences in the Soviet prison camps, and eventually rethinking whether the same would have been possible were it not for the modern methods that were adopted to further brutalize the population....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

What Is Demoralization and How It Is Related To Society and People

These people were demoralized in concentration camps all over Europe....  This essay discusses demoralization and how it is related to society and people.... It analyses what or who generally causes demoralization.... Demoralisation is when one individual puts another person down....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Chris Markers Sans Soleil and Alain Resnais Nuit et Brouillard

The male narrator simply relates the series of events that start from the rounding up of the people who were being sent to the concentration camps.... n Nuit et Brouillard, the script is very objective and it portrays the suffering of the prisoners of concentration camps in Nazi Germany.... With most of the focus on the notorious Auschwitz concentration camp, the documentary which was filmed ten years after the Holocaust ended (1955), lays bare the atrocities committed therein....
6 Pages (1500 words) Movie Review

The Reactions by the Prisoners of the Concentration Camp in Works' Frankl Mans Search for Meaning

This report "The Reactions by the Prisoners of the Concentration Camp in Works' Frankl Mans Search for Meaning" attempts to recount Victor Frankl's experiences while incarcerated in the nazi concentration camp and how his experiences can be put in the perspective of human life.... In the book, there is an identification of the various reactions by the prisoners of the concentration camp towards their experiences in one degree or the other.... The first of these is the shock that they come to experience once they are admitted into the camp....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

Chindler's List

hellip; The novel focuѕeѕ on how Ѕchindler comeѕ to the realization that concentration and forced labor campѕ are wrong, and that many people were dying through no fault of their own.... This work called "Ѕchindler'ѕ Liѕt" describes a biography of Oѕkar Ѕchindler, but it iѕ the ѕtory of how good can overcome evil and how the charity can overcome greed.... Ѕchindlerѕ Liѕt iѕ not juѕt a biography of Oѕkar Ѕchindler, but it iѕ the ѕtory of how good can overcome evil and how the charity can overcome greed....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Victor Frankl's Man Search for Meaning

This book review "Victor Frankl's Man Search for Meaning" discusses Frankl that explains the horrific suffering he and his immediate family underwent as prisoners in the Nazi concentration camps.... To him, suffering is when his entire family; wife, mother, father, brother save for his sister all died....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us