StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Comparison of Two Medieval Theocracies - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The writer of this paper states that though there’s been much recent conversation centered around Middle Eastern theocracy, there can be little doubt that the golden age of religious-based government occurred during the Middle Ages.  …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Comparison of Two Medieval Theocracies
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comparison of Two Medieval Theocracies"

of God, of the World A comparative look at the theocratic governmental systems of Arabia and Europe during the Middle Ages Though there’sbeen much recent conversation centered around Middle Eastern theocracy, there can be little doubt that the golden age of religious-based government occurred during the Middle Ages. As the Christian church shaped and dominated the political structure of Western Europe, so too did the Islamic faith help to create the government and political structure in the East. For the first — and only — time in recorded history, the major powers of the world were guided by religious zeal rather than military prowess or economic ends. Both Christianity and Islam achieved status not just as state supported religions but as strong political entities in their own rights. Yet though both cultures developed theocratic systems of government during the medieval period, we will see that they came to that system of government through very different means and enacted quite different measures to secure and maintain that system. First, though, we should consider the nature of theocracy itself. In a theocratic government, religion forms the basis for political decisions. Government leadership and religious leadership are synonymous, since faith in the governing religion is a prerequisite to political power. Religious texts and tenets provide the backbone for civil law and government. Those members of a theocratic society who do not espouse the prevailing faith may be disenfranchised at best and persecuted at worst. Such was the case when Christianity became the prevailing religion in Western Europe during the Middle Ages — an ironic development since Christians themselves had been a persecuted class in the Roman Empire from the time of Nero (54-68) until the emperor Constantine was converted to Christianity in the early 300s (Tierney). The dramatic power shift led to the most significant power struggle of the medieval period in Europe: the uneasy problem of church and state. Constantine had brought the church to a position of previously unimagined power, but in return, he expected the unwavering alliance of the church — in matters of faith as well as matters of government, as the great debate over the Arian and Nicene faiths in the 300s demonstrated. The challenge was that Christianity had to win over strong, existing systems of government and people whose religious were as sophisticated and compelling (and sometimes more fun) than Christianity. How could a theocracy come to bear in a system of existing governments? The church was inventive — it assimilated pagan traditions to make its asceticism more palatable, creating convenient saints whose holy days corresponded with favored pagan holidays and whose attributes mirrored those of pagan deities. (Saint Brigid, in Ireland, is a good example of this; she has many elements of the Celtic goddess, who had Brigid as one of her names.) But it could not have succeeded in its theocratic efforts without the genius of Saint Augustine of Hippo (354-440). Augustine combined the philosophical sophistication of Plato with religious zeal to write City of God. In it, he explained that there were two governments ruling the lives of men: the City of the World, in which kings ruled, laws were passed and taxes paid, and the City of God, in which people’s hearts and lives were set on heaven. Though Augustine didn’t blatantly attack secular government or identify his City of God with the church, he set up the framework of western theocracy that would survive most of the Middle Ages. Kings ruled physical kingdoms, but God ruled even kings — and the church was the hand and voice of God on earth. People’s first loyalty was to God, not to the king, though as long as the king was obeying God’s law, his people should obey him. And the church was there to say when the king stopped obeying God’s law. It was a brilliant solution to the problem of church and state, and its effects reverberate through the western world to this day. Islam emerged in a different environment entirely. Before the emergence of Islam, there was no real government in the Islamic world at all — Brian Tierney describes Arabia before the seventh century as “a sort of no-man’s land between the Byzantine and Persian empires” (123). The nomadic tribes who made their homes there were anarchistic and unsettled. There was no existing power structure with which to contend. The country was ripe for unification, and because the man who would unite them had had a revelatory religious experience, the unification was a religious one. Mohammed (ca. 570-632) made no distinction between the religious and the political: To be a faithful Muslim, one must be faithful to Mohammed (Tierney 125). And because one of the central tenets of Islam as Mohammed formulated it was a willingness to fight for the faith and because Mohammed proved to be an excellent military leader in addition to an inspired prophet, it was not hard for Mohammed to spread Islam through Arabia. Still, it does not do Mohammed justice to suggest that it was strength alone that swayed the Arab world toward theocracy. Though the small tribal and city leaders might have resented Mohammed’s preaching, most of the ordinary people welcomed it (Stewart). The religion was appealing: “more sophisticated and satisfying than their own local cults,” says Tierney (125). Islam put all faithful into the same boat, regardless of class or societal position. Its emphasis on mercy and justice, kindness and charity to the poor and weak, and careful rules about diet and behavior must have seemed like an oasis of reason and peace in the sea of anarchy that was 700s Arabia. Before Mohammed’s death, all the tribes of central Arabia came together to accept Islam as their common faith. In doing so, they also accepted Islam as their political center, and unlike the Christian church in Europe, Islam did not have to weave its theocracy into existing political structure. It was able to manifest itself from the ground up, so that Mohammed was not just the prophet of Allah, he was also the first leader of the united Arabic nation (Tierney). At his side were the merchants of Mecca, a small oligarchy of economic strength in Arabia who quickly applied their capitalist zeal toward religious faith. The revelations of Mohammed became the political as well as the religious basis for Islamic society. The legislation of government, or shari’a, essentially equated the principles of religious life with the principles of social life: The first and primary source for law making and judgment was the Koran. Morality and legality were intrinsically intertwined. After Mohammed’s death, the theocratic system was already so securely in place that it continued with the rule of caliphs, or deputies, who carried on the tradition of church as state for the Arabic people. As you can see, the emergence of the Christian theocracy and the Muslim theocracy differed by necessity: Because the Christians had to contend with an existing political structure, they drew a distinction between the religious and the merely political (Stewart). It was a distinction that ultimately allowed them to become the spiritual rulers of the Western world, guarding their power with the threat of holy war and excommunication. Islamic theocracy, on the other hand, was as holistic as Christianity was divisive. The political structure of Islam did not have to subvert the existing government but to create it, basing its legislative and judicial principles directly on religious dogma. Both Christianity and Islam, however, suffered from the same inevitable fact of human existence: Where there is power, there will be corruption. By the late medieval period, the Christian church had become riddled with corruption and leadership that valued political power over religious zeal. Martin Luther’s Reformation was the inevitable response to theocratic failure: The political had replaced the religious, effectively ending the theocratic rule. The power struggles in Islam led to in-fighting and divisiveness among the various Arabic states, as disagreement arose over who was best suited to lead the religious and political future of Arabia. WORKS CITED Said, Edward. Culture and Imperialism. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1993. Stewart, Desmond. Early Islam. New York: Time-Life Books, 1967. Tierney, Brian. The Crisis of Church and State, 1050-1300. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1964. Tierney, Brian and Sidney Painter. Western Europe in the Middle Ages: 300-1475. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1992. Yale, William. The Near East: A Modern History. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press, 1958. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Comparison of Two Medieval Theocracies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Comparison of Two Medieval Theocracies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1548697-comparison-of-two-medieval-theocracies
(Comparison of Two Medieval Theocracies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Comparison of Two Medieval Theocracies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/history/1548697-comparison-of-two-medieval-theocracies.
“Comparison of Two Medieval Theocracies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1548697-comparison-of-two-medieval-theocracies.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparison of Two Medieval Theocracies

Comparison of Two Dissertations

comparison of two PAST DISSERTATIONS NAME OF INSTITUTION 16th APRIL 2013 comparison of two past dissertations This essay involves a comparison of two dissertations done in the past in different institutions.... The staffs proposed for completions of the tool were; four of the twelve West Sussex County council commissioning managers and two of the four NHS Sussex Commissioning Managers....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Muslim and Christian Medieval Theocracies

hellip; theocracies are found throughout history and in recent times.... This essay will focus on Islamic and Christian theocracies during medieval times and will compare the two.... In many theocracies of the past the ruler has been one who was designated by the religious leader of that time and place.... Christianity has spread around the world despite the fact that few Christian theocracies exist.... The major religions during medieval times were Christianity and Islam....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Comparison between Two Sisters

The researcher explores how two people can be vastly different and yet similar simultaneously.... rdquo;… The researcher states that when he was studying primary school biology, he remembers the teacher once told them that all of the character traits which children exhibit are inherited from their ancestors, and yet here they were, two sisters who a stranger could never tell had the same blood running through their veins.... This paper illustrates that two years back the author's cousin, Kate invited him over to California during the summers to spend the vacations with her family, and the researcher had readily accepted the invitation....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Medieval / Modern Islamic Civilization Comparison

As such, the Muslim community had a number of innovation and creativity during the medieval age when it was undergoing civilization.... This paper will be a discussion of the reason why medieval/MODERN ISLAMIC CIVILISATION COMPARISON medieval/Modern Islamic Civilization Comparison One of the things that are synonymous with the medieval age is innovation.... As such, the Muslim community had a number of innovation and creativity during the medieval age when it was undergoing civilization....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Comparison of two friends

Aziz and I are good friends even though we differ… For example, I like to play PlayStation but he likes to play Xbox, I like playing soccer but Aziz likes to play tennis, and I'm interested in Egyptian culture but he likes Asian culture. Our backgrounds differ in that we grew up with parents whose style of comparison of two friends November 25, Every one of us has some friends....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Comparison between two books

Criminological theories can be categorized as macro theories if they explain crimes in the context of the larger society and This study aims at examining and analyzing the approaches used by two books in explaining criminological issues and the criminal justice system in America.... The two books are Criminological Theories and Rebuilding Justice....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Comparison of Two Types of Operational Budgets

The operating and financial budgets are the two parts of a master budget.... A comparison is then drawn between the… Flexible budgeting starts with the identification of all fixed costs and their isolation in the form of a budget (Finkler, Jones & Kovner, 2013).... This accounts for the small variances registered in this comparison than those registered under static budget....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Companion to Medieval and Renaissance Music

This assignment "Companion to medieval and Renaissance Music" discusses monophony that is known to have its roots in the 6th century.... The Gregorian chant was named for Pope Gregory because he codified and standardized its use, therefore, promoted its use in the Roman liturgy.... hellip; It was a requirement for the Catholic Church that all the music used for the liturgy was monophonic....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us