StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Two Predominant Power Poles: the USSR and the USA - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper “The Two Predominant Power Poles: the USSR and the USA” compares and contrasts two articles: Matthew Parris’s It’s Time We All Signed Up for the Rest of the World Team and Laura Miller’s “America the Ignorant”. They have tried to analyze the role of the USA in the post-Cold War scenario…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93% of users find it useful
The Two Predominant Power Poles: the USSR and the USA
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Two Predominant Power Poles: the USSR and the USA"

of the English of the Concerned 2 December Critical Analysis (Between Two Essays) It is a strange irony that the world has been deciphering the intricacies of the geopolitical political dynamics in the light of the strategic interests of a few dominant nations that tend to have a more than average say and impact in the world politics. During the Cold War, the world politics hovered around the two predominant power poles that are the USSR and the USA. However, with the end of the Cold War, the world stage is left open to one single dominant power that is the USA. Varied intellectuals and think tanks have been contriving varied theories to size up the role of the only left super power that is the USA on the world stage. In that context, Matthew Parris in his article It’s Time We All Signed Up for the Rest of the World Team and Laura Miller in her article America the Ignorant; have tried to minutely analyze the role of the United States of America in the post Cold War scenario. However, both the authors tend to differ in the approach they use to influence the target audience and the rhetorical strategies resorted to by them to come out with a convincing argument. Hence, it will be really interesting to analyze the premises resorted to by both the authors in their effort to move the target audience towards their way of thinking. Certainly, it would not be wrong to say that Matthew Parris tends to draw the picture of a highly polarized word, where the United States of America tends to be one dominant pole, and the other nations are painted as hesitant and subservient forces, many of which are trying their best to chalk out an independent foreign policy, which is significantly devoid of the American influence and happens to be independent and sovereign in its scope and dynamics. Even a cursory perusal of the article It’s Time We All Signed Up for the Rest of the World Team leads to the conclusion that Parris is trying to target an audience that is in the favor of a multi-polar world and that is averse to the dominance of the United States of America in the shaping of the world politics. Parris comes out as being supportive of the efforts of the sovereign nations that are desirous of coming together to do away with the American dominance, so as to contrive a geopolitical strategy that is self serving and independent. Yet, the weak point about Parris argument is that it fails to come out as a reasonable and cohesive argument in the support of the cause that it intends to uphold. So far as the element of logos is concerned, Parris argument comes out as being totally divest of the deductive and inductive reasoning that could justifiably prove that the US is acting as the only left dominant influence in the world affairs. When it comes to ethos, Parris indeed manages to throw his weight as an astute politician and his expansive experience as a seasoned reporter behind his argument. However, once the Parris’ argument is divested of the weight of the personality that is trying to assert it, the whole argument comes out as being something that is totally emotive and lacking the weight of the factual evidence and the sighting of the scholarly sources that may support and bolster it. To put it in a few words, the line of Parris’s argument predominantly relies on the pathos to make its way into the target audience’s sense of reason. Parris nowhere seems to care to prop up his assertion with the requisite evidence and sources. Hence, in a conclusive context, Parris assertion is emotive, weak and devoid of the much needed factual evidence. In contrast, Laura Miller in her article America the Ignorant tries to correlate the much infamous fiascos in the American foreign policy to the commensurate short sightedness, ignorance and complacence of the American masses. Miller tries to bring home the fact that the American education system is such that it fails to endow the American masses with the fundamental facts and information pertaining to international geography and geopolitics that could be exploited by them to make a sense of the international politics being pursued by the American leadership. Miller tries her best to belabor the point that owing to this factual paucity of the American masses regarding the world geography and the associated political and social concepts, the American media has been pulling out of the policy to accrue an expansive coverage to the international political and strategic issues. In other words, Miller emphatically decries the passive attitude of the American masses towards the international strategic maneuvers being indulged in by the American political class. The good thing about Miller’s line of argument is that it is able to support its forthcoming premises with the commensurate facts properly ascribed to, to the authentic academic institutions and the experts who have a deep insight into the American foreign policy. When it comes to logos, Miller bolsters and supports her logic with the appropriate factual evidence and facts that lie in the sphere of public awareness. Miller indeed manages to put the weight of the ethos driven appeal that her editorial experience commands, right behind her line of argument. However, nowhere Miller comes out as a rabid and opinionated personality that tries to take away her audience for a ride by pandering to the emotive side of their personality. All over, Miler’s line of argument is factual, evidence based and credible in its scope and framework. To put it in a few words, though both the writers that are Matthew Parris and Laura Miller are trying to make a sense of the current status of the US as the sole surviving super power and its role in the world politics, in a rhetorical context, Miller comes out as being more factual, authentic and logical. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Two Predominant Power Poles: the USSR and the USA Article”, n.d.)
The Two Predominant Power Poles: the USSR and the USA Article. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1462152-critical-analysisbetween
(The Two Predominant Power Poles: The USSR and the USA Article)
The Two Predominant Power Poles: The USSR and the USA Article. https://studentshare.org/history/1462152-critical-analysisbetween.
“The Two Predominant Power Poles: The USSR and the USA Article”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1462152-critical-analysisbetween.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Two Predominant Power Poles: the USSR and the USA

The Effects Of Social Networks On E-Commerce

Therefore, customers have a better bargaining power.... The impact of social networks has been exceedingly significant on the way communication between internet users is conducted in everyday life.... Over the past years, the internet was used by majority of people as a medium for interaction and making fun by engaging in activities such as online gaming....
7 Pages (1750 words) Dissertation

Integrative Vision for Technology

hellip; DDS, in its predominant ideology, was meant to be designed as a virtual (digital) city that would promote public interaction within the community as well as with the politicians.... An essay "Integrative Vision for Technology " reports that the city was to be the first of its kind in the Netherlands and its initial test phase was to be carried out in Amsterdam....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

What Is Electronic Authentication

Our existence in society has become dependent on proving our credentials, our identity and our right of access to a certain set of resources.... Whereas, authentication in computer science as Schellekens (2004, pg.... 60)… In all such instances, one is supposed too furnish a requisite identity to the concerned authorities that would establish our eligibility Authentication procedures in the modern day rely extensively on electronic methods....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Secessions of Kosovo, Abkhazia, and South Ossetia

A review of the literature seems to suggest that power politics has a role to play in the responses to these secessions.... The purpose of this research is to demonstrate that power politics permits what amounts to a spin on the international legal framework for statehood and state recognition.... It will be argued that from a purely legal perspective the secessions are no different from one another, and power politics plays a greater role in the international community's responses than international customary law....
70 Pages (17500 words) Essay

How Does Spyware Work

The paper "How Does Spyware Work?... points out In the past years, many security issues have emerged.... Though organizations and individuals are continuously adopting strict measures to deal with these challenges, their efforts are less productive against such serious attacks such as spyware programs....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Specifics of Cold War

Nevertheless the two superpowers did not engage in a fight or applied weapons against each other, but the war was fought using nuclear weapons, the proxy wars, propaganda and… The end of the Cold War resulted in the world structure to shift from multipolar and bipolar to unipolar which also caused in statbilities in Third World Nations through withdrawal and disengagement of superpowers, ethnic issues and The falling of the Berlin wall in 1989 marked the end of the Cold War and as a result the world moved from a state of military multipolarity to a state of unipolarity which still exists today....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Why Have There Been so Many Wars in the Middle East since 1945

The Middle East was an extension of the Cold War theatre between the ussr and the usa for four decades (Beverly Milton and Peter Hinchcliffe, 2008 p.... The author outlines Colonial powers, the role of the superpowers: the Soviet Union and the usa in the region, natural resources.... The western powers divided this region into several sections so as to help them impose their own power.... Another predominant influence can be seen in the Israel-Palestine conflict in the Middle East....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Pros and Cons of the Semi-Sovereign Democracy in the Germany

In such a state of affair, the course of semi-sovereign democracy in Germany should not be determined by power politics but people's politics.... Although the policymakers are often practicing too much anti-militarism or excessive power politics, people of Germany are expected to redefine semi-sovereign democracy in a realistic and beneficial way.... However, in 1989, GDR dissolved in the Federal Republic and the present day the Federal Republic of Germany has emerged as a significant power in Central Europe with its own political line....
15 Pages (3750 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us