StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Comparison of Environmental Effects of Steel and Concrete Framed Buildings - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
This assignment "Comparison of Environmental Effects of Steel and Concrete Framed Buildings" presents concrete that offers the best possible choice in terms of structural integrity and sustainability although its construction costs are higher than timber…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Comparison of Environmental Effects of Steel and Concrete Framed Buildings
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comparison of Environmental Effects of Steel and Concrete Framed Buildings"

Introduction Designing and constructing sustainable buildings revolves around balancing social, environmental as well as economic considerations simultaneously. The current building (Brunel University’s Lecture Centre) is in large part constructed using a concrete frame. The building is envisaged for reconstruction and this presents a number of options to designers such as timber frame, steel frame and composites. However, the final say on the matter can only be arrived at after balancing social, environmental and economic considerations for these differentiated methods of construction. 1.1. Social Buildings have to comply with social considerations of sustainability so that they must provide safe, comfortable and healthy interiors. In order to meet these objectives the major considerations are ensuring structural integrity, dealing with vibration levels, adequate weather protection, fire resistance and acoustic performance. 1.2. Economic Economic considerations play a major and often deciding role in determining what kinds of materials to use for construction purposes. The major considerations are that buildings ought to be durable, reusable, require low maintenance and energy efficient. These considerations need to be satisfied both during the building phase as well as during the operation phase. Some other considerations include the construction costs, net lettable area, building reuse value, construction programmes and whole of life value. 1.3. Environmental Environmental considerations mandate that buildings ought to be constructed in a manner that their whole-of-life energy use as well as their greenhouse gas emissions produce a small ecological footprint. The major considerations are the life cycle assessment (LCA), cooling of urban areas, thermal mass and recycling. Appendix ‘A’ shows the mutually common area that social, environmental and economic factors share to produce a truly sustainable design. 2. Sustainability of Current Lecture Centre Building Concrete has been in extensive use around the globe as a preferred construction material for residential and commercial applications alike (Goodchild, 1997). When put in perspective of sustainability, concrete has a number of advantages to offer including (but not limited to) economic considerations, durability, acoustic performance, recyclability, thermal mass, fire resistance and adaptability. The factors listed above can be optimised to achieve maximised sustainability from concrete construction based on construction techniques and other considerations. The current Lecture Centre Building at Brunel University is made out of concrete in large part and offers a sustainable outlook based on social, economic and environmental considerations. These are discussed below in detail. 2.1. Social Concrete buildings are able to offer structural integrity along with structural requirements that are well understood by designers and builders alike. This leads to the construction of safer structures that are able to stand up to risks such as snow, earthquakes, wind base loading etc. The large mass involved in concrete construction ensures that these structures provide excellent damping characteristics that are required for minimising vibration. In addition, concrete provides exceptional fire resistance given that it does not burn at all and does not emit toxic fumes when exposed to fire (Ching, 1995). For most cases concrete structures can be described as fire proof. Similarly, concrete structures are able to offer excellent acoustic damping characteristics as well which mandates the lowest possible use of insulation materials. 2.2. Economic Concrete buildings are the most economical solution when it comes to multi-storey buildings (please see Appendix ‘C’ for a comparison). The large amount of benefits that are provided by concrete such as fire resistance, large thermal mass and durability ensure that concrete buildings have lower operating costs and maintenance requirements. Building reuse is also more common for concrete structure for example old warehouses are converted into office space at little cost (Sezen, 2011). 2.3. Environmental LCA cannot be under stressed for any building under consideration. Estimates reveal that concrete buildings with a 50-year life cycle use only 10% of their total energy requirements when being built and instead the largest energy requirements stem from the operational phase of the building (please see Appendix ‘B’ for a comparison) (Cement Concrete & Aggregates Australia, 2010). Furthermore, the energy consumption for a concrete structure and a steel structure are nearly the same during the construction phase. Thermal mass describes the building’s ability to store thermal energy and release it a few hours later and serves an important part in determining the heating and cooling loads for comfortable residence (Cement Concrete & Aggregates Australia, 2010). Portland cement used for concrete construction offers an albedo between 0.35 and 0.8 leading to greater reflection of incoming electromagnetic radiation (Geem, 2002). This in turn leads to cooler urban areas. When a concrete building is recycled, the resulting aggregate cannot be used for rebuilding but instead gets used for landfill and road base building purposes. 3. Re-Selecting Construction Materials Governmental regulations require that most buildings meet a net zero carbon emissions stipulation by 2019. In this respect, alternative construction materials are being considered for the Lecture Building at Brunel University. The materials under consideration include concrete, steel, timber and composites. A comparison of these materials is provided below to select a preferable material for construction. 3.1. Structural Integrity Structural integrity is the core most requirement for any construction based outcome. When the structural integrity of the selected construction materials is compared it becomes obvious that concrete and steel are able to offer the greatest structural integrity especially for high rise buildings. In contrast, composites offer greater structural integrity than timber but it is still low when compared to concrete and steel. Given that the Central Lecture Building is not a high rise it can be surmised then that concrete, steel and composites could be used because timber would be unable to support the multi-storey structure. 3.2. Social In terms of social aspects, the first thing to consider is fire resistance. Concrete is able to offer the greatest fire resistance followed by steel and composites. Unfortunately, timber is itself combustible and is unable to offer any fire resistance even with large amounts of fire resistance cladding. Concrete has the greatest resistance to fire as it is not affected by high temperatures because of its non-combustible nature and because it cannot be melted. In contrast, steel can offer decent fire resistance with fire proof claddings but it cannot withstand heat for prolonged periods. Any extended fires can damage steel structures to a large degree though it is rare that steel structures are damaged beyond repair. When considering composites it is necessary to see what the composite in question is made out of. For high steel composites the same fire resistance issues may emerge as well. In addition, concrete structures offer the best vibration protection as well as acoustical performance. Steel structures can match these characteristics only with a large amount of cladding that often increases the size of the structure required to support it. Consequently, when a steel structure needs to be fire proofed and its acoustic performance needs to be improved then its cost rises dramatically. Furthermore, all available construction material options provide suitable weather protection as long as thermal mass considerations are not taken into account (Froeschle, 1999). 3.3. Environmental In terms of environmental considerations, the first thing to look into is the LCA for the selected materials. Concrete and steel offer nearly the same amount of energy consumption during the construction phase (Guggemos & Horvarth, 2005) making them bear an equal environmental footprint. In contrast, composites lie close to steel and concrete in terms of energy usage in the construction phase while timber has the lowest energy consumption during construction. However, when the operational costs of these materials are considered it becomes obvious that concrete has the lowest operational costs followed by steel, composites and finally timber. Concrete provides a large thermal mass that offers lowering of energy input for heating and cooling purposes. In contrast, steel has a low thermal mass and bolstering the thermal mass requires upgrading the structure to bear the additional weight. Timber requires extensive insulation to make it more environmentally friendly while composites lie between timber and steel for their operational costs. However, when the issue of urban cooling is considered it becomes obvious that concrete and timber have relatively low albedos leading to distortion in cooling patterns. On the other hand, steel structures offer better albedos due to the extensive use of glass which is similar to composite based structures (NHBC Foundation, 2007). As for recycling, steel offers the greatest advantage at recycling because it is totally recyclable which is not true for any of the other materials being considered. 3.4. Economic The construction costs for concrete and steel are near equal (as steel prices have shot up in recent years). However, these costs are large when compared to timber construction while composite construction requires the greatest cost largely due to few contractors handling such materials and their construction. The whole-of-life value for concrete is the highest followed by steel, composites and then timber. Moreover, concrete and steel building reuse is far higher when compared to composites and timber. 4. Conclusion Overall, concrete offers the best possible choice in terms of structural integrity and sustainability although its construction costs are higher than timber. Steel structures offer close competition but fail to deliver the required LCA and whole-of-life value that would make them just as or more sustainable. 5. References Cement Concrete & Aggregates Australia. (2010). CCCA Comparison of LCA. Retrieved March 8, 2012, from Cement Concrete & Aggregates Australia: http://www.ccaa.com.au/LCA Cement Concrete & Aggregates Australia. (2010). Thermal Mass Benefits for Housing. Perth: Cement Concrete & Aggregates Australia. Ching, F. (1995). A Visual Dictionary of Architecture. Amsterdam: Van Nostrand Reinhold Company. Froeschle, L. (1999). Environmental Assessment and Specification of Green Building Materials. The Construction Specifier , 53. Geem, V. (2002). Albedo of Concrete and Selected Other Materials. Retrieved March 7, 2012, from Construction Technologies: http://www.lehigcement.com/Education Goodchild, C. (1997). Economic Concrete Frame Elements. 1st ed. . Berkshire: British Cement Association. Guggemos, A. A., & Horvarth, A. (2005). Comparison of Environmental Effects of Steel and Concrete Framed Buildings. Journal of Infrastructure Systems ASCE . NHBC Foundation. (2007). Climate Change and Innovation in House Building: Designing out Risk. Retrieved March 7, 2012, from NHBC Foundation: http://www.nhbcfoundation.org/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=viZ9mWU9cqQ%3D&tabid=339&mid=774&language=en-GB Sezen, H. (2011). Reinforced Concrete Frame and Wall Buildings. Retrieved March 7, 2012, from http://nisee.berkeley.edu/turkey/Fturkch3.pdf 6. Appendix ‘A’ 7. Appendix ‘B’ Figure 1 - Energy used on three CCAA warehouse life cycle examples studied (Cement Concrete & Aggregates Australia, 2010) 8. Appendix ‘C’ Figure 2 - Total cost of medium-rise commercial building structural frames by location (8.4 x 8.4 m grid) (Cement Concrete & Aggregates Australia, 2010) Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Construction Materials Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/engineering-and-construction/1444474-construction-materials
(Construction Materials Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/engineering-and-construction/1444474-construction-materials.
“Construction Materials Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/engineering-and-construction/1444474-construction-materials.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparison of Environmental Effects of Steel and Concrete Framed Buildings

Framing Construction Techniques

e on Steel framed buildings 15 7.... The coefficient of thermal expansion of concrete is also low and concrete tends to shrink as it ages.... tructural effects of Fir.... xamples of buildings 6 3.... xamples of buildings 9 4.... xamples of buildings 11 5.... Concrete frames cost marginally lower than steel frame construction for high rise buildings that need to bear massive loads....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Construction Technology: Provisions of the Basic Environmental Envelope and the Effects of Weather on Buildings

Glazing is utmost generally accepted in energy terms because it replaces perfectly serviceable even in thermally inefficient steel frames.... Moreover, if the glazing of frames needs replacement, you need to consider the over-cost of the high-performance system in comparison to the base-case option courtesy of the Building Regulations....
16 Pages (4000 words) Term Paper

Steel in Construction

The paper gives detailed information about Steel in Construction and careful selection of environmentally sustainable building materials is the easiest way for architects to begin incorporating sustainable design principles in buildings.... However, the 'off-the-shelf' price of a building component represents only the manufacturing and transportation costs, not social or environmental costs....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Framing Construction Techniques

The coefficient of thermal expansion of concrete is also low and concrete tends to shrink as it ages.... concrete frames are also known better as reinforced concrete frames and are composed of vertical elements known as columns and horizontal elements known as beams.... Reinforced concrete frames are constructed in a number of different ways.... The major ones are:concrete displays a high compressive strength but relatively lower tensile strength....
19 Pages (4750 words) Report

Structures, Materials &Fire

Site condition and constraints play a significant role for the whole construction process and safety of the buildings and their safety as in accordance with the building standards and all their structural designs.... ite condition and constraints play a significant role for the whole construction process and safety of the buildings and their safety as in accordance with the building standards and all their structural designs.... educe the potential risk to the environment and the buildings through their safe use as in accordance with the approved building laws and regulations in safe manner, and ...
23 Pages (5750 words) Coursework

Steel and Concrete Construction Frames

"steel and concrete Construction Frames" paper compares and contrasts steel and concrete frame construction as well as their structural design in normal and fire conditions.... Frame construction of both steel and concrete is the ideal solution that provides a structure with a flexible layout of the floor that is open as well as external elevations for continuous cladding and glazing.... The steel frame is a building technique that has a skeleton frame of horizontal I-beams and vertical steel columns as illustrated by the American Institute of steel Construction (2001)....
20 Pages (5000 words) Term Paper

Characteristics and Properties of Construction Materials

The higher density and mass of concrete-framed buildings and structures make it serve appropriately when it comes to insulation.... A building or structure with concrete frame construction has the capability of retaining heat as well as cold in comparison to buildings and structures with wood-framed construction.... Another advantage that is associated with the use of timber-framed construction is that more accurate edges and corners can easily be achieved as a result of the factory-built aspect....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Fire Resistant Design High Rise Building

ulti-storey Steel-framed buildings should have beams which if not protected unprotected should withstand 30 and 60 minutes fire resistance.... Concrete- framed buildings are have enhanced strength, ductility and stiffness in terms of their columns and beams this is because they do not easily buckle, erode and have high fire resistance.... teel Building The building selected in this case study is T- Mobile headquarters' which was originally a concrete framed building but was changed to steel....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us