StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Analysis and Critique of Literature Review - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
Analysis and Critique of Literature Review [University] [Instructor Name] Analysis and Critique of Literature Review Research Problem The following analysis and critique is regarding the impact of decision making in organizational performance…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Analysis and Critique of Literature Review
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis and Critique of Literature Review"

Download file to see previous pages

The effectiveness of the process of decision making is highly important for the overall performance of an organization therefore it is of utmost importance to evaluate the factors that influence the effectiveness of the process of decision making. Theoretical Foundation From the outlook of the article, theoretical foundation is clearly apparent. It can be said that the article is based on the concepts of organizational behavior as set by the pioneers on the subject such as Porter and Mintzberg.

The author quotes the theories presented by such pioneers throughout the article. According to the author, the decision making process can be classified into three major types which are; fluid, constricted and sporadic, and the author bases this conclusion on a research conducted in 1986 in which 150 decision making processes in British organizations were examined. The author further provides references to a number of other research works conducted by different authors who classify decision making processes in accordance with their researches.

Relevance of Literature to the Research Question The literature used in this article was mostly the theoretical foundations of the research question under consideration and references to other research works conducted related to the research question. The author has included references to numerous authors who have presented their work on any aspect of the strategic decision making. . The efficient use of literature increases the concreteness of the content of the article. Therefore it can be inferred that the literature used in this article is relevant to the research question.

Synthesis of Literature There is no doubt in the fact that the article provides extensive information regarding the subject and the authenticity of the information provided can be ensured from the references made by the author in this article, however, the length of the article affects the synthesis of the literature. It is not being denied that the facts provided in the article are complete, but in the presence of so many facts and much information, it becomes difficult to ensure the logical sequencing of the information.

The synthesis of literature in this article is done quite convincingly by the author but due to the length of the article, it can be said that the article derails from its main theme at times. Instead of keeping the article concise and ensuring conformity with the main theme, the author provides extensive information regarding the views of other authors on the topic and the research work conducted. It cannot be said that the literature was not synthesized clearly but the synthesis of the literature could have been better had the author given this article the attribute of conciseness.

Discussion The article provides a comprehensive insight on the research question and the literature used in the article is highly relevant to the topic as well. The author has made use of a great number of sources and this is the factor that increases the overall credibility of the article. The sources used are for both the main theme of the article and the subproblems identified in the article. The sources used are relevant to both the main

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Analysis and Critique of Literature Review Article”, n.d.)
Analysis and Critique of Literature Review Article. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1441864-m4a2
(Analysis and Critique of Literature Review Article)
Analysis and Critique of Literature Review Article. https://studentshare.org/business/1441864-m4a2.
“Analysis and Critique of Literature Review Article”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1441864-m4a2.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis and Critique of Literature Review

Dynamics of Decision Power in the Localization Process

At the outset it is worth beginning the article critique to begin with a very wise (and humorous) quote from the genius Lewis Carroll in his very famous work "Alice in the Wonderland" to illustrate the difficulty faced by authors of large pieces of work in keeping their work in context and relevant while at the same time being able to estimate their own direction and stance in relation to the research. … Struggling with the same issues of direction and context this article, "Dynamics of decision power in the localization process: comparative case studies of China-Western IJV's" reviews the International Human Resources Management issues and how they have impacted on the transfer of HRM facilities by Multinational Corporations ....
16 Pages (4000 words) Book Report/Review

Traditional Chinese Medicine Article Critique

  Struggling with the same issues of direction and context this article aims to review the “effectiveness of a clinical treatment program with traditional Chinese medicine for migraine and tension-type headache” and this research is stated at the outset to culminate into a finding that hospital treatment of TCM has caused “long lasting” improvements to the majority of patients.... nbsp;The aim of this critique thus becomes to explore the strength of the topic in terms of the given methodology and results....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

BOOK REVIEW : IAN KERSHAW - THE END (HITLERS GERMANY 1944-1945)

There were also attempts to be very detailed with character analysis and actual description of events including warfront reports and this gave the book a lot of mental pictorial background.... 2011, ‘The End: Hitlers Germany, 1944-45 by Ian Kershaw – review' The Observer [Online] http://www.... k/world/2011/aug/21/the-end-ian-kershaw-review [April 19, 2012]... For instance the attempt by the author to take the subject of the World War II from a different perspective from what has already existed in literature was a step in the right direction....
2 Pages (500 words) Literature review

Healthcare Providers Intentions to Engage in an Approach to Shared Decision-Making by Legare

More importantly, the abstract details the experimental controls, key influences, barriers of research, type of data used, type of analysis as well as the methodology used.... The research objective is clearly defined by establishing the two main items under analysis, the intentions, and the factors behind the intentions of the health workers....
15 Pages (3750 words) Literature review

Journal Article Critique

iscussionIn order to prove theoretical part of proposed hypothesis, the article provides extensive literature review refuting or confirming the statements of other researchers.... White middle-class privileges should be comprehended and noted during therapy since their realization is prone to improve the effectiveness of Journal Article critique Psychology Cover page Mental health counselors do not always pay sufficient attention to the social privileges that cause significant effect on persons lifestyle and actions....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

How Sustainability Strategies Can Be Measured

As a generalised approach, the literature review was performed with an emphasis on addressing the research questions outlined in the first chapter of the study.... This was largely done by focusing on literature works that seek to set a theoretical underpinning to the concepts that… Yet as a critical literature review, the review summarises the main ideas from the articles used, and critiques these articles for their limitations and cases of bias in reporting, where necessary. The theme of sustainability was reviewed to focus on what companies across the globe can do to attain sustainability and the important role that sustainability plays for them in their daily corporate management tasks....
14 Pages (3500 words) Literature review

Research Critique: Esmond, Butler, and McCormack

The purpose of this review "Research Critique: Esmond, Butler, and McCormack" is to analyze the research by Esmond, Butler, and McCormack conducted in 2006.... 55), was compliant with the standard protocols, as “studies that involve testing or observation of people must be authorized by an institutional review board” (Orentlicher, 2005, p....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review

Do Children in Full-day Kindergartens Learn More than Half-day Kindergartens

This literature review "Do Children in Full-day Kindergartens Learn More than Half-day Kindergartens" discusses the learning advantages offered by the full-day learning mode for kindergarten scholars against the alternative half-day learning mode.... Upon further review of the introduction, the research hypotheses (which are also not clearly outlined) provide a hint into the fact that the research investigated the literacy score benefits that emerge from the adoption of the FDK system....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us